Discussion Overview
The discussion centers on the mass transfer between neutron stars in a binary system, specifically addressing how the receiving star can increase its spin rate despite gaining mass, which typically would slow a spinning object due to conservation of momentum. Participants explore the dynamics of angular momentum and the effects of falling matter on the neutron star's rotation.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Technical explanation
- Conceptual clarification
- Debate/contested
Main Points Raised
- One participant questions how a neutron star can increase its spin rate when it receives mass, suggesting that conservation of momentum would imply a slowing effect.
- Another participant proposes that the matter falls spirally and at high velocity, contributing significant momentum perpendicular to the neutron star's radius.
- A different viewpoint emphasizes the conservation of overall angular momentum in the system, noting that there are multiple sources of angular momentum, including the individual spins of the stars and their orbital motion.
- One participant introduces the ice-skater analogy to illustrate how a decrease in effective radius can lead to an increase in angular speed, prompting further inquiry into the effects of added mass on a neutron star's radius.
- Another participant expresses surprise at the implications of mass addition on the neutron star's radius, indicating a lack of prior knowledge on the topic.
- A later reply acknowledges the importance of considering the entire system's angular momentum and suggests that the neutron star's radius likely decreases with added mass, which could facilitate an increase in spin rate.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express varying levels of understanding and assumptions about the effects of mass transfer and angular momentum, with no consensus reached on the specific mechanisms involved. The discussion remains exploratory with multiple competing views.
Contextual Notes
Participants reference the complexities of angular momentum conservation and the behavior of neutron stars under mass addition, but do not resolve the specific effects on radius or spin rate, leaving these aspects open to interpretation.