Mastering Physics Help, Conservation of Momentum

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The problem involves the conservation of momentum in a nuclear decay scenario, specifically focusing on a 238U nucleus decaying into an alpha particle and a thorium nucleus. The original poster seeks to determine the speed and direction of the thorium nucleus after the decay.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Assumption checking, Mathematical reasoning

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the application of conservation of momentum in both x and y components, questioning the initial setup and calculations. There are attempts to resolve discrepancies in velocity calculations and the interpretation of momentum as a vector.

Discussion Status

The discussion has evolved with participants providing insights into the correct application of momentum conservation principles. Some have identified errors in the original calculations and have worked through revisions, leading to a successful determination of the thorium nucleus's speed and direction.

Contextual Notes

Participants express concerns about the feedback from the Mastering Physics platform, indicating a lack of guidance on errors. There is a sense of urgency due to limited attempts remaining for submission.

theoblivin8r
Messages
9
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


A 238U nucleus is moving in the x direction at 4.5*10^5 m/s when it decays into an alpha particle 4He and a 234Th nucleus.

1.) If the alpha particle moves off at 34degrees above the x-axis with a speed of 2.0*10^7 m/s, what is the speed of the thorium nucleus?

2.)What is the direction of the motion of the thorium nucleus?

Homework Equations


I know that momentum is conserved since this is a totally inelastic collision in reverse.
M1(V1)+M2(V2)=(M1+M2)VFinal

The Attempt at a Solution


1.)Im using the atomic numbers for the masses.

238(4.5*10^5)=4(2.0*10^7m/s)+234(V2)
Solving for V2 I got the answer 1.158*10^5 or 1.2*10^5. Mastering physics says this is wrong and nothing else. I believe I might have the wrong formula or something.

2.) I have no ideo how to start this part of the problem. Any help/tips would be greatly appreciated
 
Physics news on Phys.org
theoblivin8r said:
238(4.5*10^5)=4(2.0*10^7m/s)+234(V2)
Solving for V2 I got the answer 1.158*10^5 or 1.2*10^5. Mastering physics says this is wrong and nothing else. I believe I might have the wrong formula or something.
Since momentum is a vector, apply conservation of momentum to each component (x and y) separately.
 
Doc Al said:
Since momentum is a vector, apply conservation of momentum to each component (x and y) separately.

Okay, I understand that I need to look at the conservation of momentum for both the x and y directions. Here was my next attempt.

M1(V1x)+M2(V2x)=(M1+M2)Vfinal(x)
M1(V1y)+M2(V2y)=(M1+M2)Vfinal(y)

Using the angle 34 as given I calculated the initial velocities of the 4He particle.
2.0*10^7(sin34)=V1x=1.12*10^7
2.0*10^7(cos34)=V2y=1.66*10^7

I substituted those values into the equations above again using the atomic number as the masses.

4(1.12*10^7m/s)+234(V2x)=238(4.5*10^5m/s) Solving for V2x I got 2.66*10^5
4(1.66*10^7m/s)+234(V2y)=238(4.5*10^5m/s) Solving for V2y I got 1.74*10^5

Next I used the Pythagorean Theorem to calculate the final velocity using the x and y components. (2.66*10^5)^2+(1.74*10^5)^2=Vfinal^2
Solving for Vfinal I got 3.18*10^5

This is still wrong according to mastering physics and I received no feedback from the program on how it was wrong. Any help again would be greatly appreciated.
 
theoblivin8r said:
M1(V1x)+M2(V2x)=(M1+M2)Vfinal(x)
M1(V1y)+M2(V2y)=(M1+M2)Vfinal(y)

Using the angle 34 as given I calculated the initial velocities of the 4He particle.
2.0*10^7(sin34)=V1x=1.12*10^7
2.0*10^7(cos34)=V2y=1.66*10^7

4(1.12*10^7m/s)+234(V2x)=238(4.5*10^5m/s) Solving for V2x I got 2.66*10^5
4(1.66*10^7m/s)+234(V2y)=238(4.5*10^5m/s) Solving for V2y I got 1.74*10^5

If my math doesn't fail me velocity in x direction should be vcos34 and vsin34 for y direction.
Initially the particle is moving in the x direction so second equation is wrong the particle has no velocity in the y direction.
 
semc said:
If my math doesn't fail me velocity in x direction should be vcos34 and vsin34 for y direction.
Initially the particle is moving in the x direction so second equation is wrong the particle has no velocity in the y direction.

Okay, this makes sense if you are talking about the 238U particle. I see my simple error in calculating the x-velocity. Here was my next attempt.

V1x=2.0*10^7(cos34)=1.66*10^7m/s
V1y=2.0*10^7(sin34)=1.12*10^7m/s

Since there is no velocity in the y direction for the initial particle I revised my formula.

M1(V1y)+M2(V2y)=(M1+M2)VFinal(y)
M1(V1y)+M2(V2y)=0
M1(V1y)=-M2(V2y)

4(1.12*10^7m/s)=-234(V2y) Solving for V2y I got -1.91*10^5m/s. This negative sign indicates the particle is moving in the negative y direction.

So again using the Pythagorean Theorem I calculated the final velocity of the 234Th particle.

(2.66*10^5m/s)^2+(-1.91*10^5)^2=(V2Final)^2 Solving for V2Final I got 3.30*10^5m/s.

I submitted it into Mastering Physics and again it was wrong with no feedback. I'm getting a little concerned because I only have one more attempt to get the answer right. Again any help/tips will be greatly appreciated.
 
By the way I have to go to work so I'll check back in around 6 hours. Thanks again.
 
Dude, work it out again i see velocity in x direction 2.66 which is the same in the previous post.
 
semc said:
Dude, work it out again i see velocity in x direction 2.66 which is the same in the previous post.

Sorry, In my rush to complete the problem I got ahead of myself and forgot to correct my previous mistake.

Well I fixed my error and found the new V1x and used it to calculate the V2y. Then I used the Pythagorean Theorem and found a velocity of 2.6*10^5 and it was correct.

Now onto the second part of the question.

2.) What is the direction of the motion of the thorium nucleus?

This part was simple. I drew a right triangle and placed the velocities on their corresponding sides. I used sin(theta)=(-1.9*10^5m/s)/(2.6*10^5m/s) and took the inverse sin of that answer to get a angle of 47 degrees which was correct.

Thanks for the help people.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
4K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
3K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
7K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • · Replies 17 ·
Replies
17
Views
6K
Replies
16
Views
5K