Movies for hardcore sci-fi geeks

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ivan Seeking
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Movies Sci-fi
AI Thread Summary
The discussion highlights several notable independent science fiction films, with a particular focus on "Primer," a low-budget film that explores complex themes of time travel and causality. Despite its intricate plot, which some find confusing, it has garnered a cult following and critical acclaim, including the Grand Jury Prize at Sundance. Other films mentioned include "Metropolis," "Solaris," "Brazil," "The Man from Earth," and "A Scanner Darkly," with varying opinions on their narrative depth and adaptation quality. The conversation also touches on the merits of character-driven storytelling, as seen in "Firefly," and critiques the reliance on special effects in modern cinema, advocating for narratives that prioritize strong writing and conceptual originality. The participants express a preference for science fiction that adheres to realistic scientific principles, contrasting it with fantasy elements that can detract from the genre's integrity. Overall, the thread emphasizes the value of thoughtful storytelling in science fiction, regardless of budget or mainstream success.
  • #551
new6ton said:
I haven't watched yet

1. The Gate
2. In the Mouth of Madness
3. The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe

Thanks. Will start looking for them. More guys!

By the way. The language used for Ghostbusters 2016 is "Barrier". Not "Gateway". I think there is a distinction between Barrier and Gateway? Gateway is more physical. Barrier more subtle and natural. So what other sci-fi flicks with ideas about Barrier?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #552
new6ton said:
I think there is a distinction between Barrier and Gateway?
Certainly. They are polar opposites.

A gateway provides access.
A barrier prevents access.

Now, a gateway can have a barrier - such as a gate. So, in the 2016 GB, they're talking about the barrier preventing the greeblies from passing through the gateway.
 
  • Like
Likes new6ton
  • #553
Anything on Terry Pratchett's Discworld. I thought Going Postal was quite well done ; their depiction of
Adora Belle as a Goth with S&M overtones
was brilliant and apropos IMHO (something I missed in reading the novel, if it was even there in the first place).
 
Last edited:
  • #554
hmmm27 said:
Anything on Terry Pratchett's Discworld.
?
Is this a movie?

Trying to tie your post to the thread topic...
 
  • #555
DaveC426913 said:
Trying to tie your post to the thread topic...

An internally consistent(ish) fictional science framework ; alternative to deciding which handwavium elements to ignore in a future "real world". (Embedded link added to previous post, for clarification).
 
  • #556
DaveC426913 said:
Certainly. They are polar opposites.

A gateway provides access.
A barrier prevents access.

Now, a gateway can have a barrier - such as a gate. So, in the 2016 GB, they're talking about the barrier preventing the greeblies from passing through the gateway.

How about the atmosphere of the planet. Do you call it a barrier (or gateway) against very strong UV rays or how about the magnetic field that enclose the planet that protects it from cosmic rays, is it a barrier or gateway?

In this context. Barrier means it is all around us, but barrier is there to allow major filtering. It's better to use than saying "The atmosphere of the planet serves as gateway to powerful UV rays". Or the "magnetic field of Earth serves as gateway to cosmic rays". Are there people using such language?

So when I said I wanted movies about Barriers. I guess it is about something that protects from what is all around us. Not about Stargate which is a one place gateway.
 
  • #557
DaveC426913 said:
Certainly. They are polar opposites.

A gateway provides access.
A barrier prevents access.

Now, a gateway can have a barrier - such as a gate. So, in the 2016 GB, they're talking about the barrier preventing the greeblies from passing through the gateway.

I want to know whether to use the language of gateway or barrier when presenting the following to physicists someday for example (Today is Holloween day, so let me share this in this special day).

etheric.jpg
In our body, and when we got the right quantum interpretation. It will be known that there are extensions (to so called astral plane) that is directly connected to our awareness in addition to neurons.

For your Halloween adventures. Try to meet people with the shield (barrier? not gateway, right?) broken. You would see he is like possessed by entities from the astral planes. There is a tested method in the world now that can seal the crack barrier. Result is instant relief from the intrusion from the astral plane. Note all drug addicts who commit very violent crimes is due to the shield (barrier) damaged resulting in intrusion from astral entities that obssessed them to do crimes. This is also present in many patients in mental institutions. So just the science of this can change society for the better and affect millions and millions of lives.

I want to watch movies with themes about barriers just to think about it. Just to give me ideas what language when one will present it to Michio Kaku or the world's top physicists.
 
  • #558
Recently saw a movie that I really enjoyed. It's not an action packed one, and not much explicit sci-fi, but still I think it fits. Really made me think. "Welcome the stranger" https://www.imdb.com/title/tt5716280/

Also saw "Under the skin". A slow burner, but again one that made me think, though this time more in the sense of putting myself in her shoes kinda. Really intrigued me. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1441395/
 
  • #559
I recently watched what may come to be an important milestone in Sci Fi. Don't get excited yet since it is by no means a "pulse-pounder". It is the 2017 film, The Beyond .

I liked this movie rather a lot while at the same time understanding it's low rating and probably low appeal as far as numbers are concerned. It's not visceral. It's intellectual. I've loved Sci Fi since I was a child but over time I came to realize that much of it is just Cowboys and Indians in Space and while it often pays homage to Science and Technology it is most often rather fearful of them, which is probably a reflection of how the unscientific, the vast majority of the population, view Science and Technology. It may well play a part in the current suspicion, distrust and skepticism that gives us Flat Earthers and Moon Landing Denial, etc etc etc.

Some of the "Science" in The Beyond is.. well... silly but it's not a deal breaker to the main thrust of the concept and some of those can keep your thoughts and imagination highly stimulated especially if you're at all intrigued by Kurzweil's "singularity".

Some of the plot mechanics are silly too unless you are able to suspend disbelief when presented with many so-called Sci Fi plots that actually imagine the current state of humanity has a snowball's chance in Hell of defending against a civilization that can travel interstellar distances let alone routinely command energies equivalent to orders of magnitude greater than our Sun over it's entire lifetime, but then quite a few movies not only seem to imagine this possible and reasonable but hold it up to be somehow heroic. Because of this fact, I can forgive The Beyond, especially in the service of the Big Picture that finally get's presented with a positive message and displays trust in Science and Technology while doing it.

Since fearful, suspicious Sci Fi and Technology has also led to the TLDR generation, here's the skinny. If you loved "Aliens" AND hated "Star Trek: The Next Generation" or even preferred "Star Wars" to "Star Trek"this probably isn't your "cuppa". If you liked "Contact" it very well might be. It's not quite as well done as the recent "Arrival" (not the Charlie Sheen movie) but it is broader and equally high minded with a far greater reach. It could keep you thinking about anyone of a number of points for a very long time.

The way it addresses human-technology singularity is extremely thought provoking and quite possibly rather prescient.
 
  • #560
I just realized there's a gap in my reading here. I did finally get to see a few seasons of "Expanse" and it's really quite good. I also recently viewed High Life and I concur. It's good and the blend mention is accurate and who wouldn't love a blend of Solaris and Silent Running?
 
  • #561
enorbet said:
I recently watched what may come to be an important milestone in Sci Fi. Don't get excited yet since it is by no means a "pulse-pounder". It is the 2017 film, The Beyond .

I liked this movie rather a lot while at the same time understanding it's low rating and probably low appeal as far as numbers are concerned. It's not visceral. It's intellectual. I've loved Sci Fi since I was a child but over time I came to realize that much of it is just Cowboys and Indians in Space and while it often pays homage to Science and Technology it is most often rather fearful of them, which is probably a reflection of how the unscientific, the vast majority of the population, view Science and Technology. It may well play a part in the current suspicion, distrust and skepticism that gives us Flat Earthers and Moon Landing Denial, etc etc etc.

Some of the "Science" in The Beyond is.. well... silly but it's not a deal breaker to the main thrust of the concept and some of those can keep your thoughts and imagination highly stimulated especially if you're at all intrigued by Kurzweil's "singularity".

Some of the plot mechanics are silly too unless you are able to suspend disbelief when presented with many so-called Sci Fi plots that actually imagine the current state of humanity has a snowball's chance in Hell of defending against a civilization that can travel interstellar distances let alone routinely command energies equivalent to orders of magnitude greater than our Sun over it's entire lifetime, but then quite a few movies not only seem to imagine this possible and reasonable but hold it up to be somehow heroic. Because of this fact, I can forgive The Beyond, especially in the service of the Big Picture that finally get's presented with a positive message and displays trust in Science and Technology while doing it.

Since fearful, suspicious Sci Fi and Technology has also led to the TLDR generation, here's the skinny. If you loved "Aliens" AND hated "Star Trek: The Next Generation" or even preferred "Star Wars" to "Star Trek"this probably isn't your "cuppa". If you liked "Contact" it very well might be. It's not quite as well done as the recent "Arrival" (not the Charlie Sheen movie) but it is broader and equally high minded with a far greater reach. It could keep you thinking about anyone of a number of points for a very long time.

The way it addresses human-technology singularity is extremely thought provoking and quite possibly rather prescient.

Your suggestion "The Beyond" looks cool. I acquired it and will watch it tonight.

More like it please. Movies that can make you think of the future and possible technological marvels especially regarding the brain and its extensions.
 
  • #562
new6ton said:
Your suggestion "The Beyond" looks cool. I acquired it and will watch it tonight.

More like it please. Movies that can make you think of the future and possible technological marvels especially regarding the brain and its extensions.
This is the purview of speculative fiction - of which science fiction is a subset.
You will find no end of material about how technology affects mind and culture in the field of speculative fiction.
But due to the fact that it's more conceptual and more subtle, it lends itself better to the written word than the screen, where abstract ideas can be fleshed out in exposition, rather than in action.
There are some great authors that specialize in this field.
 
  • #563
I don't know if it's been mentioned but this was a favorite of mine - Timerider
Motorcycle racer Lyle Swann (Fred Ward) is cruising through the Mexican desert when he accidentally stumbles into a time-travel experiment and finds himself transported back to the Old West of the 1870s. There he encounters an attractive local woman (Belinda Bauer) and a gang of criminals led by Porter Reese (Peter Coyote). Lyle's motorized bike is impressive in the past -- until it runs out of gas. Now Lyle must rely on his wits to take care of business and return to his own time.
 
  • #564
Incidentally for those of us who enjoy positive message Sci Fi suitable for whole family viewing Disney's Tomorrowland is a decent experience. It poses a great riddle for kids (and maybe some adults) to ponder -
Brad Bird (writer) said:
You have two pets
One is Darkness and Doom
The other is Brightness and Hope
Which one survives and flourishes?

Some of the Science is typically Disney child-like but it displays a trust in Science and Technology and accepts and champions a responsibility in people as well as displaying the joy and empowerment of grasping "how things work" that is fundamental to all enthralled with Science. Your kids, especially the girls, will love it and rightfully so.
 
  • #565
Here is a Science mag news interview of Naren Shankar, showrunner of "The Expanse".
Covers his physics background, motivations, and how he got into showbiz.

New show in about a week.
 
  • #566
I can't see that Tom Cruise's Oblivion has been mentioned (the noise made by the sentinel bots is terrific), but it's a solid little sci-fi mystery, as is his Edge of Tomorrow.
 
  • Like
Likes BWV
  • #567
I'm rather impressed with a new (2019) gem from the UK which may be rather unfortunately titled Cosmos as there is bound to be some confusion and blurring over that title, but it is well worth seeking unless you don't enjoy the geekier films of the genre. It starts very slowly and takes a long time to begin accelerating and does have a few crude plot devices to bring the visceral to the cerebral, but once it gets the base revealed it rapidly becomes a true "mind blower". Even some of the plot devices will have you imagining how seemingly minor random events in real life could utterly alter how the plot unfolds on perhaps THE most compelling question anyone interested in Science-driven imagination can pose, and how the answer may one day unfold.
 
  • Like
Likes BillTre
  • #568
On a lesser note I binge watched the new season of The Expanse and while the cast and production are as compelling as ever, I found it mildly disappointing but that is probably due to the "tough act to follow" syndrome. Not every writing team or story can conclude a brilliant story as perfectly as The Sopranos or Six Feet Under. It's still worth watching and does retain some possibility of greater things to follow, but for me, this season was a bit of a lull. Hopefully it's just the "eye of the hurricane".
 
  • #569
enorbet said:
On a lesser note I binge watched the new season of The Expanse and while the cast and production are as compelling as ever, I found it mildly disappointing but that is probably due to the "tough act to follow" syndrome. Not every writing team or story can conclude a brilliant story as perfectly as The Sopranos or Six Feet Under. It's still worth watching and does retain some possibility of greater things to follow, but for me, this season was a bit of a lull. Hopefully it's just the "eye of the hurricane".
FWIW it seemed to me that the book series ran out of ideas and steam
 
  • #571
One I've been watching lately that is okay, is Travelers, on Netflix. It isn't great but it is keeping my attention for now.

Hoping to see more episodes of The Black Mirror soon.

I haven't seen a lot of hard sci-fi recently. I enjoyed the series Jericho, which sort of qualifies as sci-fi. I definitely enjoyed Away.

Certainly fantasy and not sci-fi, I really enjoyed The OA. At times it got silly but I thought it was very creative. And for a wonderfully satirical and slap-stick look at the afterlife while getting an overview of classical philosophy and ethics, The Good Place cracks me up.
 
  • Like
Likes BillTre

Similar threads

Back
Top