My 'why' questions -- Wanting to learn Chemistry to figure out my why questions

  • Thread starter Thread starter Gifovaco
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Chemistry
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around an individual's desire to learn chemistry to understand various phenomena related to materials and reactions, including solidification times, the behavior of adhesives, and the properties of substances like hot sauce. The scope includes self-teaching challenges, foundational knowledge in chemistry, and the importance of safety and mentorship in experimental chemistry.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Homework-related

Main Points Raised

  • The original poster expresses a desire to understand the underlying reasons for material behaviors and chemical reactions, emphasizing a need for foundational knowledge in chemistry.
  • Some participants suggest that self-teaching chemistry is challenging due to its experimental nature and recommend pursuing a formal degree instead.
  • There is a discussion about the importance of safety in chemistry, with concerns raised about the risks of self-teaching without proper guidance and equipment.
  • Participants recommend specific textbooks and resources to build theoretical knowledge, highlighting the difficulty of knowing what to study without a mentor.
  • One participant cautions that the original poster's ambitions may be overly ambitious, suggesting a need for more general knowledge before delving into complex topics like quantum chemistry.
  • The original poster acknowledges the challenges and expresses gratitude for the recommendations, indicating a willingness to engage with the material at a foundational level.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree on the challenges of self-teaching chemistry and the importance of foundational knowledge. However, there are differing opinions on the feasibility of self-teaching versus pursuing formal education, and the level of ambition expressed by the original poster is met with caution by some participants.

Contextual Notes

Limitations include the original poster's lack of experience in chemistry, the potential risks associated with self-teaching, and the need for guidance in selecting appropriate study materials and understanding complex concepts.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be useful for individuals interested in self-learning chemistry, those considering formal education in the subject, and anyone curious about the practical applications of chemistry in everyday materials and reactions.

Gifovaco
Messages
17
Reaction score
26
TL;DR
Because it surrounds me.....
OK, My 1st post. I am going to learn chemistry because:
I know electro-mechanical engineering, but I don't know why 'stuff' behaves like it does.
Why my epoxy has different solidification times? Why can I not burst it with a specific EM spectrum to react it immediately?
Why my garage door genie button turned to mush?
Why Heat shrink works?
I should be able to design an adhesive that maximizes all Bulk, Young and Shear modulus, but stable at what temp?
Why is hot sauce Hot?
What makes energetic materials...energetic

Well, you get the idea. I want to start at the beginning, be able to balance a chem equation, understand 3d molecule structure and what the xxx it means? I am so new, but so long in wishing I knew. I am in no hurry, this is my deal for me. Of course I have used various acids to etch metals, aqua regia for gold, but I want to be able to design and predict outcomes. I don't like being told "mix this that and the other thing and it works" I want to understand it to the point I can refine and perfect the processes.

My start, notice I didn't challenge Heisenberg on where an electron is located by asking 'When' it is located, we'll do that later....lol
I look forward to a long, slow, enlightening process...more heads make the thinking easier....
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
Chemistry is difficult to self-teach since it's highly experimental. I'd suggest pursuing a degree if it's feasible, because self-teaching is not nearly as easy as many think.
 
Last edited:
  • Informative
Likes   Reactions: symbolipoint
:welcome:
Gifovaco said:
TL;DR Summary: Because it surrounds me.....

Why is hot sauce Hot?
That's the easy one!

Ingredient called capsaicin. It is very good at getting the attention of nerves!

Cheers,
Tom
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: pinball1970 and BillTre
Mayhem said:
Chemistry is difficult to self-teach since it's highly experimental. I'd suggest pursuing a degree if it's feasible, because self-teaching is not nearly as easy as many think.
Thanks, I get that. As I learned electricity formally, I started with Ohm's law so before 'hooking' things up, I knew what to expect. At my point now I want to be able read/write chem equations before I go past baking soda and vinegar acid /base anything. Maybe a worthwhile beginners tutorial in theory to learn and test myself before I start mixing up stuff? Simple nomenclature 'feels' right. Then maybe I can ask a descriptive question. So any tutorial would be appreciated. tkx, Vaco
 
Physics to study may help you with most of your questions, extensively. Physics alone will not help enough with all your questions. Chemistry alone will not help with all your questions. Undergraduate degree or more in Physics might be what will give you what you want; and include AT LEAST three years of undergraduate Chemistry courses as if for that major field.
 
Gifovaco said:
Thanks, I get that. As I learned electricity formally, I started with Ohm's law so before 'hooking' things up, I knew what to expect. At my point now I want to be able read/write chem equations before I go past baking soda and vinegar acid /base anything. Maybe a worthwhile beginners tutorial in theory to learn and test myself before I start mixing up stuff? Simple nomenclature 'feels' right. Then maybe I can ask a descriptive question. So any tutorial would be appreciated. tkx, Vaco
You can't safely do any meaningful chemistry without a fumehood (or something with a similar functionality), and sourcing chemicals legally requires a license. Safety is also something which must be taught and reinforced by more experienced chemists. Those are the main problems od self-teaching chemistry.
 
  • Like
  • Informative
Likes   Reactions: symbolipoint and berkeman
Mayhem said:
You can't safely do any meaningful chemistry without a fumehood (or something with a similar functionality), and sourcing chemicals legally requires a license. Safety is also something which must be taught and reinforced by more experienced chemists. Those are the main problems od self-teaching chemistry.
You hit the nail on "that scares me' with your fume hood comment. I worked with mom and pop electro-platers... cyanide... really? and their safety protocol is to be upwind? My common sense told me to leave and wisely so. I suppose 'what' I desire to learn is the 'why' do these molecules do what they do, before I start introducing them to one another. I will not hazard what I do not understand. But now, it feels good to be moving past the "just mix it up and it works' un-easiness. AND also, having experienced mentoring is becoming another 'common sense' inclusion. Thank you, Mayhem....
 
Gifovaco said:
You hit the nail on "that scares me' with your fume hood comment. I worked with mom and pop electro-platers... cyanide... really? and their safety protocol is to be upwind? My common sense told me to leave and wisely so. I suppose 'what' I desire to learn is the 'why' do these molecules do what they do, before I start introducing them to one another. I will not hazard what I do not understand. But now, it feels good to be moving past the "just mix it up and it works' un-easiness. AND also, having experienced mentoring is becoming another 'common sense' inclusion. Thank you, Mayhem....
Read Blackman's Chemistry (last chapters can be skipped). Get extremely comfortable with general lab calculations. Atkin's Physical Chemistry (Quanta, Matter and Change). Read Clayden's Organic Chemistry. Read Housecroft and Sharpe's Inorganic Chemistry. Read If you read and understand these, you will have theoretical knowledge that matches a well-read undergraduate closing in on their graduation.

Thing is, knowing what to read and what to skip, knowing if your understanding is correct, etc. is very hard without a mentor. You'd need to solve countless practice problems.

But those books will form a great deal of the theory you'd encounter as an undergraduate.
 
  • #10
Gifovaco said:
I want to start at the beginning, be able to balance a chem equation, understand 3d molecule structure and what the xxx it means?
You are asking for far too much. The 'plain' chemistry alone is already a really big bite, but you aim to push it till the uncertainty-wrecked areas of quantum chemistry...
I suggest to try to get some more general knowledge first so you could identify the area you wish to focus on for real.
 
  • #11
Rive said:
You are asking for far too much. The 'plain' chemistry alone is already a really big bite, but you aim to push it till the uncertainty-wrecked areas of quantum chemistry...
I suggest to try to get some more general knowledge first so you could identify the area you wish to focus on for real.
You are so correct. My curiosity based on having experience of 'stuff' that works is why is want to fill the gaps. Again correct, I am beginning in a very general area, up the staircase in understanding, I will see to ask of myself what I would not yet know. I am glad you said what you did "uncertainty-wrecked areas of quantum chemistry", I can 'feel' why Planck's constant, and Heisenberg's indeterminacy principle makes sense. I was referred to Allen Blackman's book from a member here. Upon glance, the perfect start. Thank YOU Rive for your direction, I will surely be surprised! Vaco....
 
  • #12
Mayhem said:
Read Blackman's Chemistry (last chapters can be skipped). Get extremely comfortable with general lab calculations. Atkin's Physical Chemistry (Quanta, Matter and Change). Read Clayden's Organic Chemistry. Read Housecroft and Sharpe's Inorganic Chemistry. Read If you read and understand these, you will have theoretical knowledge that matches a well-read undergraduate closing in on their graduation.

Thing is, knowing what to read and what to skip, knowing if your understanding is correct, etc. is very hard without a mentor. You'd need to solve countless practice problems.

But those books will form a great deal of the theory you'd encounter as an undergraduate.
Mayhem, I really thank you for that start, I downloaded the 4th Allen Blackman's and it has already filled gaps....I may not appear here for a while as I integrate your recommendations. Food for a hungry mind....much appreciated, Vaco...
 

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
9K
  • · Replies 22 ·
Replies
22
Views
4K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
7K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
1K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
5K
Replies
1
Views
3K