Neutron decay - is my answer unrealistic?

[jeebs]

Hi,
here's the problem:

"a neutron at rest decays into a proton with a decay energy of 0.78MeV. What is the maximum kinetic energy of the proton left behind?"

here's what I've tried:

In this decay, I assumed that although it's not mentioned, there would be something negatively charged produced to conserve charge. I went with beta decay, so that an electron and an antineutrino would be produced. I assumed that the neutrino was massless and ignored it (my lecturer said it could be ignored).

In the neutron's rest-frame, i said that the proton and electron would have equal and opposite momenta p_p and p_e respectively, ie.

$$\stackrel{\rightarrow}{p_e} = -\stackrel{\rightarrow}{p_p}$$

ie.

$$p_e = p_p = p$$ (magnitudes are equal.)

Also, for conservation of energy, i said that neutron energy E_n = E_p + E_e = (m_p² + p²)^1/2 + (m_e² + p²)^1/2 = m_n since the neutron has no momentum.

(Here I have used the expression E² = p²c² + m²c⁴ in c=1 units).

m_n - (m_p² + p²)^1/2 = (m_e² + p²)^1/2

(m_n - (m_p² + p²)^1/2)² = m_e² + p²

m_n² - 2m_n(m_p² + p²)^1/2 + m_p² + p² = m_e² + p²

m_n² + m_p² - m_e² = 2m_n(m_p² + p²)^1/2

hence

$$p = \sqrt{(\frac{m_n^2 + m_p^2 - m_e^2}{2m_n})^2 - m_p^2 }$$

Using wikipedia's data:
m_p = 938.272 MeV/c^2
m_n = 939.566 MeV/c^2
m_e = 0.510 MeV/c^2

I get p = 1.188 MeV/c

Again, using E² = p²c² + m²c⁴ I get the proton energy E_p = 938.2727521 MeV and when I subtract the rest energy from this to get the kinetic energy, I am left with 7.52x10^-4 MeV.

When I do the same for the electron, I find that E_e is just less than 0.78 MeV.

Is this a reasonable answer? It seems weird to me that the electron should take the vast majority of the energy, especially when I am looking for the maximum PROTON energy?

Thanks.

 

[Astronuc]

That's not weird. The electrons rest mass = ~1/1836 of the proton rest mass, so it receives most of the kinetic energy, while the proton has a lot of 'rest' energy. In the problem, 0.78 MeV means the electron is relativistic.

In reality, the neutrino can take a lot of energy/momentum as well, and in beta decay, there is a continuous spectrum of energy with the most probably energy of the beta being ~ 1/3 of the maximum allowable energy.

 

[quarkmeup]

Hi,

I would like to know more about the beta decay. Could you give me a good reference book to start with? I would like to calculate the electron energy spectrum resulting from a neutron decaying into a proton, electron and anti-electron neutrino. Any idea where to start? Thanks!

 

[Astronuc]

Hi,

I would like to know more about the beta decay. Could you give me a good reference book to start with? I would like to calculate the electron energy spectrum resulting from a neutron decaying into a proton, electron and anti-electron neutrino. Any idea where to start? Thanks!

Data for each beta-emitter has been tabulated.

Here is some general information - http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/Hbase/nuclear/beta2.html
http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/Hbase/nuclear/beta.html#c5

Decay of a neutron
http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/Hbase/particles/proton.html#c4


Some notes
http://www.hep.phys.soton.ac.uk/hepwww/staff/D.Ross/phys3002/beta.pdf

 

[quarkmeup]

Thanks! Do you happen to know where I could find the tabulated energy spectrum for decay electrons in the rest frame of the parent neutron?