Newtons third law, elevator question (free body diagram)

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
2 replies · 4K views
supernova1203
Messages
209
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



An elevator containing 3 passengers(with a mass of 72kg 84 kg and 35 kg) has a mass combined of 1030 kg . The cable attached to the elevator exherts an upward force of 12000 N. But the friction opposing the motion of the elevator is 1400 N.

a) Draw a free body diagram for all the forces acting on the elevator.


Homework Equations


Fg=mg



The Attempt at a Solution



Now since net force is greater for upward motion, we can assume the elevator is going up, since gravity + friction is still less than the upward force exherted, so elevator is going up,
but my question is...in the free body diagram..do i put both friction and force of gravity as a downward force?

Or should i just remove force of gravity and just put force of friction in the freebody diagram as a downward force?

The free body diagram i have in mind is in attachment, and that's what it looks like now...as always you don't need to download attachment to view it.


thanks!
 

Attachments

  • Fbd 1.jpg
    Fbd 1.jpg
    2.2 KB · Views: 893
on Phys.org
supernova1203 said:

Homework Statement



An elevator containing 3 passengers(with a mass of 72kg 84 kg and 35 kg) has a mass combined of 1030 kg . The cable attached to the elevator exherts an upward force of 12000 N. But the friction opposing the motion of the elevator is 1400 N.

a) Draw a free body diagram for all the forces acting on the elevator.


Homework Equations


Fg=mg



The Attempt at a Solution



Now since net force is greater for upward motion, we can assume the elevator is going up, since gravity + friction is still less than the upward force exherted, so elevator is going up,
but my question is...in the free body diagram..do i put both friction and force of gravity as a downward force?

Or should i just remove force of gravity and just put force of friction in the freebody diagram as a downward force?

The free body diagram i have in mind is in attachment, and that's what it looks like now...as always you don't need to download attachment to view it.


thanks!

I believe you should be drawing both "gravity" and friction - down - but only Applied force up.

The net force is the vector sum of the three real forces - but I am not sure it is generally shown on these diagrams.

Also - you can do MUCH better with the arrows. The applied Force vector should be nearly 9 times as long as the friction Force.
How does the weight force compare in size?
 
well this is not the actual diagram, its not to scale, the actual diagram is done in paper, i just sort of did a quick sloppy version to post here