Nuclear fusion (requirements to start fusion)

In summary, the conversation discusses the conditions needed for atoms to fuse and create a fusion reaction, specifically the amount of pressure and heat required. The Lawson criterion is mentioned as a figure of merit for ignition, and it is noted that a self-sustaining fusion reaction requires a combination of density and temperature. The possibility of using high centrifugal pressure to sustain a fusion reaction is also brought up, but it is pointed out that this would require off-scale high temperatures. The purpose of a fusion reaction is also discussed, and it is noted that while the excess heat could be used in turbines, too much heat can also be a problem.
  • #1
831
12
I have a question , hoq much pressure s needed for atoms to start to fuse(hydrogen atoms i guess) let's say we use the same tritium and deuterium and we put them in an environment with pressure how much pressure would it need? could you please say the pressure like in G like in gravitational measurment?
Also I would like to know if pressure alone can start the fusion reaction or does it need pressure and heat but if so then how would that reaftion could ever start because heat comes after the reaction has started and it would sound logically that the pressure comes first the atoms fuse and create heat in the process?

I guess its the "who was first, the egg or chicken" question

let's imagine a centrifuge that spins so fast that at the outr side of the centrifuge such pressure is built up that is sufficient to start fusion, the fusion starts but the centrifuge is surrounded by water that absorbs the heat and turns to steam? would the fusion reaction continue if the centrifuge would continua to spin at the same rate and the pressure would be the same only the heat would never build up like in a typical fusion reaction that would destroy the apparatus?
So the basic questions is is pressure enough or do we need pressure and heat combined to fuse atoms?

Thanks for answering:)
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Crazymechanic said:
I have a question , hoq much pressure s needed for atoms to start to fuse(hydrogen atoms i guess) let's say we use the same tritium and deuterium and we put them in an environment with pressure how much pressure would it need? could you please say the pressure like in G like in gravitational measurment?
Also I would like to know if pressure alone can start the fusion reaction or does it need pressure and heat but if so then how would that reaftion could ever start because heat comes after the reaction has started and it would sound logically that the pressure comes first the atoms fuse and create heat in the process?

I guess its the "who was first, the egg or chicken" question

let's imagine a centrifuge that spins so fast that at the outr side of the centrifuge such pressure is built up that is sufficient to start fusion, the fusion starts but the centrifuge is surrounded by water that absorbs the heat and turns to steam? would the fusion reaction continue if the centrifuge would continua to spin at the same rate and the pressure would be the same only the heat would never build up like in a typical fusion reaction that would destroy the apparatus?
So the basic questions is is pressure enough or do we need pressure and heat combined to fuse atoms?

Thanks for answering:)

Welcome to the PF.

The Lawson criterion is what you are asking about. It uses plasma density, confinement time and temperature as a figure of merit for ignition:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawson_criterion

.
 
  • Like
Likes Toast
  • #3
A glass of water has deuterium and tritium nucleii fusing (a few of them, but they are there), so the question actually has no answer unless you talk about getting enough nucleii to fuse often enough to beat some other rate - which leads you to different criteria like Lawson's.

Heating rates are basically proportional to density squared times a reaction rate that scales very, very steeply with temperature and is negligibly small unless you get into the tens to hundreds of million degree range. That's before you start self-heating, so you have to get there some other way.
 
  • #4
Yes first time , thanks for welcoming:)
So for a fusion reaction to be self sustaining it has to have either
1) huge enough temperature and pressure or just temperature? i guess both are needed right?

But a fusion reaction is achievable under different condition right, like under huge pressure?

Okay so my question is if a huge pressure like huge centrifugal pressure from a very high rpm turbine is applied then would the fusion reaction keep on going even without the extreme heat ?
because imagine that the heat would go away in form of steam from water cooling but to keep the reaction going the pressure would be kept very high so that new and new atoms start to fuse, could someone explain is this possible?and if is would the energy put into keep the pressure be bigger than the energy extracted from the heat of the reaction or not?

I guess i could answer my question myself with numbers and formulas but that aint so easy so could you please give a lil light on this? :)
 
  • #5
A self-sustaining fusion reaction needs density and temperature in some combination - you could write this as pressure and temperature, or pressure and density, but that seems generally pointless as it's conceptually simpler to think of density and temperature, which is what the Wiki link uses (did you read that?).

High pressure generally = high temperature, and high density and off-scale high temperature generally = ridiculously high pressure, so good luck with that centrifuge idea. Self-sustaining fusion schemes are in the tens-of-millions of degree range, as I pointed out and as the Wiki link also shows (did you read that?).
 
  • #6
not that i would think of it as a idea that has a chance for real life more like theoretical interest in things, yes i read the article in wiki.
 
  • #7
Why do you want a fusion reaction?
 
  • #8
It's not so much about what I or we want or can it's more about what is possible, there are some things that you have or can find out practically and some that can be theorized, this is one of them.
I guess the problem about fusion reactions is that they produce too much heat, well ofcourse we want the heat for steam that could be used in turbines, but again too much heat is no good, if not for the heat I think and some calculations show that let's say a 10 m in diametter centrifuge with some 30 000+ rpm could get H atoms dense enough at the outer walls to make them fuse, because centrifugal force acts just the way gravity acts so if we know that gravity and the huge gravitational pressure causes atoms to fuse in center of sun and not only , this should do the trick but again there is this huge heat everywhere which makes everything so bad...
 
  • #9
Crazymechanic said:
It's not so much about what I or we want or can it's more about what is possible, there are some things that you have or can find out practically and some that can be theorized, this is one of them.
I guess the problem about fusion reactions is that they produce too much heat, well ofcourse we want the heat for steam that could be used in turbines, but again too much heat is no good, if not for the heat I think and some calculations show that let's say a 10 m in diametter centrifuge with some 30 000+ rpm could get H atoms dense enough at the outer walls to make them fuse, because centrifugal force acts just the way gravity acts so if we know that gravity and the huge gravitational pressure causes atoms to fuse in center of sun and not only , this should do the trick but again there is this huge heat everywhere which makes everything so bad...

I think you have a lot of very basic misconceptions about all this, perhaps best to start with a basic book about power production and physics - I don't think there is much that a forum thread can do for you.
 
  • #10
Crazymechanic, you need to isolate the plasma from the walls of the containment vessel. The heat requirements are enormous and requires something like magnetic fields to keep the plasma from hitting the walls of the reactor.

Also, there is a difference between pressure and heat. The heat inside the sun occurs because the plasma has collapsed under a great amount of pressure. This generates the heat needed to fuse and also keeps the plasma dense enough for the fusion reactions to continue at a reasonable rate. (It does no good if you have the temperature requirements for fusion but your plasma is only dense enough so that 10 reactions per second occur)

I highly doubt the kind of pressure needed for confinement is capable of being mechanically generated by spinning the reactor around.
 

What is nuclear fusion?

Nuclear fusion is a process in which two or more atomic nuclei combine to form a heavier nucleus. This process releases a tremendous amount of energy.

What is required to start nuclear fusion?

In order to start nuclear fusion, extremely high temperatures and pressures are needed to overcome the repulsive forces between positively charged nuclei. This is usually achieved by using powerful lasers or magnetic fields.

Why is nuclear fusion considered the "holy grail" of energy production?

Nuclear fusion has the potential to provide a virtually limitless source of clean energy. It produces no greenhouse gases or long-lived nuclear waste, making it a sustainable and environmentally friendly source of energy.

What elements are involved in the process of nuclear fusion?

The most commonly used elements in nuclear fusion are deuterium and tritium, which are isotopes of hydrogen. These elements are abundant in seawater and can be extracted in large quantities.

What are the challenges in achieving nuclear fusion?

One of the main challenges in achieving nuclear fusion is confining the extremely hot plasma required for the reaction. Another challenge is sustaining the fusion reaction for a long enough period of time to make it a viable energy source. Additionally, the materials used in the fusion reactor must be able to withstand the extreme temperatures and radiation generated by the reaction.

Suggested for: Nuclear fusion (requirements to start fusion)

Replies
11
Views
1K
Replies
0
Views
236
Replies
6
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
766
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
11
Views
1K
Back
Top