Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Particle Elastic Collision problem

  1. Apr 23, 2006 #1
    I have a problem here. I got "answers", but I don't beleive they are correct and I have no idea where I went wrong.

    The question is... "Determine the speed V_2 (V sub 2) of the larger mass after the collision and Theta 1 and Theta 2.

    mass of smaller particle = m
    mass of larger particle = 2m
    Initial speed of m = 3V_0 (3 v knot)
    Initial speed of 2m= 0
    Final speed of m = 5^(.5)V_0
    Final speed of 2m=V_2 ....??
    Theta1= ?
    Theta2= ?

    This is obviously a conservation of momentum/Kinetic energy problem, with X and Y components of direction. Here is what I have.

    3mV_0=5^(.5)V_0Cos(theta1)+(2m)2^(.5)V_0Cos(theta2 )--->Conservation of momentum in the x direction(COMX)

    0=5^(.5)mV_0Sin(theta1)-2*2^(.5)mV_0Sin(theta2)--->Conservation of momentum in the y direction(COMY)

    .5*m(3V_0)^2=(m(5^(.5*V_0)^2)*(.5)+m(V_2final)^2--->Conservation of Kenetic ENergy(COKE)
    (COKE) goes down to (2^(.5))*(V_0)
    (COMY) goes to 0=5^(.5)*Sin(theta1)-2*2^(.5)*Sin(theta2)
    (COMX) goes to 3=5^(.5)Cos(theta1)+2*2^(.5)*Cos(theta2)

    Any mistakes ? Any suggestions? Thanks for looking, and sorry I am not very well schooled in how to write equations on the computer. PS: theta1 will be angle of m (from the horizontal) and theta2 will be angle of 2m(from the horizontal)

    View Public Profile
    Send a private message to M98Ranger
    Find More Posts by M98Ranger
    Add M98Ranger to Your Buddy List
  2. jcsd
  3. Apr 23, 2006 #2


    User Avatar
    Homework Helper

    p_x : m 3v_0 = m sqrt(5)v_0 cos(theta1) + 2m ***v_2***cos(theta2)
    . . . . how did you figure out immediately that v_2 = sqrt(2) v_0 ?

    (It might be easier to calculate this in the "center-of-mass" reference frame,
    (the bee in c.o.m. frame sees the total momentum = 0 ; bee has v_x = v_0).
  4. Apr 23, 2006 #3
    masses cancel out and 2*m*(.5) cancels out to give the following
    (((3Vi)^2)/2)=(.5*(sqrt5Vi)^2)+Velocity^2[<---velocity for mass 2]
    3vi^2=9vi^2,---->sqrt5Vi^2=5Vi^2, so---> Taking .5*sqrt5Vi^2 to the other side
    ((9Vi^2)\2)-((5Vi^2)\2)=(Velocity final for mass 2)^2---> Subtracting Vi from Vi
    then 4/2*Vi^2=(Velocity final for mass 2)^2---> Sqrt'ing whole equation
    Then sqrt2*Vi=(Velocity final for mass 2)
    Last edited: Apr 23, 2006
  5. Apr 23, 2006 #4


    User Avatar
    Homework Helper

    For a Perfectly Elastic collision, like yours,
    the relative velocity after collision to be opposite the rel.velocity before.
    . . . ( but 3 v_0 - 0 =/= - sqrt(5) v_0 - sqrt(2) v_0 ~ 3.6 v_0 ) . . .
    in the center-of-mass reference frame.
    v_1fy = -2 v_2fy . . . . . and . . . . v_1fx = - 2 ( v_2fx ) .
    so, we can add the velocity triangles and we find that the v_fx = 0 !

    This leads to (in lab frame) : v_1fy = +/- 2 v_0 , v_1fx = - v_0 ;
    so tan(theta1) = +/- 2 (it is symmetric across the x-axis).
Share this great discussion with others via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook