The discussion centers around opinions on the Men's Journal list of the top 50 guy movies, with participants expressing strong preferences for classic films like "The Great Escape" and "The Magnificent Seven," which they believe should rank higher. Many contributors argue against the inclusion of certain films, such as "Caddyshack" and "The Three Stooges," while advocating for titles like "Saving Private Ryan," "Die Hard," and various action and war films that they feel better represent the genre. The conversation also touches on the importance of plot and character development in defining a "guy movie," with some participants suggesting that subtitles disqualify a film from this category. Overall, the thread highlights a passionate debate about what constitutes a quintessential guy movie, with numerous suggestions and personal favorites shared. The lively exchange underscores the diverse tastes and nostalgic connections to these films among the participants.
However, the guys I've been involved with tended to be fans of these, so I figure I must have some cred.