Mark S 2014
- 3
- 0
What exactly are the phases of orbitals/wavefunctions, for example the 2px orbital in hydrogen, what does it mean for the two lobes to be in different phases ?
The discussion centers on the phases of orbitals and wavefunctions, specifically the 2px orbital in hydrogen. Participants explore the significance of different phases in the lobes of the orbital, touching on concepts from quantum mechanics and atomic structure.
Participants express varying levels of understanding and confusion regarding the concept of phases in wavefunctions. There is no consensus on the significance of these phases, and multiple viewpoints are presented without resolution.
Some participants highlight the complexity of the wavefunction, indicating that its interpretation may depend on the context of quantum mechanics and the specific mathematical formulations used. There are unresolved questions regarding the implications of phase differences in overlapping orbitals.
To say that "the wavefunction is like a wave" is not completely correct. What is important here is that the wavefunction is like a function, since it is a function, with complex values. In the case of a p orbital, that function is real, and can have a positive or a negative value, depending on the position. If you consider the probability of finding the electron in some volume in space, the sign of the wavefunction is not important since the probability is proportional to ##| \psi(\mathbf{r})|^2 ##. However, the sign can be important when considering overlaping orbitals, as the sign can lead to constructive or destructive interference: in some places, the orbitals will add to each other, elsewhere they will cancel each other out.Mark S 2014 said:I just don't really get the significance of the different phases in each lobe, I get that the wavefunction is like a wave and has positive and negative values at certain points. I just don't get what this means really. How does a positive phase differ from a negative phase ?