Programs PhD Theoretical Physics - Part 2

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on various aspects of the PhD application process and program organization across different countries. Participants inquire about centralized websites for PhD offers, differences in supervision and management styles by country, and the feasibility of remote PhD supervision. It is noted that supervision quality varies significantly by university and individual professors, with personal preferences for mentorship styles playing a crucial role in the decision-making process. Additionally, it is acceptable to request recommendation letters from summer school professors, provided a strong working relationship has been established. Overall, prospective PhD candidates are encouraged to prioritize finding the right mentorship and program fit for their research interests.
The Moon Gauge
Messages
22
Reaction score
10
Hello,
I have several questions around the application process as well as the organization.
1. Are you aware of any reference website centralizing PhD offers by countries?
2.When it comes to the organization/management/ supervision of a PhD program, I wonder if there are differences by countries (UK,France,Germany,USA..) when it comes to how close the monitoring of our advisor is, presentations, evaluations...
3. Following question 2, which countries offer the best supervision for a PhD for you?
4. Is it possible to do a PhD at distance with your supervisor being in another country? Is it equally recognized? Is there a website for it?
5. Is it ok to ask for a recommandation letter (for a PhD application) from a summer school prof. supervising the program?

Many thanks
 
Physics news on Phys.org
* With respect to 5, it's OK.

* With respect to 2 and 3, there will likely be differences between universities that require a master before applying for a PhD and universities that require only a bachelor. But in any case, the wide variation among individual professors within a country will likely swamp out any generalizations among different countries.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes The Moon Gauge
The Moon Gauge said:
1. Are you aware of any reference website centralizing PhD offers by countries?
You might want to check out https://physicsgre.com
Maybe it's not exactly what you're looking for, but the applicant profile thread is quite popular.

The Moon Gauge said:
2.When it comes to the organization/management/ supervision of a PhD program, I wonder if there are differences by countries (UK,France,Germany,USA..) when it comes to how close the monitoring of our advisor is, presentations, evaluations...
Yes. And it varies from school to school as well. And supervisor to supervisor. If you're not locked into a particular place by geography, you might do better to filter by topic. Look at the strongest schools in the fields you're interested in, and then research the details of each program. Another way to look at it might be this: if you had the opportunity to work with a brilliant mentor on a PhD project you're going to love would it be a deal breaker if you had to first enroll in a masters program and then transfer to the PhD? Or if you had to do a written comprehensive examination instead of an oral?
The Moon Gauge said:
3. Following question 2, which countries offer the best supervision for a PhD for you?
Not sure why that would make a difference for anyone else, but for me personally it was Canada.
Given the relationships with professors you've developed so far, it's worth taking the time to think about what kind of mentorship will be most effective for you. Do you like rigid deadlines and a clear project map? Regular meetings? Or do you work better with more independence? Do you want to be one of a small number of graduate students, or have lots of colleagues but less access to your supervisor? Where are recent graduates of this mentor ending up? Is that were you see yourself in several years?

The Moon Gauge said:
4. Is it possible to do a PhD at distance with your supervisor being in another country? Is it equally recognized? Is there a website for it?
Possible - sure. But a lot can depend on the details of the program and what the individual supervisor is willing to do. With the pandemic, a lot of PhD supervision has moved online... students meeting with their supervisors via Zoom, Skype, etc. and so I suspect where things have been rigid in the past, they may be more pliable in the future. There are also regulator issues such as student visas to consider.

The Moon Gauge said:
5. Is it ok to ask for a recommandation letter (for a PhD application) from a summer school prof. supervising the program?
Sure. If you've developed a good working relationship with a professor, or you feel that person is in a good position to evaluate your ability to succeed in graduate school then yes. Generally though, you're looking for something better than "this student attended a summer course I taught in thermodynamics and did okay in it."
 
  • Like
Likes The Moon Gauge
Hi,

Thank you for the detailed answers.
Choppy said:
Yes. And it varies from school to school as well. And supervisor to supervisor. If you're not locked into a particular place by geography, you might do better to filter by topic. Look at the strongest schools in the fields you're interested in, and then research the details of each program. Another way to look at it might be this: if you had the opportunity to work with a brilliant mentor on a PhD project you're going to love would it be a deal breaker if you had to first enroll in a masters program and then transfer to the PhD? Or if you had to do a written comprehensive examination instead of an oral?
Honestly, for 2, it will definitely be an issue for me since I already have a Master’s degree which was 2 years full-time in 2016 so my priority is to jump into PhD research. Furthermore, I also noticed that the knowledge we get during the Master’s does not really prepare for research.

Choppy said:
Not sure why that would make a difference for anyone else, but for me personally it was Canada.
Given the relationships with professors you've developed so far, it's worth taking the time to think about what kind of mentorship will be most effective for you. Do you like rigid deadlines and a clear project map? Regular meetings? Or do you work better with more independence? Do you want to be one of a small number of graduate students, or have lots of colleagues but less access to your supervisor? Where are recent graduates of this mentor ending up? Is that were you see yourself in several years?
For 3, I really would prefer to be part of a small cohort of PhD student so that our supervisor will have time to focus more effectively on each of us. I also heard that the more prestigious your mentor is the better…

The Imperial College London theoretical group seems good but they have a very large intake of PhD student, what UK department would you advise for a PhD?
 
Hey, I am Andreas from Germany. I am currently 35 years old and I want to relearn math and physics. This is not one of these regular questions when it comes to this matter. So... I am very realistic about it. I know that there are severe contraints when it comes to selfstudy compared to a regular school and/or university (structure, peers, teachers, learning groups, tests, access to papers and so on) . I will never get a job in this field and I will never be taken serious by "real"...
Yesterday, 9/5/2025, when I was surfing, I found an article The Schwarzschild solution contains three problems, which can be easily solved - Journal of King Saud University - Science ABUNDANCE ESTIMATION IN AN ARID ENVIRONMENT https://jksus.org/the-schwarzschild-solution-contains-three-problems-which-can-be-easily-solved/ that has the derivation of a line element as a corrected version of the Schwarzschild solution to Einstein’s field equation. This article's date received is 2022-11-15...
Back
Top