Lucas Nunes Rosa
- 1
- 0
- TL;DR
- Simple photon question...
Could someone ell me if photon has mass? How can light have its direction changed by massive bodies?
The discussion centers around the question of whether photons have mass and how light can have its direction altered by massive bodies. It explores concepts from general relativity and the implications of gravity on light, touching on both theoretical and experimental aspects.
Participants generally agree that photons are massless, but there is ongoing debate regarding the implications of this for gravity and the potential for future theories to alter current understandings.
The discussion includes references to theoretical frameworks and experimental evidence, but it does not resolve the complexities surrounding the relationship between mass, energy, and gravity in the context of light.
This question was the basis of the first experimental verification of GR. This is what proved (OK, one thing that proved) that Einstein was right and Newton was wrong.Lucas Nunes Rosa said:Summary:: Simple photon question...
Could someone ell me if photon has mass? How can light have its direction changed by massive bodies?
To be pedantic, it was one piece of evidence that showed that Newton's theory was only an approximation, albeit one which remains valid in all but some fairly extreme circumstances.DaveE said:This is what proved (OK, one thing that proved) that Einstein was right and Newton was wrong.
Fair enough. I guess Quantum Gravity will prove Einstein was also wrong, someday.Ibix said:To be pedantic, it was one piece of evidence that showed that Newton's theory was only an approximation, albeit one which remains valid in all but some fairly extreme circumstances.
Well, to be pedantic again, relativity must be an approximation to quantum gravity which is accurate in all but some very extreme circumstances. Any successor theory must simplify to something indistinguishable from the current one, because it must explain all the experimental data we've got that matches the current theory to our best precision.DaveE said:Fair enough. I guess Quantum Gravity will prove Einstein was also wrong, someday.
As far as we know, photons are massless. In GR the gravitational interaction is due to the energy, momentum, and stress and not only due to mass energy. That's why photons (I'd rather say the electromagnetic field) are subject to the gravitational interaction as anything that has energy, momentum, and stress.Lucas Nunes Rosa said:Summary:: Simple photon question...
Could someone ell me if photon has mass? How can light have its direction changed by massive bodies?