Poisson's Ratio and Ultrasonic Velocity for Isotropic Material

In summary, when nu=0, VT/VL=sqrt(0.5). However, when nu=0, what happens to the longitudinal ultrasonic velocity. Does VL become zero when nu beccomes zero?
  • #1
3
0
For an isotropic material, the relation between the longitudinal ultrasonic
velocity(VL), the transverse (shear) ultrasonic velocity(VT) and the Poisson's ratio (nu) is given by

(VT/VL)^2 = (1-2*nu)/(2*(1-nu))


From the above relation, one gets that VL=0 when nu=1 which is
not physically acceptable as nu varies between -1 and 0.5 for an
isotropic material. On the contrary when nu=0, VT/VL=sqrt(0.5).
However, when nu=0, what happens to the longitudinal ultrasonic
velocity. Does VL becomes zero when nu beccomes zero ?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
"Does VL becomes zero when nu beccomes zero?"

No. Why did you think it might be zero?
 
  • #3
AlephZero said:
"Does VL becomes zero when nu beccomes zero?"

No. Why did you think it might be zero?
Reply to AlephZero

Poisson's ratio (nu) zero means that there will be no lateral deformation of
the material. In that case, if VL exists, the material will also have a
longitudinal elastic modulus. Under extension, the volume of the material
will tend to increase without any lateral contraction. This can only happen
if simultaneously density change occurs ? Is it feasible.
 
  • #4
The transverse wave is a shear wave. The volume of material doesn't change in shear, for any value of nu. The shear modulus G = E/2(1+nu) is not zero when nu is zero.

Velocity of VL = sqrt(E/rho), velocity of VT = sqrt(G/rho).

There are materials where (in some specific coordinate system) E is non zero and G is zero, but they are not isotropic. A piece of woven cloth is one example. G = 0 in a coordinate system lined up with the fibres of the cloth.

If you think of these waves as stress waves, not "displacement" waves, the names make more sense. For the VL wave, there is a lateral displacement (expansion and contraction) when nu is non-zero, but there is no lateral stress. For the VT wave there is transverse shear stress, but no longtitudinal stress.
 
  • #5
AlephZero said:
The transverse wave is a shear wave. The volume of material doesn't change in shear, for any value of nu. The shear modulus G = E/2(1+nu) is not zero when nu is zero.

Velocity of VL = sqrt(E/rho), velocity of VT = sqrt(G/rho).

There are materials where (in some specific coordinate system) E is non zero and G is zero, but they are not isotropic. A piece of woven cloth is one example. G = 0 in a coordinate system lined up with the fibres of the cloth.

If you think of these waves as stress waves, not "displacement" waves, the names make more sense. For the VL wave, there is a lateral displacement (expansion and contraction) when nu is non-zero, but there is no lateral stress. For the VT wave there is transverse shear stress, but no longtitudinal stress.
Thanks. I am still confused.
For an isotropic material, when nu=0,
if E and G both are non-zero, then under
tensile loading the material will extend
and the material volume should increase
as it cannot have lateral contraction.
This can happen only when if the density
decreases. Is this physcially tenable ?
If yes, then decreasing density should
imply increase in VL, otherwise elastic
instability will occur.

Please reply.
 
  • #6
The conventional way to define density for solids undergoing small strains is relative to the unstrained condition of the material - i.e. the density is (by definition) always constant, even for problems involving temperature change and thermal expansion.

The relevance of this definition is that when you set up the equations of motion you are considering the motion of a fixed piece of material (e.g a small box size dx.dy.dz) and the mass of that material is constant. This method is called the Lagrangian formulation of the equations.

You can indeed formulate the equations of motion by considering a fixed region in space instead of a fixed piece of material. Then, material with varying density moves in and out of that region during the motion. This is called the Euleran formulation and it's often used in fluid mechanics, but rarely in solid mechanics.

The results of both formulations are identical because they both use the same Newtonian mechanics, the same constitutive equations for the material, etc. There is no advantage in using an Euleran formulation for solid mechanics unless you have a problem involving large strains and/or displacements (e.g. plastic deformation of ductile materials).

To summarize, it's possible to formulate the equations of motion correctly with your "variable density" definition, but you would then have a different form of wave equation, and its physical solution would still be the same as the Lagrangian equations.

Finally, there are things called ALE formulations (Adaptive Lagrangian-Euleran) which combine both approaches - try a literature search for keywords ALE, DYNA3D (a computer program), and John Hallquist (its author) for more on those.


Hope this helps.
 
Last edited:

1. What is Poisson's Ratio?

Poisson's Ratio is a material property that describes the relationship between the lateral and axial strains of a material when it is subjected to stress. It is denoted by the Greek letter "nu" (ν) and is calculated by dividing the lateral strain by the axial strain.

2. How does Poisson's Ratio affect the behavior of a material?

Poisson's Ratio affects the stiffness and compressibility of a material. Materials with a high Poisson's Ratio are more compressible and have a lower stiffness, while materials with a low Poisson's Ratio are less compressible and have a higher stiffness. It also affects the material's ability to withstand stress and deformation without breaking.

3. What is Ultrasonic Velocity?

Ultrasonic Velocity is the speed at which sound waves travel through a material. It is measured in meters per second (m/s) and is influenced by the material's density, stiffness, and Poisson's Ratio.

4. How are Poisson's Ratio and Ultrasonic Velocity related for isotropic materials?

For isotropic materials, Poisson's Ratio and Ultrasonic Velocity are inversely proportional. This means that as Poisson's Ratio increases, Ultrasonic Velocity decreases and vice versa. This relationship is due to the fact that Poisson's Ratio and Ultrasonic Velocity are both influenced by the same material properties, such as density and stiffness.

5. How is Poisson's Ratio and Ultrasonic Velocity measured for isotropic materials?

Poisson's Ratio can be measured using a variety of methods, including strain gauges, extensometers, and ultrasound techniques. Ultrasonic Velocity can be measured using ultrasonic testing equipment that sends high frequency sound waves through the material and measures the time it takes for the waves to travel through it. Both measurements can also be calculated using known material properties, such as density and stiffness.

Suggested for: Poisson's Ratio and Ultrasonic Velocity for Isotropic Material

Back
Top