Problem about non-inertial reference frame

8 replies · 2K views · last reply
MatinSAR
Messages
676
Reaction score
207
Homework Statement
Consider two circles(in a plane) rotating with a constant angular velocity, ω, relative to an inertial reference frame. The center of one circle is fixed at the origin of this reference frame, while the center of the second circle is located on the circumference of the first circle. If there is a point mass located on the second circle, what would be the fictitious force acting on it? The position vector of the point mass is ##\vec R(t)## in C1 circle.
Relevant Equations
Newton's 2nd law in non-inertial reference frame.
Picture of the problem:
Diagram of a large circle C1 with a smaller circle C2 rolling on its outside, both rotating with angular velocity omega shown by arrows, and a dot marking a point on C2.


I wanted to use this formula: (From Classical dynamics of particles and systems Book by Stephen Thornton)
Equation for effective force in a rotating frame: F_eff = m a_r = F - m R-double-dot_f - m omega-dot cross r - m omega cross (omega cross r) - 2m omega cross v_r.

Diagram of two circles: a large circle C1 centred at O and a smaller circle C2 centred at O' that overlaps it, each with an arrow marked omega showing rotation, and a black dot on C2 with hand-drawn radius lines from both centres.

O is inertial observer. O' is non-inertial observer.
I think ##F## and ##\ddot R## and ##\dot \omega## are ##0##. According to O' the point mass has velocity of ##v_r## so it's not ##0##. I believe I just need to determine the values of ##w \times r## and ##\omega \times v_r##.

However, I’m uncertain about how to proceed. I would appreciate any assistance you could provide.
 
Last edited:
Your choice of non-inertial frame is not entirely clear. Is it:
  • origin O' orbits O but the axes are in fixed directions,
  • origin O' orbits O and axes rotate anticlockwise at rate ##\omega##, or
  • origin remains at O but axes rotate anticlockwise at rate ##\omega##
?
 
haruspex said:
  • origin O' orbits O but the axes are in fixed directions
This is what I meant.
 
I would answer the question by comparing the accelerations in the two reference frames. The fictitious force would be held responsible for the difference.
 
haruspex said:
The fictitious force would be held responsible for the difference.
Very meaningful. I didn't look at it this way. I will try to solve again.
 
haruspex said:
I would answer the question by comparing the accelerations in the two reference frames. The fictitious force would be held responsible for the difference.
Can I say that the point mass rotates with angular velocity of ##\vec \omega## compare to O' and ##2 \vec \omega## compare to O?
Diagram of two circles, C1 (large, centre O) and C2 (smaller, centre O'), with their rim contacting; each has a blue radius drawn from its centre, labelled r and r' respectively, and both have arrows marked omega showing counterclockwise rotation; a black point mass sits on the rim of C2.
 
MatinSAR said:
Can I say that the point mass rotates with angular velocity of ##\vec \omega## compare to O' and ##2 \vec \omega## compare to O?
View attachment 345791
No, you can’t add rotations about different centres. The motion of the point about O varies over time. If the radii are ##r_1, r_2## then the motion varies between
- a tangential speed of ##\omega r_2+\omega(r_1+r_2)## at distance ##r_1+r_2##, implying an angular rotation of ##\omega \frac{ r_1+2r_2}{r_1+r_2}## about O, and
- a tangential speed of ##-\omega r_2+\omega(r_1-r_2)## at distance ##r_1-r_2##, implying an angular rotation of ##\omega \frac{ r_1-2r_2}{r_1-r_2}## about O.
 
@haruspex I'm going to solve this question using TA's help. I will share the results. Thank you for your help and time.
 
MatinSAR said:
@haruspex I'm going to solve this question using TA's help. I will share the results. Thank you for your help and time.
Ok, but if you write down the vector expression for the position of the mass at time t you can differentiate to find the acceleration. You can do that in both the ground frame and the accelerating frame.