- #1
QuasarBoy543298
- 32
- 2
assume i have a gass made from N identical particles in a box and i want to calculate the probability for k out of N particles to be in the left side of the box.
the problem is ,that if we treat the N particles as identical , each state in which exacly k of the N particles are in the left side of the box is considered to be the same state (thats the meaning of identical particles from qm as i understood - the configuration in which particle A is on the left side and particle B on the right side and the configuration in which particle A is on the right side and particle B is on the left side are considered as one configuration ).
that does not seem very reasonable considering the fact that we now have not so neglegable probability for all the particles to go to the left side of the box
its kinda silly but i can't figure out where the mistake is
help me I am confused :(((
the problem is ,that if we treat the N particles as identical , each state in which exacly k of the N particles are in the left side of the box is considered to be the same state (thats the meaning of identical particles from qm as i understood - the configuration in which particle A is on the left side and particle B on the right side and the configuration in which particle A is on the right side and particle B is on the left side are considered as one configuration ).
that does not seem very reasonable considering the fact that we now have not so neglegable probability for all the particles to go to the left side of the box
its kinda silly but i can't figure out where the mistake is
help me I am confused :(((