I'm not clear as to how the overall interference pattern (or lack thereof) observed in the quantum eraser experiments (http://grad.physics.sunysb.edu/~amarch/ [Broken]) ends up being the same if the eraser is present or not present. My thinking follows.(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});

Say N entangled photons are sent through the apparatus without the eraser, and then N with the eraser.

Configuration 1: Eraser is NOT present

In this configuration some M (<N) photons will end up being detected with appropriate coincidence conditions satisfied. Roughly M/2 of these cases will correspond to the photon knowingly passing through one slit and resulting in a pattern without interference, call it pattern A, on the screen. Similarly, about M/2 cases correspond to the photon knowingly passing through the other slit and resulting in pattern B. In the remaining N-M cases we can't determine which-path info and we get the usual interference pattern, call it pattern C.

Configuration 2: Eraser is present

In this configuration which-path info is never available and hence pattern C is the result after all N photons pass through the apparatus.

So, the OVERALL pattern in configuration 1 should be (M/(2N))A + (M/(2N))B + ((N-M)/N)C, but the overall pattern in configuration 2 should be C. If the overall patterns are the same then:

(M/(2N))A + (M/(2N))B + ((N-M)/N)C = C

now moving the RHS to the LHS:

(M/(2N))A + (M/(2N))B - (2M/(2N))C = 0

now multiplying by 2N/M

A + B = 2C

This seems impossible to me. Suppose the screen is setup at a distance behind the slits where the maxima in pattern C occurs on the line normal to the screen and midway between the two slits (as appears to be the case in publication by Walborn, Cunha, Padua, ...). I don't think the pattern A+B can have a maxima in that location.

I must be missing something here.

**Physics Forums - The Fusion of Science and Community**

The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

# Quantum Eraser Interference Patterns

**Physics Forums - The Fusion of Science and Community**