Electrical Raspberry Pi Zero W receiver / transmitter

Click For Summary
The discussion centers on using a Raspberry Pi Zero W as both the CPU and receiver for an autonomous project, with a required communication range of at least 3000 feet. The Raspberry Pi Zero W, while equipped with WiFi, is not inherently designed as a receiver for long-range communication. Participants suggest exploring alternatives like the RFD900 Radio Modem or SiK telemetry radios, which are capable of bidirectional communication. There is a debate about the cost-effectiveness of using two RFD900 devices compared to cheaper options, with some emphasizing the need for clarity on project requirements. Other suggestions include considering laser communication for fixed-position devices or utilizing cellular networks for data transmission, provided unlimited data plans are available. The conversation highlights the balance between quality and cost in selecting communication devices for the project.
nduka-san
Messages
70
Reaction score
14
TL;DR
I'm currently trying to make a remote control for a robot using a raspberry pi 0w as its cpu
For a project that I'm making it has a raspberry pi 0w as its cpu for running autonomously, But I want to make use the raspberry pi 0w as the receiver as well. The range needed is about 3000 feet minimum. Currently I have been looking at some rc and drone receivers that would work as well, but I want to use a raspberry pi to save money.
here are the links for the receivers and transmitters I am looking athttps://hobbyking.com/en_us/turnigy...149&indexName=hbk_live_magento_en_us_products

https://hobbyking.com/en_us/turnigy...367&indexName=hbk_live_magento_en_us_products
 
Physics news on Phys.org
It is not clear what kind of functionality you need. Raspberry Pi Zero W is not a receiver per se, although it has a built in WiFi module. 3000 ft will be too much for both WiFi and standard RC transmitters/receivers as the ones you linked. I would look into solutions used by Ardupilot and Pixhawk, things like RFD900 Radio Modem or SiK telemetry radio.
 
  • Like
Likes sysprog
Borek said:
It is not clear what kind of functionality you need. Raspberry Pi Zero W is not a receiver per se, although it has a built in WiFi module. 3000 ft will be too much for both WiFi and standard RC transmitters/receivers as the ones you linked. I would look into solutions used by Ardupilot and Pixhawk, things like RFD900 Radio Modem or SiK telemetry radio.
Thanks for the advice the RFD900 Radio Modem looks good but what about a transmitter, since it only a receiver?
 
As far as I am aware for bidirectional communication you just take two RFD900, they are both transmitters and receivers.
 
  • Like
Likes sysprog
If a $30 device (one of your links) is too expensive, why are you looking at two $80 devices?
I think you need to be clearer as to your requirements.
 
  • Like
Likes sysprog
nduka-san said:
For a project that I'm making it has a raspberry pi 0w as its cpu for running autonomously, But I want to make use the raspberry pi 0w as the receiver as well. The range needed is about 3000 feet minimum.
Are the two devices fixed in position? Do they have a clear line of sight between them?

If so, you could consider using a modulated laser diode and optics to complete the link. What data bandwidth do you need?

If not, can you just use cellphone communication? Be sure to sign up for the unlimited data plans for the two devices... :wink:
 
  • Like
Likes Vanadium 50 and sysprog
nduka-san said:
Thanks for the advice the RFD900 Radio Modem looks good but what about a transmitter, since it only a receiver?
As @Borek has pointed out, that device is both a transmitter and a receiver ##-## just as the term 'modem' is a contraction for 'modulator-demodulater', the term 'transceiver' is a contraction for 'transmitter-receiver' ##-## please look around before buying ##\dots##
 
Vanadium 50 said:
If a $30 device (one of your links) is too expensive, why are you looking at two $80 devices?
I think you need to be clearer as to your requirements.
I'm willing to shell out the money for higher quality. I'm just trying to decrease the cost of my project so I can distribute it to other things .