Relationship between voltage, power and current

AI Thread Summary
Doubling the voltage in a simple electric circuit results in doubling the current and quadrupling the power, according to Ohm's Law. The discussion emphasizes that current is dependent on both voltage and resistance, and cannot change independently. Participants clarified that power is calculated using the formula P = I x V, leading to the conclusion that if voltage is doubled, the current also doubles, but the power increases by a factor of four. Misunderstandings about the relationship between these variables were addressed, highlighting the importance of context in electrical calculations. Overall, the correct answer to the initial question is that both current and power are affected, but power increases more significantly.
Imtiaz Ahmad
Messages
51
Reaction score
2
Misplaced homework thread moved here by moderator, hence no template.
Hy,
If we double the voltage than what will be double
A. power
B. Current
C. Resistance
D. Both a & b
 
Physics news on Phys.org
As usual: It depends. You have not specified the context. A drawing would help.
 
Svein said:
As usual: It depends. You have not specified the context. A drawing would help.
When we double the voltage in a simple electric circuit, we double the
A. Current
B. Power
C. Resistance
D. Both current and power
 
Imtiaz Ahmad said:
When we double the voltage in a simple electric circuit, we double the

you still haven't specified the circuit setup
until you fix (state) a couple of the variables, your Q cannot be answered

Dave
 
davenn said:
you still haven't specified the circuit setup
until you fix (state) a couple of the variables, your Q cannot be answered

Dave
Actually problem is that
This question is on the textbook which is recommended by government.
 
Imtiaz Ahmad said:
Actually problem is that
This question is on the textbook which is recommended by government.
So there is not show any circuit
 
Imtiaz Ahmad said:
So there is not show any circuit

so, so let me provide you with a circuit ...

upload_2017-1-23_18-22-49.png


a nice simple one, a battery and a resistor

do you know Ohm's Law ? ...
 
davenn said:
so, so let me provide you with a circuit ...

View attachment 111995

a nice simple one a battery and a resistor

do you know Ohm's Law ? ...
Yes I know
 
Imtiaz Ahmad said:
Yes I know

OK, good

so you have 10V across a 10 Ohm resistor ...
what is the current flowing in that circuit ?

show me your working :smile:
 
  • #10
davenn said:
OK, good

so you have 10V across a 10 Ohm resistor ...
what is the current flowing in that circuit ?

show me your working :smile:
1 A
 
  • #11
Imtiaz Ahmad said:
1 A

correct

so if you now increase the voltage to 20 V, what is the current in the circuit ?
 
  • #12
davenn said:
correct

so if you now increase the voltage to 20 V, what is the current in the circuit ?
2 A
 
  • #13
Imtiaz Ahmad said:
2 A

correct :smile:

so next, what is the formula for finding power ?
 
  • #14
davenn said:
correct [emoji2]
so next, what is the formula for finding power ?
P = I V
P= I (2) R
P = V (2) / R
 
  • #15
Imtiaz Ahmad said:
P = I V
P= I (2) R
P = V (2) / R

Yup
for ease we can use your first choice P = I x V

work out the two power levels for the examples we have just done

then answer your original Q ...

Imtiaz Ahmad said:
Hy,
If we double the voltage than what will be double
A. power
B. Current
C. Resistance
D. Both a & b

Dave
 
  • #16
davenn said:
Yup
for ease we can use your first choice P = I x V

work out the two power levels for the examples we have just done

then answer your original Q ...
Dave
Mean D option is correct
 
  • #17
Imtiaz Ahmad said:
Mean D option is correct

yes, well done :smile:

wasn't too difficult to work out, huh :wink:
.

Dave
 
  • #18
davenn said:
yes, well done [emoji2]
wasn't too difficult to work out, huh :wink:
.

Dave
Thanks
But
Is this answer corrected. If current is double
P = 2 I * 2 V
 
  • #19
Imtiaz Ahmad said:
Is this answer corrected. If current is double

unlike voltage or resistance, current cannot just change
current is a RESULT of a given voltage across a given resistance
That is, current can ONLY change IF the voltage OR the resistance changes

And the power, in Watts, dissipated in a circuit, in our circuits above ( in the resistor)
is always related to the voltage across the resistance divided by the resistance

so for a fixed resistance, if the voltage is doubled, then the current is doubled and therefore so is the power dissipatedDave
 
  • #20
davenn said:
unlike voltage or resistance, current cannot just change
current is a RESULT of a given voltage across a given resistance
That is, current can ONLY change IF the voltage OR the resistance changes

And the power, in Watts, dissipated in a circuit, in our circuits above ( in the resistor)
is always related to the voltage across the resistance divided by the resistance

so for a fixed resistance, if the voltage is doubled, then the current is doubled and therefore so is the power dissipatedDave
Power dissipated mean?
 
  • #21
Mean energy loss
 
  • Like
Likes davenn
  • #22
Imtiaz Ahmad said:
Power dissipated mean?

power lost, radiated, used up <---- take your pick, all the same :smile:
 
  • #23
davenn said:
power lost, radiated, used up <---- take your pick, all the same :smile:
[emoji3]
 
  • #24
I moved it to homework, where it better fits and can be found by others with similar questions.
 
  • #25
Imtiaz Ahmad said:
Mean D option is correct
Check again the amount by which current and power changed. They don't change by the same factor.
 
  • Like
Likes conscience, Merlin3189 and davenn
  • #26
gneill said:
Check again the amount by which current and power changed. They don't change by the same factor.

I royally screwed up ... I blame old age and senility :wink: :rolleyes:

@imtiaz ... humble apologies answer b) current ... should have been answer

for power

10V x 1 A = 10 W

double the voltage, the current doubles as correctly stated but the power dissipated quadruples

20V x 2A = 40W

@gneill ... cheersDave
 
  • Like
Likes Imtiaz Ahmad and gneill
  • #27
davenn said:
I royally screwed up ... I blame old age and senility :wink: :rolleyes:

@imtiaz ... humble apologies answer b) current ... should have been answer

for power

10V x 1 A = 10 W

double the voltage, the current doubles as correctly stated but the power dissipated quadruples

20V x 2A = 40W

@gneill ... cheersDave
So current is correct
 
  • Like
Likes davenn
  • #28
Imtiaz Ahmad said:
Hy,
If we double the voltage than what will be double
A. power
B. Current
C. Resistance
D. Both a & b
If circuit is simple
 
  • #29
Imtiaz Ahmad said:
Hy,
If we double the voltage than what will be double
A. power
B. Current
C. Resistance
D. Both a & b
If circuit is double
 
Back
Top