Relationship of Physical Quantities in Functions

5 replies · 4K views · last reply
Youngster
Messages
37
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



This is actually a part of my physics lab assignment, but there isn't any physics involved here, so I chose to post this here. I hope that isn't a problem.

Anyway, I've been given three data tables, and have been asked to make graphs for each of the data tables by hand. After doing so, I'm tasked to find the function for each graph, also being tasked with finding the relationships between the values that compose the function.

Here is one of those tables:

Problem text and Table I of measured capacitive reactance (ohms) against AC frequency (kHz): reactance 312±9, 145±6, 96±4, 79±3, 62±3, 49±2 at frequencies 100±1, 200±2, 300±3, 400±4, 500±5, 600±6.


Homework Equations



For linear functions: y = Bx + A
For power functions: log y = n log x + log A
For exponential functions: ln y = Bx + ln A

The Attempt at a Solution



I did actually graph the data first, with reactance as my independent variable (in the x-axis) and frequency as my dependent variable, and I'm guessing it's not an exponential function, just based on appearance.

Scatter plot titled Reactance at given Frequency, with Frequency (kHz) from 0 to 700 on the x-axis and Reactance (Ω) from 0 to 350 on the y-axis. Six blue diamond points fall from about 310 at 100 kHz to about 50 at 600 kHz, decreasing as frequency rises.


I then tried plugging in my y values into power function equation, but I don't know how to derive the exponent n, or the coefficient A from that equation (assuming a power function relationship even exists in this case).

I'm hoping to get some direction here, so I can start on the other two data sets that I've also graphed.
 
Okay, just tried that and got a (nearly) straight line with a slope around -1.

So -1 would be n, and A (after some further calculation) would be about 4.492.

Plugged those into check so that at x = 100, y = 310.7, and at x = 200, y = 155.34. These are pretty close, and sound reasonable when factoring in uncertainty. Thanks a lot!

Okay, I also managed to do the second one, but I need some clarification (and maybe help) with the last data table.

Homework problem text about Amy, a cosmic ray physicist, and a table titled Table III listing number of cosmic ray events at energies from 1 GeV to 10 GeV: 2953±54, 519±23, 184±14, 82±9, 46±7, 33±6, 16±4, 16±4, 9±3, 9±3.


The energy given by GeV is the independent variable here, yes?
 
Youngster said:
The energy given by GeV is the independent variable here, yes?

Yes. What does the graph look like?
 
Alright, the graph looks like this:

Scatter plot titled Number of Cosmic Ray Events at Given Energy: counts fall from about 2950 at 1 GeV to about 500 at 2 GeV, then near zero by 6 GeV, through 10 GeV.


And I was thinking this was an exponential function, but when I took the logarithm of both sides, I got another (somewhat) straight line

Scatter plot of log10 of cosmic energy event counts (y, 0 to 4) against log of energy (x, 0 to 1.2), with blue diamond points decreasing roughly linearly from about 3.5 at x = 0 to about 1 at x = 1.


So I'm guessing it's another power function since the natural log of the dependent variable does not form a straight line.

Plugging the values in, I again receive values pretty close to what should be expected. I suppose none of the data tables given provide an exponential function (the second one was linear when graphed).

Thanks a lot, I appreciate the help.