Relative velocity ship problem intuitively

3 replies · 3K views · last reply
anurag07
Messages
2
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Two ships A and B are 4 km apart. A is due west of B. If A moves with uniform velocity of 8 km/hr due east and B moves with a uniform velocity of 6 km/hr due south. Calculate 1) the magnitudeof the velocity of A in relation to B 2) the closest distance apart of A and B

Homework Equations


The first solution is pretty simple but the second one, I don't get it. I know how to just solve it but without any intuition. Can someone help me get an intuitive idea of the solution of 2) ? The solution will be down there.

The Attempt at a Solution


In the example BD is drawn from B to relative velocity of A with respect to B represented by AE. From the given distance between A and B is 4km i.e. AB = 4km. In ABE sin x = BE/AE = 6/10 ( x= Angle EAB, BE = Velocity of B in opposite direction, AE = relative velocity of A in respect to B )
x=36.67
Closest distance apart from A to B is BD.
Now in BDA,
BD = sin x * AB = sin 36.87 * 4 = 2.4 km
This is the closest distance.
 
Attachments
  • Photo of a printed textbook page showing Example 27 solution text with equations for relative velocity and a vector triangle diagram with labeled sides 8 km/hr, 6 km/hr and 10 km/hr.
    1474766237216520889294.jpg
    20.6 KB · Views: 720
  • Handwritten solution on a printed page: In triangle ABE, sin α = BE/AE = 6/10, so α = 36.87°. A diagram of triangle ABD with point C below B shows the closest distance BD. Text reads 'Example 28' about a man swimming across a river.
    1474766295463-1605830173.jpg
    26.5 KB · Views: 735
phinds said:
Posting tiny sideways pics is not a good way to get people to look at them.
Dont have a good phone. Sorry. And vertical pictures are even tinier.
 
The idea is to use B's reference frame. In that frame, what are the NS and EW components of A's motion. At what point does B perceive A as being at closest approach?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: anurag07