Relativity: Massless particles and photons

Click For Summary
Massless particles, such as photons, always travel at the speed of light and do not gain mass by moving at this velocity. The discussion clarifies that a particle cannot transition from having mass to being massless; it is either one or the other. Misunderstandings about mass and the nature of photons are addressed, emphasizing that photons are indeed massless and not heavier than electrons. The concept of relativistic mass is also explained, noting that it approaches infinity as a particle's speed approaches light speed, but this does not apply to the invariant mass of massless particles. Overall, the conversation highlights the importance of understanding the fundamental properties of particles in the context of relativity.
sunmoon
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
I f a particle starts moving with the velocity of light it becomes massless.But practically a massless particle has no existence.Again one of the main constituents of light is photon,then is it a massless particle?But I know electron has the least mass in this world and photon is heavier than it.So I am totally confused.
 
Science news on Phys.org
sunmoon said:
I f a particle starts moving with the velocity of light it becomes massless.
It does not.
Particles are either massless, then they always travel at the speed of light, or they are not, then they never do that.
sunmoon said:
But practically a massless particle has no existence.
"Existence" can have philosophical issues, but I think light clearly exists.
sunmoon said:
Again one of the main constituents of light is photon
It is not a constituent. Light can be described with the concept of photons.
sunmoon said:
But I know electron has the least mass in this world
It does not. Neutrinos are lighter. And massless particles are even lighter of course, this includes the photon.
 
sunmoon said:
I f a particle starts moving with the velocity of light it becomes massless.But practically a massless particle has no existence.Again one of the main constituents of light is photon,then is it a massless particle?But I know electron has the least mass in this world and photon is heavier than it.So I am totally confused.

Hi there you have miss understood the equation if a particle travell with speed of light then its mass would become infinity remember the equation

M'= Mo/(√1- V2/C2)
 
Suraj Nehra said:
Hi there you have miss understood the equation if a particle travell with speed of light then its mass would become infinity remember the equation

That is still misleading... Keep in mind that no massive particle can travel with the speed of light...
If you take the limit of the velocity going to c, then you have that the relativistic mass (M' you wrote) goes to infinity, and not the rest (invariant) mass, which we call the mass of a particle.
The relativistic mass is more like the total energy of your particle (contains also the kinetic energy) and that's why the energy is written as E= m_0 \gamma (= m_{rel}).
 
sunmoon said:
I f a particle starts moving with the velocity of light it becomes massless.

You have an error in cause-and-effect here. A particle doesn't become massless when it "starts moving with the velocity of light". It is either massless, or it isn't! If it is massless, then it will move at c. It doesn't become massless when it reaches c.

But practically a massless particle has no existence.

Says who? What natural law are you using here to claim that there are no massless particle, especially when the Standard Model of elementary particle says that there is? Be very careful, on this forum, about espousing your personal beliefs, especially when it is glaringly wrong! Read the PF Rules!

Again one of the main constituents of light is photon,then is it a massless particle?

It is not the "main constituents", it is the ONLY constituent! Light is not made up of anything else.

But I know electron has the least mass in this world and photon is heavier than it.So I am totally confused.

Where did you get that a photon is "heavier" than an electron? It is difficult to answer your question when you are already asking us to explain it based on your faulty understanding. A photon is NOT heavier than an electron, as far as having a mass is concerned. A photon is massless. Period!

Maybe you need to start reexamining one conjecture at a time! Every single sentence that you posted here is faulty! Start from the beginning, and you might learn something without asking if you start reading our FAQ first, because I have a strong feeling a lot of your wrong understanding can be corrected by at least a couple of our FAQs.

Zz.
 
ZapperZ said:
Maybe you need to start reexamining one conjecture at a time! Every single sentence that you posted here is faulty! Start from the beginning, and you might learn something without asking if you start reading our FAQ first, because I have a strong feeling a lot of your wrong understanding can be corrected by at least a couple of our FAQs.

Says the person who have contributed in writing many parts of those FAQs o0) I can feel you there...
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
17K
Replies
18
Views
4K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
1K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
1K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 17 ·
Replies
17
Views
2K
  • · Replies 67 ·
3
Replies
67
Views
6K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
4K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K
Replies
7
Views
3K