Reverse Carnot - Refrigeration Cycle problem

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around an ideal refrigeration cycle problem involving refrigerant-134a. Participants are exploring the implications of a second law analysis, particularly in the context of an "expanded control volume" and its relation to the cooling and heat rejection spaces.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants are attempting to understand the meaning of "expanded control volume" and how it relates to the refrigeration cycle. Questions are raised about the interpretation of the dead state and its application in the second law analysis. There is also discussion about how to approach the analysis of the evaporator and condenser separately.

Discussion Status

Some participants have provided clarifications regarding the definitions of the heat rejection space and cooling space, as well as the role of the dead state. However, there remains uncertainty about how to conduct the second law analysis effectively, with various interpretations being explored.

Contextual Notes

The problem involves specific temperature and pressure conditions, including a cooling space at 0 degrees C and a heat rejection space at 20 degrees C, with a dead state defined at 20 degrees C and 100 kPa. Participants are navigating the constraints of these conditions while discussing their implications for the analysis.

leonida
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
Hi guys, I have difficulties understanding the what I need to do in this problem. I have a ideal refrigeration cycle. first part is standard calculations, work of compressor and such. Results are Temperature range between -23 and 60 degrees C. Second part is the one that i do not understand. it says: "Assume an expanded control volume where cooling space is at 0 degrees C and the heat rejection space is at 20 degrees C and with the dead state of 20 deg C and 100 kPa. Do a second law analysis of the system." What am i supposed to do here? Is this a cycle in a cycle that runs between o and 20 deg C? or is it a simple ideal reverse Carnot that fits inside the dome? or something else...thanks
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
leonida said:
Hi guys, I have difficulties understanding the what I need to do in this problem. I have a ideal refrigeration cycle. first part is standard calculations, work of compressor and such. Results are Temperature range between -23 and 60 degrees C. Second part is the one that i do not understand. it says: "Assume an expanded control volume where cooling space is at 0 degrees C and the heat rejection space is at 20 degrees C and with the dead state of 20 deg C and 100 kPa. Do a second law analysis of the system." What am i supposed to do here? Is this a cycle in a cycle that runs between o and 20 deg C? or is it a simple ideal reverse Carnot that fits inside the dome? or something else...thanks
The "heat rejection space" is simply the hot reservoir (that heat flows into) and the cooling space is the cold reservoir (that heat flows out of). The "dead state" is simply the state at which the system would be at equilibrium with the surroundings so no heat would flow out of or into the system. I am not sure from the problem how that really differs from the hot reservoir.

It is not clear from this what is meant by "expanded control volume". It might help to give us the entire first problem.

AM
 
AM Thanks for your quick response.

I will post the text of the problem below, and doing the first part of it is not a big deal. I am confused with the same thing you are, 2nd part of it - "expanded control volume". What does that mean?

text of the problem:
A refrigerator uses refrigerant-134a as the working fluid and operates
on the ideal vapor-compression refrigeration cycle except for the compression process.
The refrigerant enters the evaporator with a quality of 30 % and leaves the compressor at 60 C
Compressor work is 0.45 kW.
a) The mass flow rate of the refrigerant, the condenser pressure, and the COP of the refrigerator are to be determined.
b) Assume an expanded control volume where cooling space is at 0 degrees C and the heat rejection space is at 20 degrees C and with the dead state of 20 deg C and 100 kPa. Do a second law analysis of the system
 
leonida said:
AM Thanks for your quick response.

I will post the text of the problem below, and doing the first part of it is not a big deal. I am confused with the same thing you are, 2nd part of it - "expanded control volume". What does that mean?

text of the problem:
A refrigerator uses refrigerant-134a as the working fluid and operates
on the ideal vapor-compression refrigeration cycle except for the compression process.
The refrigerant enters the evaporator with a quality of 30 % and leaves the compressor at 60 C
Compressor work is 0.45 kW.
a) The mass flow rate of the refrigerant, the condenser pressure, and the COP of the refrigerator are to be determined.
b) Assume an expanded control volume where cooling space is at 0 degrees C and the heat rejection space is at 20 degrees C and with the dead state of 20 deg C and 100 kPa. Do a second law analysis of the system
"Expanded control volume" must just refer to the volume of refrigerant (vapour) that is in thermal contact with the cold reservoir. The cold reservoir (the air being refrigerated) is being kept cooled to 0 C.

Refrigerant enters the control volume at less than 0C and leaves this space at or close to 0 C. The refrigerant then enters the compressor. It leaves the compressor as a liquid at 60C and is then placed in thermal contact with the hot reservoir (the heat rejection space) which is at 20C. It leaves the heat rejection space at close to 20C. It is then put through the throttle valve causing it to expand/evaporate and cool. It then again enters the control volume and the cycle repeats.

Does that help?

AM
 
Andrew, thanks again for your help.

To me it does make sense what you have described. But how do i proceed with the 2nd law analysis? I do have dead state at 20 deg C and 100 kPa. How am i supposed to use this information? Restricted Dead State is used for Exergy calculation on system as a whole. Do I use the 0 and 20 deg C as dead states to calculate waste energy for evaporator and condenser as separate equipment? Using 0 deg for evaporator and 20 for condenser? In that case how should i analyze valve?
 
leonida said:
Andrew, thanks again for your help.

To me it does make sense what you have described. But how do i proceed with the 2nd law analysis? I do have dead state at 20 deg C and 100 kPa. How am i supposed to use this information? Restricted Dead State is used for Exergy calculation on system as a whole. Do I use the 0 and 20 deg C as dead states to calculate waste energy for evaporator and condenser as separate equipment? Using 0 deg for evaporator and 20 for condenser? In that case how should i analyze valve?
Second law analysis looks at entropy. Draw a diagram of Temperature v. entropy for a unit mass of refrigerant for each part of the cycle. What is happening to entropy in the different stages? I think that is what they are asking.

AM
 

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
6K
Replies
6
Views
9K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
8K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
9K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
6K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K