Second uniqueness theorem application in Griffiths electrostatics example

11 replies · 2K views · last reply
Ahmed1029
Messages
109
Reaction score
40
Two diagrams: Figure 3.7 shows four separate circles with charges, top pair plus then minus, bottom pair minus then plus. Figure 3.8 shows the same four circles joined in pairs by wires forming a closed loop, top plus and minus connected, bottom minus and plus connected.

in this example in Griffiths' electrodynamics, he says the following :(Figure 3.7 shows
a simple electrostatic configuration, consisting of four conductors with charges
±Q, situated so that the plusses are near the minuses. It all looks very comfort-
able. Now, what happens if we join them in pairs, by tiny wires, as indicated in
Fig. 3.8? Since the positive charges are very near negative charges (which is where
they like to be) you might well guess that nothing will happen—the configuration
looks stable.
Well, that sounds reasonable, but it’s wrong. The configuration in Fig. 3.8 is
impossible. For there are now effectively two conductors, and the total charge
on each is zero. One possible way to distribute zero charge over these conductors is to have no accumulation of charge anywhere, and hence zero field everywhere)

I feel like there are gaps in this explanation, that is, don't know if he implicitly invoked the first uniqueness theorem here
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Delta2
This is like connecting two oppositely charged capacitors. You bet the current will flow!
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Delta2
Well he seems to imply that since one way to redistribute zero total charge over a conductor, is to have zero charge everywhere in the conductor, then this is the only way. Is this the first uniqueness theorem btw?
 
BvU said:
Delta2 said:
Well he seems to imply that since one way to redistribute zero total charge over a conductor, is to have zero charge everywhere in the conductor, then this is the only way. Is this the first uniqueness theorem btw?
Well there are infinite ways to distribute charge on conductors, each with its own electric field. What conditions will tell me which of them is the true one? This is the second uniqueness theorem
 
A conductor has no potential difference. The charge may be distributed unevenly, but the surface potential is the same everywhere.

##\ ##
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: vanhees71
Ahmed1029 said:
I feel like there are gaps in this explanation, that is, don't know if he implicitly invoked the first uniqueness theorem here
The situation shown in Figure 3.8 is a fictitious assumption and it is likely not a stable state.

If we think of these two conductors as an isolated capacitor, there is no potential difference and no electric field between them since the net charge in the two conductors is zero. That is, there is also no charge accumulation on the surfaces of the two conductors.
 
Hmm, given a conductor (that is given its shape) and a total charge Q, isn't the way that this charge Q going to redistribute itself along the surface of the conductor, unique? And that depends only on the shape of the conductor?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: vanhees71
Delta2 said:
Hmm, given a conductor (that is given its shape) and a total charge Q, isn't the way that this charge Q going to redistribute itself along the surface of the conductor, unique? And that depends only on the shape of the conductor?
I think so too, which seems to be what the uniqueness theorem says.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: vanhees71 and Delta2
Delta2 said:
Hmm, given a conductor (that is given its shape) and a total charge Q, isn't the way that this charge Q going to redistribute itself along the surface of the conductor, unique? And that depends only on the shape of the conductor?

There is the small matter of an external field (if present)

##\ ##
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: vanhees71 and Delta2
In fact, the situation of Figure 3.8 is impossible because it violates the conservation of energy around closed circuit paths and circuit theory.

Handwritten sketch of two pairs of opposite charges on a closed conductor loop, each pair marked with a voltage V0 and field E0 arrow, with question marks on V = 2V0 or 0 and the sum written as ΣV = 2V0 ???.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Delta2