Servo vs ? for lift/winch/hoist

In summary, a microprocessor controlled hoist can lift a payload of 24 kg with 1 m/s acceleration. The torque needed to achieve this force is 412 N. A servo could be used, but is overkill in this application. Gearmotor selection requires understanding frequency of use, gearbox type, and heat dissipation. Properly applying a gearmotor requires analysis of frequency of use.
  • #1
Vanbot
3
0
Hello.

As many others here, I am starting a project that involves some engineering and will at some point, if I go ahead with it, require an engineer to design and certify. But for now I'd like to understand the principals involved and dust off some of my 1st year physics and see how much of it I can solve with some help from experts.

The details so far:

-hoist controlled by a microprocessor that can vertically position the payload with 1/2"-1" accuracy
-payload of 24 kg max
-wire rope hoist line, 1/4" diameter (my calculations indicate this gives a safety factor of 30 or so and electric hoist applications require SF of only 7)
-hoist line length is 100 m and mass of that length of 1/4" wire rope is 16 kg
-desired lifting/lowering speed is 1 m/s
-desired acceleration is .5 m/s/s, when lifting that works out to net acceleration of 10.3 m/s/s
-winch drum diameter is .254 m when drum is loaded with wire rope

So the force required to hit that acceleration during lifting:
F = ma, F = 40*10.3 = 412 N

The torque I'll need from the motor to achieve that force when the drum is fully loaded:
T = Fd, T = 412*.254*.5 = 52.3 Nm

I also have these formulas for selecting a motor:
Ts = stall torque
Wn = no load speed

so T = Ts – (Ts/Wn)*W
and
W = (Ts – T) (Wn/Ts)

That's as far as I am now and I'm now running into the issue of which type of motor is best for this application. I spoke with a supplier of motion control equipment who advised using a servo. That's all fine with me since they are made to keep track of position. However, because the velocity of the payload will vary as the amount of wire rope left on the drum changes I am considering having a sheave with an encoder, remote from the motor and drum that the wire rope would run over. This way the actual velocity of the wire rope could be read. What I'm not sure of is whether a servo can use info from an encoder that isn't attached directly to the motor. Can anyone provide some insight here? And since I wouldn't be using the servo's inherent position tracking ability, would I be better off using a regular motor with VFD?
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2
Would this question be better off in a different forum section? Electrical eng maybe? I wasn't sure so just posted in Mech Eng.
 
  • #3
You can get a free refresher course of motion control dynamics by websearching & finding the "Smart Motion Cheat Sheet" in PDF.

Your positioning accuracy is not too demanding. You need to determine 'peak torque' which incudes not only torque to raise the load against gravity (and friction, and stiction, and sludge in the rails, and moon phases, and...) but the added torque needed to accelerate the load from zero velocity. So you've got some significant mass moment of inertia calculations in front of you. Your unit is sized for peak torque plus any safety factors.

A servo could work, but is overkill IMHO. I don't know what your budget is, but my first look at this would be with a small gearmotor with a small AC induction motor and variable frequency drive. Many of those vendors (SEW Eurodrive pops into my head first) provide nifty online sizing calculators. If the sizing calculator does not have this "elevator" model, then the manufacturers usually provide good Engineering Guides to help you run the calculations and size the unit. You'll need to gain a bit of understanding about the different types of gearboxes in order to select the best fit for the load application. If I recall, certain of the SEW VFDs could accommodate the rope wrap-up diameter change of the winch spool because their units are used for elevators very often.

Properly applying a gearmotor requires some analysis of the frequency of use, too. Many frequent start-stop cycles will require a larger unit to dissipate the heat generated.

I was always told: "Torque is cheap...use plenty of it." Get lots of reserve torque capacity. Your system will only draw enough current to provide what torque is demanded of it.

And put brakes on that thing.
 
  • #4
Thanks tygerdawg. That was a really helpful reply.

Would using a wormgear in the drive mean I can get away without using a brake? Or is redundancy in braking a must?

I'll get in touch with our local SEW Euro guys and see what they say.
 
  • #5
Worm drives are OK, but have less mechanical efficiency that other gear trains. If I remember, they're good for shock-load applications. Not having a brake requires that the gear ratio of the worm gear arrangement has sufficient backdrive resistance to keep it from moving under load. There's a formula out there somewhere for this, but I don't remember much about it. Use a brake to be sure. Especially if this is a safety-critical application.
 

1. What is the difference between a servo and a motor for a lift/winch/hoist?

A servo is a type of motor that is specifically designed for precise control and positioning. It has built-in feedback mechanisms that allow it to accurately maintain a desired position. A regular motor, on the other hand, does not have this feedback and is typically used for continuous rotation.

2. Which is better for a lift/winch/hoist, a servo or a motor?

The answer depends on the specific application. If you need precise control and positioning, a servo would be the better choice. However, if you need continuous rotation, a regular motor would be more suitable.

3. Can a servo be used for heavy lifting?

Yes, servos can be used for heavy lifting depending on their size and torque rating. However, for very heavy loads, a specialized motor such as a linear actuator or a hydraulic motor may be more suitable.

4. Are servos more expensive than motors?

In general, servos tend to be more expensive than regular motors. This is due to their more complex design and added features, such as feedback mechanisms. However, the cost difference may vary depending on the specific brand and model.

5. Is it possible to use both a servo and a motor together for a lift/winch/hoist?

Yes, it is possible to use both a servo and a motor together in certain applications. For example, a servo can be used for precise positioning, while a motor can be used for continuous rotation. This combination can provide both accuracy and power in a single system.

Similar threads

  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
5
Views
3K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
5
Views
3K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • Mechanics
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
42
Views
12K
  • Engineering and Comp Sci Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
3K
Back
Top