SHM: Choose Sin or Cos to Solve?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Isweer
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Shm
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
4 replies · 4K views
Isweer
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
I wanted to ask if weather I choose sin or cos makes difference in solving problems.
In this question
A block of mass m=4 kg on a frictionless horizontal table is attached to one end of a spring of force constant k=400 N/m and undergoes simple harmonic oscillations about its equilibrium position (X=0) with amplitude A=6 cm. If the block is at x=6 cm at time t=0, then which of the following equations (x in cm and t in seconds) gives the block's position as a function of time?

a) x=6sin(10t + ∏/2)
b) x=6sin(10t - ∏/2)
c)...
d)...
e)...
the answer is (a) but, what I am asking is that I got cos instead of sin ( from the general form X=Acos(ωt + ∅ )
 
Physics news on Phys.org
When I started solving this problem I immediately wrote the general form I learned.
X=A*cos(wt + ∅ ).

Then I started breaking the problem into pieces:

A=6,
w= (k/m)^0.5 = (400/4)^0.5 = 10,
and ∅= sin(inverse) (x at t=0)/A)= sin(inverse) (6/6)= 90 degrees which is ∏/2

by substituting I got:

X=6cos(10t + ∏/2)

so does that mean that using sin or cos doesn't matter? or I have a mistake?
 
Isweer said:
When I started solving this problem I immediately wrote the general form I learned.
X=A*cos(wt + ∅ ).

Then I started breaking the problem into pieces:

A=6,
w= (k/m)^0.5 = (400/4)^0.5 = 10,
and ∅= sin(inverse) (x at t=0)/A)= sin(inverse) (6/6)= 90 degrees which is ∏/2

by substituting I got:

X=6cos(10t + ∏/2)

so does that mean that using sin or cos doesn't matter? or I have a mistake?

You've made a mistake. Why did you do this bit?

and ∅= sin(inverse) (x at t=0)/A)= sin(inverse) (6/6)= 90 degrees which is ∏/2

Why sine?

When you let t = 0 in [itex]6\cos({\omega}t + \varphi)[/itex], you get [itex]6\cos\varphi = 6[/itex], giving [itex]\varphi=0[/itex]. So the equation should simply be [itex]6\cos{\omega}t[/itex].

This is not one of the answers. However, you should be able to see (from basic trig) that [itex]\sin(\theta + \frac{\pi}{2}) = \cos\theta[/itex]. So you can match it to the first answer.

It doesn't matter if you use sine or cosine, both are equally valid. They may look different, but if you do the basic math, they're actually identical.

And here, you don't actually have to derive very much. It's easier to just go through the multiple choices to see which fits, i.e. which gives a displacement of 6 when t = 0.