Show that f(x,y) is differentiable

2 replies · 2K views · last reply
Jamie2
Messages
17
Reaction score
0
Problem:
View attachment 2105

I plugged in fx, fy, and f(1,pi) everywhere I could but I have no idea how to move on from here. I'm stuck trying to show that:

(1+Δx) + (1+Δx)sin(pi+Δy) - 1 = Δx - Δy + ε(Δx,Δy)Δx + ε(Δx,Δy)Δy
 
Attachments
  • Printed problem statement: Problem 5 asks to show f(x,y) = x + x sin y is differentiable at (1, pi) by finding functions e1 and e2 so that the change in f equals the partial derivatives times dx and dy plus e1 times dx plus e2 times dy, with e1, e2 tending to 0.
    Screen Shot 2014-03-13 at 11.09.32 AM.png
    9.9 KB · Views: 124
Jamie said:
I'm stuck trying to show that:

(1+Δx) + (1+Δx)sin(pi+Δy) - 1 = Δx - Δy + ε(Δx,Δy)Δx + ε(Δx,Δy)Δy
You are nearly there! You want to show that $$(1+\Delta x) + (1+\Delta x)\sin(\pi+\Delta y) - 1 = \Delta x - \Delta y + \varepsilon_1(\Delta x,\Delta y)\Delta x + \varepsilon_2(\Delta x,\Delta x y)\Delta y.$$ On the left side of that equation, $ \sin(\pi+\Delta y) = - \sin(\Delta y)$. So the left side of the equation becomes $$\Delta x - \sin(\Delta y) - \Delta x\sin(\Delta y).$$ You want that to look like the right side of the equation. So write it as $$\Delta x - \Delta y + \Delta x(-\sin(\Delta y) + \Delta y\left(1 - \frac{\sin(\Delta y)}{\Delta y}\right).$$ Now can you see how to choose the functions $\varepsilon_1(\Delta x,\Delta y)$ and $\varepsilon_2(\Delta x,\Delta y)$? (Remember that you have to show that they go to $0$ as $(\Delta x,\Delta y) \to (0,0).$)
 
Opalg said:
You are nearly there! You want to show that $$(1+\Delta x) + (1+\Delta x)\sin(\pi+\Delta y) - 1 = \Delta x - \Delta y + \varepsilon_1(\Delta x,\Delta y)\Delta x + \varepsilon_2(\Delta x,\Delta x y)\Delta y.$$ On the left side of that equation, $ \sin(\pi+\Delta y) = - \sin(\Delta y)$. So the left side of the equation becomes $$\Delta x - \sin(\Delta y) - \Delta x\sin(\Delta y).$$ You want that to look like the right side of the equation. So write it as $$\Delta x - \Delta y + \Delta x(-\sin(\Delta y) + \Delta y\left(1 - \frac{\sin(\Delta y)}{\Delta y}\right).$$ Now can you see how to choose the functions $\varepsilon_1(\Delta x,\Delta y)$ and $\varepsilon_2(\Delta x,\Delta y)$? (Remember that you have to show that they go to $0$ as $(\Delta x,\Delta y) \to (0,0).$)
thank you! I understand how to finish the problem now. But could you explain your simplification of the left side in a little more detail?