Solve the problem that involves Normal distribution

chwala
Gold Member
Messages
2,825
Reaction score
413
Homework Statement
See attached
Relevant Equations
stats
1654172872696.png
1654172908106.png
My interest is on part (c),
My take,

##Z=\dfrac{160−200}{60}=−0.666666##

##Pr(−0.66666)=0.3546##

##⇒\dfrac{x_1-200}{60}=1.05##

##x_1=63+200=263##

Yes, i am aware that they want the answer to ##5## significant figures...i just wanted to check the alternative method...
Appreciate your insight...
 
Physics news on Phys.org
What do you mean with the probability of -2/3? The density of the distribution there?
 
chwala said:
Homework Statement:: See attached
Relevant Equations:: stats

View attachment 302276View attachment 302277My interest is on part (c),
My take,

##Z=\dfrac{160−200}{60}=−0.666666##

##Pr(−0.66666)=0.3546##
One approach is to calculate P(X > 160). Your work should include the probabilities that some random variable is greater than or less than some number. Pr(-.66666) is meaningless as a probability, a pointed hinted at by the previous poster.

To get you started, calculate Pr(X > 160) = Pr(##\frac{X - 160}{60} > \frac{160 - 200}{60}##) = Pr(Z > -0.66667)##. That should give you a number that is larger than 0.6. You should then be able to find the Z score (and hence the X value) that gives you the correct probability, using a table of z-scores.
chwala said:
##⇒\dfrac{x_1-200}{60}=1.05##

##x_1=63+200=263##

Yes, i am aware that they want the answer to ##5## significant figures...i just wanted to check the alternative method...
Appreciate your insight...
 
Mark44 said:
One approach is to calculate P(X > 160). Your work should include the probabilities that some random variable is greater than or less than some number. Pr(-.66666) is meaningless as a probability, a pointed hinted at by the previous poster.

To get you started, calculate Pr(X > 160) = Pr(##\frac{X - 160}{60} > \frac{160 - 200}{60}##) = Pr(Z > -0.66667)##. That should give you a number that is larger than 0.6. You should then be able to find the Z score (and hence the X value) that gives you the correct probability, using a table of z-scores.
My point was that when ##z =-0.66666## Then the area subtended between the two x points would be equal to ##0.3546##
 
Maarten Havinga said:
What do you mean with the probability of -2/3? The density of the distribution there?
Yes I meant the density...I shouldn't have used term probability...I hope that makes sense...otherwise, I need to check again...and I should have used inequalities instead of equal sign...Will amend that later.
 
chwala said:
My point was that when ##z =-0.66666##
Then that is incorrect since Pr(Z = -0.66666) = 0. For a continuous probability, any probability statement should involve a random variable in an inequality.
 
  • Like
Likes chwala
It's OK, making mistakes is how we learn ;)
 
  • Like
Likes chwala
Maarten Havinga said:
It's OK, making mistakes is how we learn ;)

Yes, in my approach i first found the area bound by ##160## and ##X.## I found that to be; ##0.2454## then i took ##0.6-0.2454=0.3542## ...
chwala said:
Homework Statement:: See attached
Relevant Equations:: stats

View attachment 302276View attachment 302277My interest is on part (c),
My take,

##Z=\dfrac{160−200}{60}=−0.666666##

##Pr(−0.66666)=0.2454##

chwala said:
##⇒\dfrac{x_1-200}{60}=1.05##

##x_1=63+200=263##

Yes, i am aware that they want the answer to ##5## significant figures...i just wanted to check the alternative method...
Appreciate your insight...

chwala said:
Homework Statement:: See attached
Relevant Equations:: stats

View attachment 302276View attachment 302277My interest is on part (c),
My take,

##Z=\dfrac{160−200}{60}=−0.666666##

##Pr(−0.66666)=0.3546##

##⇒\dfrac{x_1-200}{60}=1.05##

##x_1=63+200=263##

Yes, i am aware that they want the answer to ##5## significant figures...i just wanted to check the alternative method...
Appreciate your insight...
I made a mistake ...find the corrected version here;

My interest is on part (c),
My take,

##Z=\dfrac{160−200}{60}=−0.666666##

##Pr(−0.66666)=0.2454##

##0.6-0.2454=0.3542##

##0.3542= Z_{1.05}## Therefore

##⇒\dfrac{x_1-200}{60}=1.05##

##x_1=63+200=263##

Yes, i am aware that they want the answer to ##5## significant figures...i just wanted to check the alternative method...
Appreciate your insight...
 
  • Like
Likes Maarten Havinga
Back
Top