Stellar stream vs. Dark matter

  • Level: Graduate 
  • Thread starter arabianights
  • Start date
4 replies · 583 views · last reply
arabianights
Messages
70
Reaction score
9
I attended a presentation held at an University in NYC last week, and the presenter (a physics PhD candidate) talked about the Stellar stream (interstellar structure caused by Galaxies gobbling each other), he spent big portion of time to link this observed phenomenon to dark matter and how observing the stellar stream can reveal the nature of dark matter. he also made a distinction of 'cold' vs. 'warm' dark matter.

I haven't been keeping the latest development on the dark matter, but somehow this seems fishy - how can one characters dark matter by stellar stream or call it 'warm' or 'cold', is this a consensus of view among modern astrophysicists?
 
Cold dark matter means that the average speed of dark matter particles is low (like baryonic matter), whereas hot dark matter particles typically move at large fractions of the speed of light. Since we don't have a firm grasp on what dark matter is, we don't know for certain which model (if either) is correct. I think the consensus view leans towards cold, but with significant dissent (including things like alternative gravity theories).

Stellar streams are new to me, but they seem to be streams of stars associated with galaxies but outside them, not part of their disc/ellipsoid structure. As such, I suspect they give you a way to probe the gravitational field outside the galaxy proper, which might tell you more about the dark matter distribution outside the main part of the galaxy. I would imagine that the warmer your dark matter is (the higher the typical speeds of particles) the more diffuse the dark matter halo of a galaxy is, and that would affect the speeds of stars in a stream. So studying them could tell you something about the nature of dark matter.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: phyzguy and Bandersnatch
I think we should wait until Dark Matter is confirmed to exist in a lab before we start giving it attributes like "cold" or "hot."
 
ioannisakousoulakos said:
I think we should wait until Dark Matter is confirmed to exist in a lab before we start giving it attributes like "cold" or "hot."
We aren't giving it such attributes - yet. We're considering the possible cases where dark matter is made of relativistic or non-relativistic particles, or somewhere in between, working out the implications of each model, and seeing which (if any) case matches observation. This is the way science is supposed to work - if we're going to posit dark matter at all we need to consider its properties. For example, if we make two sets of observations on the same body we might find that one set rules out hot dark matter and the other rules out cold dark matter. Then we'd know we need to go back to the drawing board. You can't rule out any case if you refuse to consider it until it's found.

Theoretical models are important because they both interpret and predict observations.