- #1
Teclis
- 25
- 2
Why are there no problems at the end of chapters one and two in Stratton Electromagnetic theory like there are at the end of all the other chapters??
deskswirl said:Just out of interest. Why Stratton?
I mean the only people I know who use Stratton are researchers (myself included) who need a few details omitted from later books. But it is even rare for me to pull my copy off of the shelf. There are more modern books that cover essentially the same material without the headache to decipher what Stratton is taking about... Seriously you ought to read the section where he introduces Laplace Transforms :( ... If you want a modern outlook at the same level of rigour that covers the same material you ought to look at Van Bladel's Electromagnetic Fields 2nd edition. Chapters 2 and 17 are a real treat (variational techniques and electrodynamics of moving bodies).
Thank you very much! I was able to find PDFs of all of them on the web. What about for Hilbert Spaces? I looked in the index of Landau and Lifshitz's Quantum Mechanics and I didn't see them. They are supposed to be covered in Math texts on Topology and Analysis but it seems to be a real hit and miss in the ones I have looked at.deskswirl said:Physicists typically use different books. It seems to me that most of the current generation prefer Jackson's Classical Electrodynamics and Landau and Lifshitz's Electrodynamics of Continuous Media. Personally I prefer the older Panofsky and Philips to Jackson but Landau and Lifshitz is a charm. Books written for/by electrical engineers emphasis wave guiding, scattering, and radiation from antennas for the most part outside of that it is hit or miss on other topics physicists deem necessary. In a sense you could say that the EE's book are incomplete, which is true but they do cover topics in depth which physicists gloss over (but are important in engineering practice). I think the best way to learn is read one of each side by side.
Interesting historical fact: if you read Jackson's biography he says he used Stratton's text religiously before he entered graduate school at MIT. Not suprising as Stratton was the main upper undergrad text till probably the mid 1950s/early 1960s. To me Stratton and many of the (physics) electrodynamics books from that era, have a very electrical engineering feel to it, unlike say Jackson's latest edition. Perhaps electrical engineers are just 60 years behind physics in their electrodynamics education.
Of course EEs have been know to teach/learn from Jackson as well although I would say it is not common.
Telemachus said:I think that the book Introductory Functional Analysis with Applications by Erwin Kreyszig is a pretty good introduction to Hilbert spaces. It has problems at the end of each chapter, and solutions at the end of the book. I've used it to study Hilbert spaces once. The book was on the library of my university.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/0471504599/?tag=pfamazon01-20
The Stratton Electromagnetic Theory is a mathematical framework for understanding and predicting the behavior of electromagnetic fields. It is important because it helps us to understand and develop technologies that rely on electromagnetic phenomena, such as radio communication and electronics.
It is possible that the problem solutions for Chapters 1 and 2 of the Stratton Electromagnetic Theory were not included in the materials provided by the author or publisher. Alternatively, the problem solutions may have been intentionally omitted to encourage students to work through the problems themselves.
You may be able to find the missing problem solutions by contacting the author or publisher of the textbook or by searching online for supplemental materials or solutions manuals. You can also try reaching out to other students or professors who have used the same textbook.
It is possible that not having the problem solutions for Chapters 1 and 2 could make it more challenging to understand the material. However, it also presents an opportunity to practice problem-solving skills and develop a deeper understanding of the concepts.
Yes, there are many resources available that can help you with the problems in Chapters 1 and 2 of the Stratton Electromagnetic Theory. You can consult other textbooks, online forums and discussion boards, or even seek help from a tutor or professor. It may also be helpful to review class notes and lecture materials to gain a better understanding of the concepts.