Summation Index Notation in the Transformation Equations

4 replies · 2K views · last reply
sams
Gold Member
Messages
84
Reaction score
2
In Chapter 7: Hamilton's Principle, in the Classical Dynamics of Particles and Systems book by Thornton and Marion, Fifth Edition, page 258-259, we have the following equations:

Two equations from a classical mechanics text. Equation (7.116): x_{α,i} = x_{α,i}(q_j, t), j = 1, 2, ..., s. Equation (7.117): dot x_{α,i} = sum from j=1 to s of (partial x_{α,i} / partial q_j) times dot q_j, plus partial x_{α,i} / partial t.
Equation (7.118): the square of the time derivative of x_{α,i} equals a double sum over j and k of (∂x_{α,i}/∂q_j)(∂x_{α,i}/∂q_k) q̇_j q̇_k, plus 2 times a sum over j of (∂x_{α,i}/∂q_j)(∂x_{α,i}/∂t) q̇_j, plus (∂x_{α,i}/∂t) squared.

1. Upon squaring Equation (7.117), why did the authors in the first term of Equation (7.118) are summing over two indices ##j## and ##k##, and not over ##j## only? In other words, where did the index ##k## come from? Why do we add sometimes a new index and when do we do that?

2. What is the physical interpretation of Equation (7.121)?
Boxed equation T = sum over j,k of a_jk times the time derivative of q_j times the time derivative of q_k, with summation indices j and k below the sum sign, labelled (7.121).

Thanks a lot!
 
Attachments
  • Two equations from a classical mechanics text. Equation (7.116): x_{α,i} = x_{α,i}(q_j, t), j = 1, 2, ..., s. Equation (7.117): dot x_{α,i} = sum from j=1 to s of (partial x_{α,i} / partial q_j) times dot q_j, plus partial x_{α,i} / partial t.
    1.PNG
    3 KB · Views: 732
  • Equation (7.118): the square of the time derivative of x_{α,i} equals a double sum over j and k of (∂x_{α,i}/∂q_j)(∂x_{α,i}/∂q_k) q̇_j q̇_k, plus 2 times a sum over j of (∂x_{α,i}/∂q_j)(∂x_{α,i}/∂t) q̇_j, plus (∂x_{α,i}/∂t) squared.
    2.PNG
    6.7 KB · Views: 727
  • Boxed equation T = sum over j,k of a_jk times the time derivative of q_j times the time derivative of q_k, with summation indices j and k below the sum sign, labelled (7.121).
    3.PNG
    1.4 KB · Views: 753
sams said:
why did the authors in the first term of Equation (7.118) are summing over two indices ##j## and ##k##, and not over ##j## only? In other words, where did the index ##k## come from? Why do we add sometimes a new index and when do we do that?

2. What is the physical interpretation of Equation (7.121)?
View attachment 232606
Thanks a lot![/QUOTE]

As easy examples, calculate
$$\sum_j q_j^2$$
and
$$\sum_{j,k} q_j q_k$$
where both ##j## and ##k## run from 1 to 3.

sams said:
What is the physical interpretation of Equation (7.121)?

The physical interpretation of (7.121) is given in the words just before the equation.
 
George Jones said:
As easy examples, calculate
$$\sum_j q_j^2$$
and
$$\sum_{j,k} q_j q_k$$
where both ##j## and ##k## run from 1 to 3.

Thank you for your reply. Yes, I expanded the summations. The first one leads to three terms and the second one to nine terms, but I still did not get it why should we use two indices instead of one index!
 
George Jones said:
2. What is the physical interpretation of Equation (7.121)?
The physical interpretation of (7.121) is given in the words just before the equation.
For those of us who don't have the book, would you mind telling us what the words say, or showing. Thanks.
 
Carpe Physicum said:
For those of us who don't have the book, would you mind telling us what the words say, or showing. Thanks.
Printed text stating that under these conditions the kinetic energy is a homogeneous quadratic function of the generalized velocities, followed by the equation T = sum over j,k of a_jk q̇_j q̇_k, labelled (7.121), boxed.
 
Attachments
  • Printed text stating that under these conditions the kinetic energy is a homogeneous quadratic function of the generalized velocities, followed by the equation T = sum over j,k of a_jk q̇_j q̇_k, labelled (7.121), boxed.
    Capture.PNG
    7.4 KB · Views: 475