Symmetrical component example: can't understand solution

1 reply · 2K views · last reply
ffp
Messages
96
Reaction score
5
Thread moved from the technical forums to the schoolwork forums
Ok, now I'm studying symmetrical components. Im using Stevenson's Power System Analysis book and example 11.9 asks for the zero sequence circuit of the example 6.1 in the same book.

Here's the example and the solution:
Printed text reading: Example 11.8. Draw the negative-sequence network for the system described in Example 6.1. Assume that the negative-sequence reactance of each machine is equal to its subtransient reactance. Omit resistance and phase shifts associated with the transformer connections.

Here's example 6.1, so we can see what is the circuit:
One-line diagram for Example 6.1: 20 kV generator through transformer T1 (230 kV) to a 64 km line, then transformer T2 (13.8 kV) feeding motors M1 and M2.


Here's the beginning of the solution, where I'm stuck...

Textbook solution page: three-phase rating of T2 is 3 x 100 = 300 kVA with voltage ratio sqrt(3) x 127/13.2 = 220/13.2 kV; base voltages 230 kV and 13.8 kV; transformer reactances X = 0.0857 and 0.0915 per unit.


I believe de X of T1 (0.0857 pu) is found by changing bases (Xpu=OLDpu x OLDbase/NEWbase). So 0.1 is the pu of T1, 300 is the Sbase (MVA) of the generator (and hence, system) and 350 is the Sbase (MVA) of T1. Is that right?

If so, why is X of T2 calculated differently, I believe by reflecting impedances? If that's really what he's doing, why is he using 13.2 and 13.8?

I'm really lost here with this example.
 
Attachments
  • Printed textbook caption reading: Example 11.8. Draw the negative-sequence network for the system described in Example 6.1. Assume that the negative-sequence reactance of each machine is equal to its subtransient reactance. Omit resistance and phase shifts associated with the transformer connections.
    SmartSelect_20230123_225052_Moon+ Reader Pro.jpg
    21.1 KB · Views: 179
  • One-line diagram for Example 6.1: 20 kV generator through transformer T1 (230 kV) to a 64-km line, then transformer T2 (13.8 kV) feeding motors M1 and M2.
    SmartSelect_20230123_225223_Moon+ Reader Pro.jpg
    52 KB · Views: 155
ffp said:
I believe de X of T1 (0.0857 pu) is found by changing bases (Xpu=OLDpu x OLDbase/NEWbase). So 0.1 is the pu of T1, 300 is the Sbase (MVA) of the generator (and hence, system) and 350 is the Sbase (MVA) of T1. Is that right?
Yes. Both T1 and the generator have the same voltage rating(and are at the same voltage level in the line diagram). This is why only the ratio of MVA ratings is used to find the new pu reactance.
ffp said:
If so, why is X of T2 calculated differently
The MVA rating of T2 is same as the base MVA (300MVA). The 0.1 pu reactance of T2 is w.r.t its own ratings (300MVA, 13.2kV). To convert it properly according to the motor citcuit voltage level, it is divided by the motor circuit voltage level (and then squared).