The magnetic flux density at point P between parallel wires

2 replies · 3K views · last reply
whatdoido
Messages
48
Reaction score
2

Homework Statement


In the picture at points A and B are two thin parallel wires, where traveling currents are 15 A and 32 A to opposite directions. The distance between wires is 5.3 cm. Point's P distances from A and B are the same. Calculate the magnetic flux density at point P.
Triangle diagram with vertices A, P and B; P at the apex has a right-angle mark, sides AP and PB labelled L, base AB labelled x. Labels: A has 15A, B has 32A with circled dot.


Homework Equations


##B=\mu_0\frac{I}{2\pi r}##

The Attempt at a Solution



##I_1=15A##
##I_2=32A##
##x=5.3cm=0.053m##
##\mu_0=4\pi *10^-7 Tm/A##

I solved length L with Pythagorean equation

##L^2+L^2=x^2##

##L=\frac{x}{\sqrt{2}}##

With right-hand-rule the directions of magnetic flux density can be deduced. The magnetic flux density at point P generated from point B is to the direction of point A. From point A the generated magnetic flux density at point P is towards point B.

Diagram of two parallel wires A and B at the base of a triangle, with apex P above the midpoint X; sides PA and PB are labelled L, angles theta at P, field vectors B_A and B_B shown, currents 15A at A and 32A at B.


To add both ##B_B## and ##B_A## they need to be turned downward by ##\theta## which is ##\theta=\frac{90^o}{2}=45^o##. This should be reasonable, right? The total magnetic flux density at point P is then:

##B_{total}=sin\theta B_B+sin\theta B_A=sin\theta\mu_0\frac{I_1}{2\pi \frac{x}{\sqrt{2}}}+sin\theta\mu_0\frac{I_2}{2\pi \frac{x}{\sqrt{2}}}=sin\theta(I_1+I_2)\frac{\mu_0}{\sqrt{2}\pi x}=1.773...*10^-4 T \approx 0.17mT##

This problem is from a book and it gives answer 0.19mT. I checked multiple times where I could have made a mistake but I cannot find it. The calculation is rather straightforward so there is not much to check. Thus it looks like there is some conceptual error? Thanks for reading and any help is appreciated
 
Attachments
  • Triangle diagram with vertices A, P and B; P at the apex has a right-angle mark, sides AP and PB labelled L, base AB labelled x. Labels: A has 15A, B has 32A with circled dot.
    magndens1.png
    1.6 KB · Views: 1,091
  • Diagram of two parallel wires A and B at the base of a triangle, with apex P above the midpoint X; sides PA and PB are labelled L, angles theta at P, field vectors B_A and B_B shown, currents 15A at A and 32A at B.
    magndens2.png
    2.2 KB · Views: 929
whatdoido said:
To add both ##B_B## and ##B_A## they need to be turned downward by θ
That will give you the PX component of each, but since they are of different magnitudes their resultant also has an AB component.
Since the two flux density vectors are orthogonal, it is much simpler to add them without resolving into PX and AB components.
 
Okay simply with Pythagorean style:

##B_{total}=\sqrt{B_B^2+B_A^2}=\sqrt{(\frac{μ_0 I_1}{√2πx})^2+(\frac{μ_0 I_2}{√2πx})^2}=1.886...*10^{-4} T \approx 0.19mT##

Thanks!
 
Last edited: