The net magnetic field at the center

12 replies · 3K views · last reply
PhysicsTest
Messages
260
Reaction score
27
Homework Statement
Four, long, parallel power lines each carry 100-A currents. A cross-sectional diagram of these lines is a square, 20.0 cm on each side. For each of the three cases shown in , calculate the magnetic field at the center of the square.
Relevant Equations
##B = \frac {\mu_0 I} {2a}##
The current direction is as follows
Four small circular symbols arranged in a square: the top two contain a cross (current into the page), the bottom two contain a dot (current out of the page).

I think so much and do the right hand rule i get 0 at the center, but not sure why the answer is non zero. I have shown the directions of the magnetic fields, i have not shown the magnitudes of equal length but they all are equal. Why the answer is non zero, what mistake i am doing?

Diagram of four circular loops at the corners of a square, each with a current shown as a cross (into page) or dot (out of page), with arrows labelled B1 to B4 for magnetic fields at the centre, which is marked Center.
 
I see only one case ? Mixup of answers ?
 
BvU said:
I see only one case ? Mixup of answers ?
The first two I could solve, this is the 3rd one which I am struggling to get answer.
 
May I suggest drawing the arrows again?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: BvU
Gordianus said:
May I suggest drawing the arrows again?
I end up getting below the same,

Diagram of four current-carrying wires in a square arrangement viewed end-on: two top circles marked with crosses (into the page) and two bottom circles marked with dots (out of the page), each with a block arrow pointing toward or away from the center.
 
Gordianus said:
No, try again.
Ok, chances are there of a below diagram
Diagram of four wires seen end-on in a square arrangement: two at the top marked with crosses for current into the page, two at the bottom marked with dots for current out of the page, with arrows between them showing the directions of the magnetic field contributions.

But a very tough one to know where it will be left. Am i correct here?
 
Gordianus said:
Try drawing the B-lines of each wire
The B lines are like this
Four loops drawn around a central point labelled Center, each with three arrowheads placed around the circumference showing the direction of the magnetic field lines.

Everything seems to be left.
 
Good! Now extend the lines to the center and draw the arrows again.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: hutchphd
Diagram of four overlapping black circles labelled B1, B2, B3 and B4, with green and red vector arrows drawn from a shared intersection point at the centre, showing the individual field contributions.

Surely the tougher than i expected. Hope it is correct.