Thermochemistry Help: Finding the final temperature of a mixture.

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around a thermochemistry problem involving the calculation of the final temperature when a piece of iron is dropped into glycerol. Participants explore the principles of heat transfer, specific heat capacities, and the implications of using different units for temperature.

Discussion Character

  • Homework-related
  • Mathematical reasoning
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant calculates the heat transfer for water and assumes that the heat lost by iron is equal to the heat gained by water, leading to confusion about applying the same principle to glycerol.
  • Another participant questions whether the heat transfer for iron in glycerol can be assumed to be the same as in water, noting the difference in specific heat capacities.
  • Some participants suggest that the specific heat of iron can be calculated using known values and that the equations for heat transfer should be treated separately for different substances.
  • There is a discussion about the units of specific heat for glycerol being in moles, which complicates the calculations when converting mass to moles.
  • A later reply proposes that temperature units (Celsius vs Kelvin) do not affect the calculations since they are additive, suggesting that participants can equate the heat transfer equations to solve for the final temperature.
  • One participant provides a detailed calculation process for determining the final temperature, expressing frustration over the complexity of the problem and seeking a simpler method.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on whether the heat transfer calculations for iron in glycerol can be treated similarly to those in water. There is no consensus on the best approach to solve for the final temperature, and multiple competing methods are proposed.

Contextual Notes

Participants note limitations related to the use of different units for specific heat capacities and the need to convert between grams and moles, which introduces complexity into the calculations. The discussion also highlights the unresolved nature of the final temperature calculation.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be useful for students studying thermochemistry, particularly those grappling with heat transfer problems involving different substances and specific heat capacities.

kirsten_2009
Messages
136
Reaction score
2

Homework Statement



A 1.22 kg piece of iron at 126.5 degrees Celsius is dropped into 981 g of water at 22.1 degrees Celsius. The temperature rises to 34.4 degrees Celsius. What will be the final temperature if this same piece of iron at 99.8 degrees celsius is dropped into 350 mL of glycerol, CH2OHCHOHCH2OH, at 26.8 degrees Celsius? For glycerol, density = 1.26 g/mL, C_p = 219 J/K x mol.

Homework Equations



q = m x C x (Tf-Ti)

The Attempt at a Solution



So, I know that the specific heat of water is 4.18 J/g x C, so I could find "q" for water (50437.134) and since the heat gained by the surroundings is equal to what is lost by the system I could also say that "q" for water is the same as "q" for iron but negative (-50437.134). Now, I could calculate the specific heat of iron (0.449 J/g x C). But now I'm stuck because I don't have "q" for the iron that is then dumped into glycerol and I don't have Tf so how could I calculate it? Or, is the value of "q" for iron the same throughout the process? Help is much appreciated! :)
 
Physics news on Phys.org
kirsten_2009 said:
So, I know that the specific heat of water is 4.18 J/g x C, so I could find "q" for water (50437.134) and since the heat gained by the surroundings is equal to what is lost by the system I could also say that "q" for water is the same as "q" for iron but negative (-50437.134). Now, I could calculate the specific heat of iron (0.449 J/g x C). But now I'm stuck because I don't have "q" for the iron that is then dumped into glycerol and I don't have Tf so how could I calculate it? Or, is the value of "q" for iron the same throughout the process? Help is much appreciated! :)
If by q (for the iron) you mean energy, then you have the mass, the temperature and C_p of iron, it's all you need. It's the same as above where you found out the C_p of iron just that you need to find out the final temp.
 
Hello!

I think I'm not understanding what you are saying...
I found "q" for iron when it was dumped in water but I don't know "q" for iron when it was dumped in glycerol, unless, "q" for iron when it was dumped in water is the same as if when it was dumped in glycerol but how can that be if glycerol and water have different specific heat capacities?
So my problem is that I don't know how to get "q" for iron when it was dumped in glycerol because I don't have the final temperature (Tf)...am I making any sense or am I just completely lost with this whole thing...thanks so much for your help!

-K
 
q of iron is depending on C_p of iron and the temp it drops. q in the two cases is not the same. Find them a different name for cleanliness sake :P (e.g. Qw Qgly)

Find out C_p of iron and then you will get q of iron dropped in glycerol. Which is q of glycerol also. something like 2 equations with 2 unknowns where q is rather useless :P.
 
Hey, I am having problem with this question as well. The Cp of Glycerin is given in kelvin (J/K*mol), so I changed the temperature to kelvin as well on the glycerin side, but had to keep it in Celsius for the iron side of the equation (because of the fact that the iron side is in J/g*c). But I end up having two unknowns (Final temp of iron, and final temp of glycerin).
 
rcaste said:
Hey, I am having problem with this question as well. The Cp of Glycerin is given in kelvin (J/K*mol), so I changed the temperature to kelvin as well on the glycerin side, but had to keep it in Celsius for the iron side of the equation (because of the fact that the iron side is in J/g*c). But I end up having two unknowns (Final temp of iron, and final temp of glycerin).

The final temp is one and the same for both. :P
 
Hi!

I think I finally figured it out. It doesn't matter if the temperature on one side is in kelvin's and the other in celsius because if you think about it they are added and not multiplied
(Tf = Ti + 273). So really what one needs to do is equate both q's. This is what i came up with and it seems to be correct:

1st: If you have the specific heat of iron from a tabulated data table you can use that value, but if you are in an exam and you need to calculate the specific heat of iron you could do it in the following way (assuming that you've memorized that the specific heat of water is 4.18 J/g x Celsius):

q_water = 981 g x 4.18 J/g x Celsius x 12.3 Celsius
q_water = 50437.13 J

And we know that q_water = -q_iron so q_iron = -50437.13 J

and now to find the specific heat of iron we re-arrange the equation to isolate for spht:

q = m x spht x (Tf -Ti) -----> spht = q / m x (Tf-Ti)

Where: "q" is quantity of heat (J/g x C), "m" is mass (grams or moles), "spht" is specific heat capacity (J/g x C), "Tf" is final temperature (Celsius) and "Ti" is initial temperature (Celsius).

spht = -50437.13 J / 1220 g x (-92.1)
spht = -50437.13 J / -112362.0 g x Celsius
spht = 0.449 J/g x Celsius

Now, we are given the amount of glycerol in mL but we are also given the density which we can use to find the grams of glycerol, so...

350 mL glycerol x (1.26 grams glycerol / 1 mL) = 441 grams of glycerol

But, the specific heat of glycerol is given in units of moles, thus it is a molar specific heat and therefore the grams of glycerol must be converted to moles...

441 g glycerol x (1 mol glycerol / 92.0 g glycerol) = 4.79 moles of glycerol

So...now we have "two" unknowns: "q" and "Tf" but we know that q = -q so we can simply equate them and we are left with just one unknown. Don't worry about the units of celsius and kelvin because as I mentioned earlier they are equivalent. 1 Celsius = 1 Kelvin because they are simply being added. So...

q= 1220 g x 0.499 J/g.C x (Tf - 99.8 C) = -4.79 mol x 219 J/K.mol x (Tf - 26.8 C)
= 547.78 J/C x (Tf - 99.8 C) = -1049.01 J/K x (Tf - 26.8)
= 547.78Tf J/C x (-54668.4 C) = -1049.01Tf J/K x 28113.4 C
= 547.78Tf J/C + 1049.01Tf J/K = 28113.4 + 54668.4
= 1596.79Tf = 82781.8
= Tf = 82781.8 / 1596.79
= Tf = 51.8 Celsius

Pretty annoying but it get's the job done...anyone know a simpler way to do it? Thanks! :)

-K.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
9K
Replies
7
Views
2K