To grad school (for physics) or not to grad school?

In summary: If you can't find a research position, you may want to consider pursuing a Masters in Engineering instead.
  • #1
soothsayer
423
5
Hey PF!

So I just finished my undergrad degree in Astrophysics, and I'm interested in going back to get my PhD. I really love physics, and I don't mind the kind of grind and time that it would take to be a successful PhD student. I'm not looking to get higher paying jobs after I get my PhD, I really just want to put myself in a position to have a more exciting career in physics or physics-related industries. I'd be really interested in becoming a researcher, or maybe even a professor.

My problem is that I just don't think I did well enough for myself in my undergrad career to be able to have a very fruitful graduate career. I've already talked to a few guys with PhDs in Physics about grad school, and one thought it would be worth it for me to do, one was wary of the kind of opportunities that I'd have, and the programs I could get into, and one generally believed that grad school for physics was a scam and wouldn't really recommend it for anyone.

So, I don't know what to think. I graduated from a UC with about a 3.2, and my Physics GRE score was just around the 50 percentile. I plan on retaking the GRE, but I'm not sure I'll do much better, if at all. I know these numbers won't get me into a top-notch program, and I'm wondering if trying to get a PhD in the first place would be worth it to me at all. Many people have suggested getting a Masters in Engineering, but I'm not really sure I'd be interested in that at all.

What do you guys think?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Grad school is a big commitment. You're going to have to work for many years on the same or related problems. The only way to do that (if you want to remain sane) is to absolutely love the subject you're working on. In particular, you must like research somehow.

In your post, you're mentioning going to grad school to get better job opportunities. For sure, you will get a lot of better opportunities than you have only with a bacherlor in astrophysics. But I don't see many other motivations in your thread. So ask yourself why you want to do a PhD. Did you ever do research? Did you like that somewhat? Do you think you're going to like working for many years on the same thing? These are the most important questions right now.

If you don't like research, then you can still do a terminal masters in physics or engineering (or something else). This will still give you better job opportunities, but it wouldn't involve much research.
 
  • #3
Yes, I did do some research, and had to do a thesis as well, so I did spend some time researching one topic, and I greatly enjoyed it. It was kind thrilling to become adept at one subject in particular. I'm sure that it would have been less thrilling had I worked on a problem that I wasn't super interested in.

But then, that's another issue of mine: I'm not really sure what I would study. I really love astrophysics, and most of my research focused around that, and I'd love to continue down that path in grad school, but it seems like it could be a dead end unless I were really capable of getting an actual research position for astrophysics which seems...competitive, to say the least, and my credentials really aren't that impressive at this point. I'm also really interested in nuclear physics, which may be more broadly applicable, I don't know. Question being, is it more advisable to simply pick a field that most interests me, or should I also factor in more practical/realistic considerations?
 
  • #4
soothsayer said:
Yes, I did do some research, and had to do a thesis as well, so I did spend some time researching one topic, and I greatly enjoyed it. It was kind thrilling to become adept at one subject in particular. I'm sure that it would have been less thrilling had I worked on a problem that I wasn't super interested in.

But then, that's another issue of mine: I'm not really sure what I would study. I really love astrophysics, and most of my research focused around that, and I'd love to continue down that path in grad school, but it seems like it could be a dead end unless I were really capable of getting an actual research position for astrophysics which seems...competitive, to say the least, and my credentials really aren't that impressive at this point. I'm also really interested in nuclear physics, which may be more broadly applicable, I don't know. Question being, is it more advisable to simply pick a field that most interests me, or should I also factor in more practical/realistic considerations?

You should take both into consideration. Picking a field that is unpractical, is of no use. You'll be left with a PhD and not many job opportunities. Picking a field that is uninteresting to you is perhaps the worst thing you can do in grad school.

So if you think you'd enjoy nuclear physics, then that would be a good career option. You don't need to enjoy it as much as astrophysics, but that's ok. What matters is that you won't go crazy because you hate your research.
 
  • #5
Good to know. Thanks for the advice!
 
  • #6
The advice I always give regarding going for a PhD in physics is "if you have to ask, don't."

Job wise, you will assuredly be better off going to grad. school for engineering, or economics, or anything else with direct application to the business world. As the quote goes, "a PhD trains you for exactly one job, your adviser already has it, and he's better at it than you are." There are some physics disciplines where this isn't the case and the job prospects are better - but, if you're only doing this for the job prospects you shouldn't be in physics at all.
 

1. Should I go to grad school for physics?

This ultimately depends on your career goals and personal interests. Grad school can provide you with advanced knowledge and skills in the field of physics, and may open up opportunities for higher paying jobs or research positions. However, if your career goals do not require a graduate degree or if you are not passionate about pursuing further education in physics, then grad school may not be the best option for you.

2. How do I decide which grad school to attend?

There are several factors to consider when choosing a grad school for physics, including the program's reputation, faculty expertise, research opportunities, location, and financial aid options. It is important to research and visit different schools to get a sense of their culture and resources before making a decision.

3. What are the job prospects after grad school in physics?

Graduates with a degree in physics have a wide range of career options, including research positions in academia or industry, teaching, data analysis, and engineering. Job prospects may vary depending on the specific field of physics and the demand for that expertise in the job market.

4. How long does it take to complete a grad school program in physics?

The length of a grad school program in physics can vary depending on the type of degree and the student's rate of progress. Generally, a master's degree can take 2-3 years to complete, while a PhD program can take 4-6 years. This time frame may also be affected by factors such as research projects, exams, and thesis requirements.

5. Is it necessary to have a strong background in physics to attend grad school?

While a strong foundation in physics is certainly beneficial, it is not always a requirement for admission into a grad school program. Some programs may offer prerequisite courses for students who do not have a strong background in physics, and others may consider relevant coursework or experience in related fields. It is important to research the specific requirements of the programs you are interested in to determine if your background aligns with their expectations.

Similar threads

  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
3
Views
754
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
18
Views
1K
Replies
7
Views
616
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
17
Views
3K
Replies
15
Views
1K
Replies
8
Views
1K
Replies
8
Views
1K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
28
Views
2K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
24
Views
2K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
7
Views
1K
Back
Top