mfb
Mentor
- 37,374
- 14,208
Well, "every" is an exaggeration. Apart from that, it is true.fresh_42 said:This is simply not trueWhere are those costs not included? Every opponent of nuclear power makes sure they get overestimated as much as possible.
A typical example from Germany: We have a "Brennelementesteuer", a special tax specifically for fuel of nuclear power plants. This tax is included in the costs of nuclear power, although it is just a redistribution of money from the companies to the public. But it gets worse: some argue that the Brennelementesteuer could be higher, and then claim it would be a subsidy that the tax rate is not higher. This made-up subsidy is then also counted as cost of nuclear power.
Germany heavily subsidizes wind and solar power. Does this increase the cost of nuclear power? Obviously not, but someone found an argument for it: Mining and processing uranium and operating various systems in a nuclear power plant costs electricity, and those costs are taken from the German electricity mix, which includes wind and solar power. It also includes coal, which is then counted as CO2 emission from nuclear power.
If there is any possibility to add any amount of money to the cost of nuclear power, someone did that.
There is no need for either of them. Oh by the way, the Earth did a pretty good job of storing uranium for billions of years. Doing it even better than that is quite a high standard.fresh_42 said:Nobody on this planet can afford to a) build thousands of safe places for nuclear waste over and over again and b) guarantee to safely guard it for the next 40 billion years.
This is not a problem of cost, it is a problem of scale and the unclear way to quantify a possible damage in money.fresh_42 said:Nobody can afford to insure the risk of a major accident as it happened already twice in about 50 years since we started to use fission.
Nuclear power saves lifes and health compared to fossile fuels. The cost is negative.fresh_42 said:If you really price in these two factors of costs nuclear energy couldn't be afforded by anyone.