Trying to solve conservation of momentum problem

14 replies · 3K views · last reply
patric44
Messages
308
Reaction score
40

Homework Statement


its a nuclear physics problem :
a deuterium atom with energy 4Mev collides with a boron atom B5/10 in an elastic collision
producing an H1/1 and B5/11 ,the Q of the reaction = 9.23 Mev .
find the E,E' , the energy of the boron and the hydrogen
the unknowns :
E,E', theta of boron.

Homework Equations


the solution is in solving these three equation :
Three equations with square roots and cosine and sine terms, followed by 22E = 16 + 2E' - sqrt(96E'), in plain algebraic form.

The Attempt at a Solution


I first tried to get the third equation by eliminating the angle ##\theta##
then when trying to solve those three equations I get:
Handwritten derivation applying conservation of momentum to an elastic collision, with a scattering diagram showing incoming and outgoing particles at angles 30 and theta, and equations (1) to (4) with E4 = 4 and masses M1 = 1 and M2 = 11.
Handwritten derivation eliminating an angle from momentum conservation equations, ending in three numbered equations: 4 = sqrt(2E') cos 30 + sqrt(22E) cos theta, 0 = sqrt(2E') sin 30 - sqrt(22E) sin theta, and 22E = 16 + sqrt(2E') - sqrt(36E').
Handwritten derivation on lined paper: three momentum and energy equations, then a substitution step, ending with theta = sin^-1 of a fraction involving sqrt(2E') and sqrt(16 + sqrt(2E) - sqrt(6E')).
Handwritten notebook page showing a substitution step: a square-root expression equal to a square root of 16 plus 2E minus square root of 96E times cos of arcsin, followed by the words 'gets really complicated'. Below, on a separate sheet, handwritten 'it has to be another way'.


 
Last edited by a moderator:
guys i made a little mistake the third equation in my attempt sulould be 22E=16+2E'+... not (2E')^0.5
and for the other three papers also. you will understand when trying to solve it .
 
Your first page is ok, but you lose your way in trying to eliminate θ. What simple algebraic relationship is there between sin and cos?
 
here another attempt i almost done but it stil complicated ( i had solved millions of equations ODE , PDE , vector calculus and many) but this
still got me :
Handwritten-style typed derivation titled 'my attempt of a solution' reducing three equations with sqrt(2E') and sqrt(96E') terms to a single equation in theta, ending with 4 = sqrt(6E'/2) + sqrt(16 + 2E' - sqrt(96E')) cos(sin^-1 ...).
Handwritten-style typeset derivation: notice cos(sin^-1 x) = sqrt(1 - x^2), so 4 = sqrt(6E'/2 + sqrt(16 + 2E' + sqrt(96E'))) * [1 - sqrt(2E') / (2 sqrt(16 + 2E' - sqrt(96E')))]^2.
 
there is a lot of trigonometric identities but i don't know which one to use :
the one that i used in getting the third equation (sin^2+cos^2=1)
those three equation is correct i checked it :
Three equations with square roots and trigonometric terms: 4 = sqrt(2E') cos(30) + sqrt(22E) cos(θ), 0 = sqrt(2E') sin(30) − sqrt(22E) sin(θ), and 22E = 16 + 2E' − sqrt(96E').


may be i sould use :
(cos2theta = 1-2sin^theta)

haruspex said:
Please try to answer my question in post
do you have particular one in mind
 
I suspect that your set of three equations are not independent, and I'm rather unclear on how you arrived at the third equation. Some annotation of your math would be nice. I also don't see where you've incorporated the Q of the nuclear reaction. Surely that must be an important contribution to the post-collision KE.
 
gneill said:
I suspect that your set of three equations are not independent, and I'm rather unclear on how you arrived at the third equation. Some annotation of your math would be nice. I also don't see where you've incorporated the Q of the nuclear reaction. Surely that must be an important contribution to the post-collision KE.
first thanks for responding
what you mean that the equations is not independent ?

in the book that contain that problem (which is a very sick book) has a very
breif solution goes like that :
1-by squaring and summing and eliminating theta we get ( the third equation)
2- by substituting in 1,2 equations we get (E=3.06 and E' = 10.17)
just like that (not a single step)

the third equation derivation i came up with my self :
Handwritten derivation of momentum conservation equations: 4 = sqrt(2E') cos30 + sqrt(22E) cos theta, sqrt(2E') sin30 = sqrt(22E) sin theta, squaring and summing to 22E = 16 + 2E' - sqrt(96E').


the Q also mentiend in the book that its equal 9.23Mev
my only problem is in solving those three equations
 
patric44 said:
the third equation derivation i came up with my self :
So it is based on the two existing momentum equations, hence it contains no new information. That means it is entirely dependent on the other two equations. The set of three equations is not a set of independent equations, and you can't use them to solve for all three variables.

You need to incorporate the Q information. You've written two momentum equations and that's all the information you can get from that. What other conservation law can you apply?
 
but in the book its said by subsituting of the third equation in 1,2
i forgot to mention that :
E+E'= 4+9.23 = 13.23Mev
which i tried to sole in it but got wrong answers
 
patric44 said:
but in the book its said by subsituting of the third equation in 1,2
I suspect that the book is incorrect on that point, and that was not how the problem was solved.
i forgot to mention that :
E+E'= 4+9.23 = 13.23Mev
which i tried to sole in it but got wrong answers
I think what the book's author actually did was use the third equation (which eliminated θ) and the energy equation above to solve for E and E'. Then θ can be found using either of the first two equations.
 
i think some thing is wrong in the third equation in the book
becouse i tried to plug E' = 10.17 i don't get E = 3.06 as mentiend in the book
 
patric44 said:
i think some thing is wrong in the third equation in the book
becouse i tried to plug E' = 10.17 i don't get E = 3.06 as mentiend in the book
That's possible. I also didn't follow your derivation of that equation, as you seemed to come to the conclusion that sin(θ) was zero for reasons I couldn't see. Work with the first two equations and the Q equation.
 
patric44 said:
there is a lot of trigonometric identities but i don't know which one to use :
the one that i used in getting the third equation (sin^2+cos^2=1)
those three equation is correct i checked it :
View attachment 197371
in that case I misunderstood your issue. I thought the book had obtained the third equation from the first two and you were trying to emulate that.

So now it looks to me that your first two equations are momentum equations, and deriving the third is a good move. But now you need to combine this with an energy equation. You are given the net change in energy.