- #1

- 108

- 0

## Main Question or Discussion Point

I'm trying to understand the true meaning of limits. But a doubt occured me...

Limits try to tell us the behavior of a function near a particular input, right? Ok...

So:

[tex]\lim_{x \to 0^{+}}{1\over x} = \infty[/tex]

[tex]\lim_{x \to \infty}{1\over x} = 0[/tex]

These two limits are true, right? Ok...

So, by the first limit we can understand that when x tends to 0, 1/x tends to infinity... x will never be zero and 1/x will never be infinity, but for us to get this result in the limit we SUPPOSE that if x would be 0 when 1/x would be infinity. The same thing for the other limit. Am I right? If yes...

So then a limit is a supposition, limits are not "real" (?) because they're a supposition. So what happens to all the things discovered using limits? Are they suppositions too?

Derivatives are defined as a limit when deltaX goes to 0. How can the derivative represent the REAL slope of the line if limits are not real (are only supposition)?

Maybe I was doing a lot of confusion with these concepts, could someone give me a light please?

Thank you,

Rafael Andreatta

Limits try to tell us the behavior of a function near a particular input, right? Ok...

So:

[tex]\lim_{x \to 0^{+}}{1\over x} = \infty[/tex]

[tex]\lim_{x \to \infty}{1\over x} = 0[/tex]

These two limits are true, right? Ok...

So, by the first limit we can understand that when x tends to 0, 1/x tends to infinity... x will never be zero and 1/x will never be infinity, but for us to get this result in the limit we SUPPOSE that if x would be 0 when 1/x would be infinity. The same thing for the other limit. Am I right? If yes...

So then a limit is a supposition, limits are not "real" (?) because they're a supposition. So what happens to all the things discovered using limits? Are they suppositions too?

Derivatives are defined as a limit when deltaX goes to 0. How can the derivative represent the REAL slope of the line if limits are not real (are only supposition)?

Maybe I was doing a lot of confusion with these concepts, could someone give me a light please?

Thank you,

Rafael Andreatta

Last edited: