Understanding Escape Velocity and Gravitational Potential Fields

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around the concept of escape velocity and gravitational potential fields, specifically questioning the conditions under which an object can leave Earth's gravitational influence. Participants explore the implications of constant velocity versus escape velocity in the context of gravitational forces.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants question the nature of escape velocity and its necessity for leaving a gravitational field. Some discuss the effects of constant thrust versus initial velocity, while others explore the concept of gravitational influence from other celestial bodies.

Discussion Status

The conversation has led to various interpretations of escape velocity and its practical implications. Some participants have provided clarifications on the relationship between thrust and velocity, while others have pointed out the complexities of gravitational fields at different altitudes.

Contextual Notes

There are ongoing discussions about the limitations of escape velocity in real-world scenarios, including the influence of other gravitational fields and the mathematical concept of limits in relation to gravitational pull.

perfectz
Messages
60
Reaction score
0
Though my question is stupid, please help me out...

Why can't I get out of the gravitational potential field without the escape velocity?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Escape velocity is not a thing. It is soft of a barrier...you need to cross it escape to "infinity." You wouldn't have sufficient kinetic energy to do that if your velocity were any less.
 
Do you understand what escape velocity means? Perhaps you can rephrase your question.
 
Ok then ...

If I travel at a constant velocity of 300 km/hr I am just going to keep on moving up.
When we throw a ball, I don't think we are imparting escape velocity to it. But still it goes up and reaches 0 velocity and comes back again, and that's because there's no constant thrust.
So when I am giving a constant thrust of 300 km/hr, even if its going to take a hell of days for me, won't I be out of the Earth's gravitational field.
 
perfectz said:
Ok then ...
If I travel at a constant velocity of 300 km/hr I am just going to keep on moving up.
No, you will not, at least not from the Earth. The escape velocity for the Earth is around 11km/s.

When we throw a ball, I don't think we are imparting escape velocity to it. But still it goes up and reaches 0 velocity and comes back again, and that's because there's no constant thrust.

You can't impart escape velocity.
So when I am giving a constant thrust of 300 km/hr, even if its going to take a hell of days for me, won't I be out of the Earth's gravitational field.

Thrust is force
300km/hr is a speed.
 
"Escape velocity" is the speed you have to give to a projectile (no power source or thrust) so that it keeps going and doesn't fall back to earth. If you have a power source--riding a rocket, for example--then of course you can escape at a lower speed.
perfectz said:
If I travel at a constant velocity of 300 km/hr I am just going to keep on moving up.
Something must be applying an upward thrust on you to maintain that speed--otherwise you'll slow down and fall back to earth.
When we throw a ball, I don't think we are imparting escape velocity to it.
I certainly hope not!
But still it goes up and reaches 0 velocity and comes back again, and that's because there's no constant thrust.
Exactly. But if you threw it fast enough (ignoring air resistance for the moment) it wouldn't reach zero until it got infinity far away. That's the escape velocity.
So when I am giving a constant thrust of 300 km/hr, even if its going to take a hell of days for me, won't I be out of the Earth's gravitational field.
Sure. You can get as far away as you like.
 
thank you fellas
My doubt is cleared

and neutrino check out the last line of the mentors post...
 
Last edited:
one more thing,
even if you fire yourself with the escape velocity,
(in real life) you will get affected by gravitational fields of other masses close by, such as moon, other planets, stars...
therefore, (in reality) you cannot "go to" infinity even if you have that calculated escape velocity from the world
 
  • #10
perfectz said:
Ok then ...

If I travel at a constant velocity of 300 km/hr I am just going to keep on moving up.
When we throw a ball, I don't think we are imparting escape velocity to it. But still it goes up and reaches 0 velocity and comes back again, and that's because there's no constant thrust.
So when I am giving a constant thrust of 300 km/hr, even if its going to take a hell of days for me, won't I be out of the Earth's gravitational field.

The thing is, escape velocity deceases with altitude. The escape velocity at sea level is greater than that at say 200 miles up. As you continue your climb upward at 300 km/hr, eventually you will reach an distance from the Earth where the escape velocity will be less than 300 km/hr.
 
  • #11
you cannot really escape from Earth's gravitational field unless you reach infinity which you cannot. there will always be a distance between you and the Earth which will make the gravitational field go smaller and smaller as you go away. but it will never actually be zero (it is the basic idea of a mathematical limit)
also, even giving an object enough trhust to keep it moving at 0,000000001 m/s
constant speed will keep it moving to infinity.

the escape speed is the minimum speed you give an object right at the surface of another big object (in this case it is the earth) to send it infinitely away from the other object. But with this concept, you fire the thing and let it go. If you apply a thrust, you need to take that energy you are putting into the system into consideration.
as I said if you apply a constant thrust that is able to lift it at the surface with a slight speed, it can "make it to infinity" :smile:
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 17 ·
Replies
17
Views
3K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
3K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 27 ·
Replies
27
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
1K