Understanding Gravitational Field Lines Between Two Objects

5 replies · 4K views · last reply
TalliThePrune
Messages
11
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


"Complete the diagram to display gravitational field lines between two objects of equal mass."
Two hand-drawn point-centred sketches, each a star of about sixteen straight radial lines meeting at a central dot, drawn on grey paper.

Homework Equations


N/A as question is descriptive.

The Attempt at a Solution


Okay, I know it's a bit of a mess but what I'm trying to show here is that the fields are radial and each mass attracts the other with equal force. Is this correct?
Handwritten pencil sketch of two equal masses, each drawn as a dark dot with many straight radial field lines pointing outward, with arrowheads on some lines between them.


If not, please point me in the right direction.

Many thanks!

- Talli
 
Hm, have you ever seen a picture of electric field-lines between two opposite charges? If there is no outer gravitational field I believe the two masses should yield a similar result. (Coulomb'ss law and Newton's law of gravitation is very similar in structure!). :)
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: TalliThePrune
Alettix said:
Hm, have you ever seen a picture of electric field-lines between two opposite charges? If there is no outer gravitational field I believe the two masses should yield a similar result. (Coulomb'ss law and Newton's law of gravitation is very similar in structure!). :)

Yeah, I've just been doing questions on that actually! :smile:

Clearly my sketch isn't the best, I meant it to look similar to this electric field diagram except with arrows pointing at both masses (instead of one way towards the negative/away from the positive). I just can't seem to find any visual representations of two masses online.

Thanks for the answer.
 
TalliThePrune said:
Yeah, I've just been doing questions on that actually! :smile:

Clearly my sketch isn't the best, I meant it to look similar to this electric field diagram except with arrows pointing at both masses (instead of one way towards the negative/away from the positive). I just can't seem to find any visual representations of two masses online.

Thanks for the answer.
This is the electric field image you mentioned:
Electric field diagram of a positive charge (red, marked +) on the left and a negative charge (blue, marked −) on the right, with curved field lines arrowed from + toward − and arrows indicating direction.


Alettix has basically a good idea in that you might consider electric field lines for a case in which point charges in an electric field will behave in a manner analogous to the behavior of point masses in a gravitational field. However, her suggestion to look at the field lines produced by opposite charges may not be what is needed.

This analogy is complicated by the fact that mass has no sign. All mass force is attractive. How do you determine the direction of a force field? Place a test charge (or test mass) at some location and determine the direction of the force exerted on or test charge (or mass) .

We are not particularly interested in whether the two objects producing the field attract each other or repel each other.

Show that the two proposed configurations are not analogous.

How can that be rectified?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Alettix and berkeman
Imagine that for grater distance the field of two masses must be like as one mass field.
 
TalliThePrune said:

The Attempt at a Solution


Okay, I know it's a bit of a mess but what I'm trying to show here is that the fields are radial and each mass attracts the other with equal force. Is this correct?
Hand-drawn sketch of two radial clusters of field lines, one on the left and one on the right, with several small arrowheads placed between them along the horizontal axis; the drawing is in pencil on blue paper.

You placed the arrows nearly correctly, and you are right, the field lines are radial, but only very near to one mass. But you know that the total field is the vector sum of the fields of the individual masses. So what is the direction of the resultant field lines along the symmetry axis (the perpendicular bisector) of the two masses? At A, for example? And what is the net field acting on a small mass at point B?
Diagram of two radial star-like patterns of lines on a grey background, with a red vertical line between them labelled with points A (above) and B (below), a blue line connecting the two centres, and green dots marking A and B.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: TalliThePrune