Understanding Snapshot and History Graphs for Waves

11 replies · 37K views · last reply
bcjochim07
Messages
366
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Snapshot graph of a wave at t = 2 s, plotting D (cm) against x (m) from -1 to 7 m, with a triangular pulse peaking at 1 cm near x = 1 m and returning to zero near x = 5 m; a green arrow labelled 1.0 m/s points left.
figure is asnapshot.jpg
Two displacement-time graphs labelled wrong (top) and right (bottom), with axes marked 1cm and t (sec); the right graph is a triangular pulse dipping below zero near t=3 s and peaking near t=6 s, then returning to zero.
correct & incorrect graphs is aasnapshot.jpg

Draw the history graph D(x=0m, t) at x= 0m for the wave shown in the figure.

Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution



I'm not quite understanding the concept of snapshot and history graphs. I think for this one the problem is that is is moving left. The graph that I drew is the wrong one. Here was my reasoning: In the figure, the graph is moving left, so shouldn't the leftmost point on the wave hit the point first? If at t=2 s this leftmost point is 1m away from x=0, then it takes 1 sec for it to arrive, so at t=3. I don't think I am visualizing this at all correctly. Could someone please explain to me why the graph on the bottom is correct? Thanks!
 
I am confused and this is really bothering me.
 
bcjochim07 said:

The Attempt at a Solution



I'm not quite understanding the concept of snapshot and history graphs. I think for this one the problem is that is is moving left. The graph that I drew is the wrong one. Here was my reasoning: In the figure, the graph is moving left, so shouldn't the leftmost point on the wave hit the point first?
Yes.

If at t=2 s this leftmost point is 1m away from x=0, then it takes 1 sec for it to arrive, so at t=3.
Yes, nothing happens (at x=0 m) until t = 3 sec.

I don't think I am visualizing this at all correctly. Could someone please explain to me why the graph on the bottom is correct? Thanks!

It's not correct. At x = 0, D is 0 until t=3 sec. The graph labeled "wrong" looks like the right one to me.
 
Yeah, see I'm having problems because there are a couple problems like this in my textbook where my drawings are completely off from what the back of the book has, so I was worried that I was not understanding this at all.
 
My answer is the same as the original poster's..please, what are we doing wrong?!??!
 
Welcome to Physics Forums :smile:

You and the OP did it right, the book has it wrong.

What is the name of this book and its author?
 
The book's called Physics for Scientists and Engineers: A Strategic Approach (2nd ed.), Vol 3, and the author is Randall D. Knight. I also got the same answer as the OP. So the book is wrong and the OP is right?
 
Welcome to PF :smile:

Klorey said:
The book's called Physics for Scientists and Engineers: A Strategic Approach (2nd ed.), Vol 3, and the author is Randall D. Knight. I also got the same answer as the OP. So the book is wrong and the OP is right?
You are correct.

And thank you for answering my question :biggrin:
 
I have the 6th edition of this book and the answer in the answer key is still wrong...