Using Macaulay's method of deflection on a cantilever beam

6 replies · 5K views · last reply
Kyle Grayston
Messages
6
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Figure 3: cantilever beam fixed at a wall on the left, with a 6 kN point load downward at 1000 mm and a 6 kN point load downward at the free end region, a uniformly distributed load of 8 kN/m over 900 mm, and total length 2.4 m with origin marked at the free end.

i) Determine the slope of the beam 1m from the wall.
ii) Calculate the deflection at the free end of the beam.

Homework Equations



Macauly's method of deflection: M = -RX + W[X-a]
Integrate once for slope
Integrate twice for deflection

The Attempt at a Solution



Handwritten derivation on lined paper using Macaulay's method for a cantilever beam: beam diagram with 6 kN loads and a uniform load, followed by moment, slope and deflection equations, constants found, and final deflection values.
[/B]
It is my understanding that a positive deflection is downwards and a negative deflection is upwards.

I am getting a negative answer for the slope which would indicate an upwards slope?

When I use my initial equation to calculate the moment before integrating, I get the correct moment value (27.84kNm) so I feel like that is correct, I am worried that maybe some of the values in my equation should be negative which would change the value of my constants A and B.

Any help would be greatly appreciated.
 
Attachments
  • Figure 3: cantilever beam fixed at a wall on the left, with a 6 kN point load downward at 1000 mm and a 6 kN point load downward at the free end region, a uniformly distributed load of 8 kN/m over 900 mm, and total length 2.4 m with origin marked at the free end.
    AUAELH9.jpg
    22.5 KB · Views: 1,761
  • Handwritten derivation on lined paper using Macaulay's method for a cantilever beam: beam diagram with 6 kN loads and a uniform load, followed by moment, slope and deflection equations, constants found, and final deflection values.
    o3OiR4T.jpg
    20.6 KB · Views: 1,625
Your hand drawn diagram does not match the printed one. You have 0.5m to the first load where the printed diagram has 1m.

Also, shouldn't there be a torque and vertical force from the support in the expression for M?
 
haruspex said:
Your hand drawn diagram does not match the printed one. You have 0.5m to the first load where the printed diagram has 1m.

Also, shouldn't there be a torque and vertical force from the support in the expression for M?

Hi, sorry I've drawn the beam out mirrored as I was trying to compare it to a similar one done in class. My diagram is shown with the fixed end on the right.

There is 19.2kN reaction force at the fixed end, I am just not sure whether this is incorporated into the equation.
 
Kyle Grayston said:
My diagram is shown with the fixed end on the right.
Ok, so you are measuring x from the free end, but the question asks for the slope 1m from the wall, and you have substituted x=1.
Also, viewed from the free end, your loads will have clockwise moments, so should have negative torques. That is why you got a negative slope.
 
Ah yes, I see where I have put the incorrect x value in, thanks!

As for the negative slope, is this what you mean by having a negative slope when looking at the free end?

Handwritten sketch of a cantilever beam with a fixed support on the left and a free end on the right, a 1 m span marked between them. A slope tangent at the free end is labelled -ve, and a tangent further along the curve is labelled +ve.
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten sketch of a cantilever beam with a fixed support on the left and a free end on the right, a 1 m span marked between them. A slope tangent at the free end is labelled -ve, and a tangent further along the curve is labelled +ve.
    woEfKLz.jpg
    13.8 KB · Views: 851
Kyle Grayston said:
As for the negative slope,
Ignore what I wrote before... not saying it was wrong, but here's a simpler way..
A downward force left of x leads to an anticlockwise torque at x and makes a negative contribution to y". So if you are taking torques as positive clockwise then your M=... equations are correct but y"=-kM.
 
Ah I see what you're saying, that makes more sense. Thanks very much for your help, I really appreciate it.