Using Wolfram Alpha to Create Truth Tables for Logical Statements

15 replies · 4K views · last reply
Myimposter
Messages
6
Reaction score
2

Homework Statement


[/B]
"Use the truth table method in Boole to determine whether the conclusion is a tautological consequence of the premises."

(Tet(a) ^ Small(a)) v Small(b)
------
Small(a) v Small(b)

Homework Equations


[/B]
Taller(claire,max) v Taller(max,claire)
Taller(claire,max)
--------
~Taller(max,claire)

Was set up like this and correct...

Taller(claire,max) | Taller(max,claire) [ ] Taller(claire,max) v Taller(max,claire) | Taller(claire,max) | ~Taller(max,claire)

The Attempt at a Solution


[/B]
I am having trouble setting up the truth table.
 
Attachments
  • Screenshot of the Boole truth table tool showing the columns (Tet(a) ∧ Small(a)) and Small(b) with T and F rows, and a second table with columns Small(a), Small(b) and Tet(a) partly filled in.
    IMG_0665(1).jpg
    70.1 KB · Views: 872
  • Printed textbook exercise 4.20: a tautological consequence check with premise (Tet(a) ∧ Small(a)) ∨ Small(b) and conclusion Small(a) ∨ Small(b), separated by a horizontal line; the exercise instructions are shown above.
    IMG_0666(1).jpg
    34.1 KB · Views: 743
Last edited:
Myimposter said:

Homework Statement


[/B]
"Use the truth table method in Boole to determine whether the conclusion is a tautological consequence of the premises."

(Tet(a) ^ Small(a)) v Small(b)
------
Small(a) v Small(b)

Homework Equations


[/B]
Taller(claire,max) v Taller(max,claire)
Taller(claire,max)
--------
~Taller(max,claire)

Was set up like this and correct...

Taller(claire,max) | Taller(max,claire) [ ] Taller(claire,max) v Taller(max,claire) | Taller(claire,max) | ~Taller(max,claire)

The Attempt at a Solution


[/B]
I am having trouble setting up the truth table.
Welcome to the PF.

Wowie, that notation is a bit foreign to me. What class is it from? It looks like it deals with the height of Claire and Max, but I'm having trouble parsing what you have posted.

Can you explicitly list each premise?

Can you explicitly indicate the conclusion?

What would the independent variables and the dependent variables be in the Truth Table?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: FactChecker
Thanks for the reply. The course is Intro to Symbolic Logic.
Basically, I need to make a Truth Table in a program called Boole.

(Tet(a) ^ Small(a)) v Small(b)
------
Small(a) v Small(b)
kGJHZ6


h4PPE6
 
The image links don't seem to be working. Can you use the UPLOAD button in the lower right to upload PDFs or JPEG images that you want to post? Thanks.
 
The way I have it set up in the pic is incorrect.
 
Attachments
  • Screenshot of a truth table in a logic software window, with columns for Small(A), Small(B) and Total(A ^ Small(A) ^ Small(B)) on the left, and Small(A), Small(B) and Total(A) on the right, filled with T and F values.
    IMG_0665.jpg
    9.6 KB · Views: 654
  • Photo of a textbook page showing exercise 4.20 with the instruction about truth tables for tautological consequence, and an argument with premise (Tet(a) ∧ Small(a)) ∨ Small(b) and conclusion Small(a) ∨ Small(b), circled in pen.
    IMG_0666.jpg
    34.3 KB · Views: 683
I also have questions about the problem. What is the definition of Tet, Small, Taller, and how is Taller relevant to the original problem statement of Tet and Small? None of this is standard terminology, so you should explain those terms and the problem.

If this problem needs specific knowledge of the program Boole, then can you give a reference to that program. I don't think it is well known.

PS. Please remember that we are not in the class you are in or reading the book that you are reading.
 
Myimposter said:
The way I have it set up in the pic is incorrect.
"So which is it young fella? if'n we get down on the floor, we'll be a movin', and if'n we don't move, we can't get down on the floor!"

Quiz Question #1 -- What movie is that from?:smile:

Quiz Question #2 -- What the heck are you asking, son? :smile:
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: FactChecker
berkeman said:
"So which is it young fella? if'n we get down on the floor, we'll be a movin', and if'n we don't move, we can't get down on the floor!"

Quiz Question #1 -- What movie is that from?:smile:
Ha! Hint -- "Son, you've got a panty on your head."
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: berkeman
Thank you very much for the replies. The "Taller max" problem i have correct, i was just mentioning it as a reference. I am including a pic of the Taller max question and solution. I need to know how to set up a truth table for..

(Tet(a) ^ Small(a)) v Small(b)
------
Small(a) v Small(b)Thank you.
 
Attachments
  • Photo of a printed textbook page showing exercises 4.21 and 4.24 with a proof: premises Taller(claire, max) or Taller(max, claire) and Taller(claire, max), conclusion not Taller(max, claire), with handwritten circles and annotations.
    taller.jpg
    46.6 KB · Views: 701
  • Screenshot of the Tarski's World software showing a truth table with columns for Taller(claire,max), Taller(max,claire), their disjunction, and a negation, with T and F values and check marks in some cells.
    IMG_0669.jpg
    71.4 KB · Views: 726
  • Textbook exercises 4.20 to 4.24 on truth table arguments, with premises above a horizontal rule and conclusions below. 4.20: (Tet(a) ∧ Small(a)) ∨ Small(b) entails Small(a) ∨ Small(b). 4.21: Taller(claire, max) ∨ Taller(max, claire), Taller(claire, max) entails ¬Taller(max, claire).
    IMG_0670.jpg
    59.6 KB · Views: 745
I'm not familiar with Boole, so I will describe how it can be done by hand.

1) Start with 3 columns that have every possible combination of T and F for Tet(a), Small(a), and Small(b). There will be 8 rows, not counting the column headings. (Boole might auto-generate these columns for you. )
2) Add a column for Tet(a) ∧ Small(a)
3) Add a column for (Tet(a) ∧ Small(a)) ∨ Small(b)
4) Add a column for Small(a) ∨ Small(b)

Do you understand how use the table to tell if (Tet(a) ∧ Small(a)) ∨ Small(b) implies Small(a) ∨ Small(b)?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Myimposter and berkeman
Factchecker, this is Awesome! I think it’s exactly what I needed to know. I won't be in fron of Boole until tonight to be sure but I've done it on paper and it looks pretty close! Ill let you know how it goes!
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten truth table on lined paper with columns for Yacht(x), Small(x), Yacht(x) ∧ Small(x), (Yacht(x) ∧ Small(x)) ∨ Small(b), and Small(a) ∨ Small(b), each filled with rows of T and F values.
    5C0B3F9D-BF7A-4B57-888B-9610DF1ECE22.jpeg
    31 KB · Views: 715
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: FactChecker
This has been SOLVED with the help of Factchecker.

Thanks man!
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: FactChecker
Myimposter said:
"Use the truth table method in Boole
This technique is just called a truth table. It's confusing to say "in Boole".
Each row in a truth table lists one of the possible combinations of true or false (Boolean values) that a set of Boolean variables can have.
FactChecker said:
I'm not familiar with Boole
Refers to George Boole, after whom Boolean Algebra is named.
 
Mark44 said:
This technique is just called a truth table. It's confusing to say "in Boole".
Each row in a truth table lists one of the possible combinations of true or false (Boolean values) that a set of Boolean variables can have.
Refers to George Boole, after whom Boolean Algebra is named.
I assumed he was talking about the software program called Boole for truth table creation.
 
FactChecker said:
I assumed he was talking about the software program called Boole for truth table creation.
Didn't realize that there was such software. I didn't look at all of the attached images in this thread...
 
Just thought I'd mention that Wolfram Alpha will do truth tables for you.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: FactChecker