Vertical force on a hemisphere submerged in fluid

23 replies · 4K views · last reply
dodonaomik
Messages
16
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


My English of influid meachanics is poor, so I only can hope that
you can understand the figure (please forgive me!)

Hand-drawn diagram of a tilted hemispherical body below a free fluid surface, with a downward arrow labelled Fz, depth h, a dashed blue axis line, and 30 degree angles marked.

Please find the force Fz which the hemisphere endures

Homework Equations



My way: "on" the hemisphere, I want to use triple integral(but I'm not sure the way's right) and cut into the part into many innumerable tiny 3D right angled trapezoid
(i.g. KJPQ-K'J'P'Q')

Diagram of a submerged hemispherical body with a free surface line at top; vertical dashed projection lines drop from points K, J, P, Q to the curved surface at K', J', P', Q', and a depth marker h is shown.


Then I think that:
ρgV( the part + the hemisphere)=Fz

The Attempt at a Solution


Because my math is weak, I hope somebody can help me.
If you can understand the problem, please tell me whther my way or my calculation is right or not, thank you!

The following is my calculation.
Handwritten-style derivation of vertical force on a hemisphere: integral of trapezoid strip areas with rho g h terms, reducing to F_Z = rho g pi R^2 (h/4 + 2R/3).

ps: one integral
Handwritten-style calculus derivation on black background: integral of sqrt(R^2 - x^2) dx equals integral of R sqrt(1 - (x/R)^2) dx, substitution x = R sin t, reducing to (R^2/2)(arcsin(x/R) + (x/R)sqrt(R^2 - x^2)) evaluated from 0 to R, giving pi R^2/4.
 
Is this force due to the internal pressure in the drop?
If so isn't this pressure generated by the surface tension?
I assume the drop of liquid is in air, maybe hanging or falling?
Not sure we are able to solve this, just trying to understand the
problem that you are dealing with.
 
Last edited:
andrevdh, 1st thank you for your replying.
And you can imagine that one hollow hemisphere is located under one still river by 1 person.
Of course the hemisphere is fixed obliquely as in the fig( dip angle=30°).
 
dodonaomik said:
andrevdh, 1st thank you for your replying.
And you can imagine that one hollow hemisphere is located under one still river by 1 person.
Of course the hemisphere is fixed obliquely as in the fig( dip angle=30°).
Is this right...
This is a hollow sealed hemisphere being held immersed in a liquid. It is held at an angle. You want the force required to hold it down?
 
andrevdh said:
Is this force due to the internal pressure in the drop? ___NO____the water pressure(---->the hollow hemisphere) in a river
If so isn't this pressure generated by the surface tension?___NO____by the force of gravity of the water in a river
I assume the drop of liquid is in air, maybe hanging or falling?___NO____not in air but in a river
Not sure we are able to solve this, just trying to understand the
problem that you are dealing with.

Diagram of a hollow hemisphere lying in a river, with its flat circular face tilted and a dashed diagonal line through it, a water surface line above, and the label 'be fixed' at its curved base; a dashed line marked 30 degrees from the water surface.
 
haruspex said:
Is this right...
This is a hollow sealed hemisphere being held immersed in a liquid. It is held at an angle. You want the force required to hold it down?
Thanks for you replying.
The hemisphere is not sealed, :smile:in other words, the hemisphere isn't closed.And I want to know the force which the river water exerts to the hemisphere.
 
Additionaly I don't know whether my method is right or not.
(PP'Q'Q is an right angled trapezoid just the same as JJ'K'K)
 
Are you familiar with Archimedes principle? Does the vertical force exerted by the surrounding fluid on a submerged object depend on its depth or orientation?

Chet
 
Chestermiller said:
Are you familiar with Archimedes principle? Does the vertical force exerted by the surrounding fluid on a submerged object depend on its depth or orientation?

Chet
Thank you! I am not familiar with Archimedes' spiral, and I olny know it's equation.

Additionaly your reply is irrelevant to this post.
 
dodonaomik said:
Thank you! I am not familiar with Archimedes' spiral, and I olny know it's equation.

Additionaly your reply is irrelevant to this post.
I don't think so. The upward force is equal to the weight of the fluid that has been displaced by the hemisphere.

chet
 
Chestermiller said:
I don't think so. The upward force is equal to the weight of the fluid that has been displaced by the hemisphere.

chet
Sorry, I mixed up 2 concepts: Archimedes principle and Archimedes' spiral.

Now I really cannot understand it_____How the fluid can be displaced by the hemisphere?
 
dodonaomik said:
Thanks for you replying.
The hemisphere is not sealed, :smile:in other words, the hemisphere isn't closed.And I want to know the force which the river water exerts to the hemisphere.
If it's hollow and not closed, do we know the shell's thickness? If it has no thickness it displaces no volume, so there is no buoyancy.
Or... is this a question about hydrodynamics... force due to fluid flow over a surface?
 
dodonaomik said:
Sorry, I mixed up 2 concepts: Archimedes principle and Archimedes' spiral.

Now I really cannot understand it_____How the fluid can be displaced by the hemisphere?
The displaced volume of fluid is the same thing as the submerged volume of the body. So the force exerted by the fluid on the submerged body in the vertical direction is given by:
$$F=\rho g V$$
where ##\rho## is the density of the fluid, g is the gravitational acceleration, and V is the submerged volume of the body.

Chet
 
haruspex said:
If it's hollow and not closed, do we know the shell's thickness?
-----No, I feel we are not necessary to know the thicness. In other words, we in fact shouldn't concer the hemisphere shell's thicknessIf it has no thickness it displaces no volume, so there is no buoyancy.
----------I think we only know Fz(as in the fig.) and are unnecessary to know the buoyancy.Or... is this a question about hydrodynamics... force due to fluid flow over a surface?
_________NO, not hydrodynamics but hydraulics... force due to the still river water over the hemisphere shell

MY English about influid mechanics is weak, so please don't mind!
 
Chestermiller said:
The displaced volume of fluid is the same thing as the submerged volume of the body. So the force exerted by the fluid on the submerged body in the vertical direction is given by:
$$F=\rho g V$$
where ##\rho## is the density of the fluid, g is the gravitational acceleration, and V is the submerged volume of the body.

Chet
First thank you so much,
but I don't want to know the buoyancy(vertical upward), and I want to know Fz(vertical downward, as in the 1st fig.).
 
dodonaomik said:
we only know Fz(as in the fig.) and are unnecessary to know the buoyancy.
dodonaomik said:
ρgV( the part + the hemisphere)=Fz
Fz is what you are trying to find, no? So you do not know it.
ρgV is the buoyancy, but if the shell has no thickness and is full of water, V = 0.
 
dodonaomik said:
First thank you so much,
but I don't want to know the buoyancy(vertical upward), and I want to know Fz(vertical downward, as in the 1st fig.).
To get that, you need to know how much the hemisphere weighs. Is the hemisphere solid, or is it just a thin shell? If it is just a thin shell, then your downward force is equal to the upward force from this equation.

Chet
 
haruspex said:
Fz is what you are trying to find, no? So you do not know it.
ρgV is the buoyancy, but if the shell has no thickness and is full of water, V = 0.

I'm having trouble understanding what she's saying. I didn't think that there was water inside the body or shell. If there is, then the buoyant force is zero for a zero thickness shell. I feel like I'm preaching to the choir.

Chet
 
haruspex said:
Fz is what you are trying to find, no? So you do not know it.
ρgV is the buoyancy, but if the shell has no thickness and is full of water, V = 0.
IT'S true that we are unnecessary to know the shell's thickness.ρgV( the part + the hemisphere)=Fz
the part=the water on the hemisphere(at the moment, you can imagine that the hemisphere is sealed or closed.)
the hemisphere= the water in the hemisphere(at the moment, you can imagine that the hemisphere is sealed or closed.)
 
Chestermiller said:
To get that, you need to know how much the hemisphere weighs. Is the hemisphere solid, or is it just a thin shell? If it is just a thin shell, then your downward force is equal to the upward force from this equation.

Chet
In my opinion~~~~in my understanding, I really feel that we are unnecessary to know the weight of hemisphere and the thickness of shell of the hemisphere.And...yes! It's just a thin shell...a very thin shell... and we should ignore the thickness of the shell.

In fact I feel that Fz= the force of gravity of water "upward" and in the hemisphere
 
dodonaomik said:
In my opinion~~~~in my understanding, I really feel that we are unnecessary to know the weight of hemisphere and the thickness of shell of the hemisphere.And...yes! It's just a thin shell...a very thin shell... and we should ignore the thickness of the shell.

In fact I feel that Fz= the force of gravity of water "upward" and in the hemisphere
Neither Chet nor I can make any sense of the question. We see no reason why there should be a net force.
There must be some text associated with the question as presented to you. If it is not in English, please provide the best translation you can make yourself, as well as a translation through an online utility such as Google or Babelfish.
 
haruspex said:
Neither Chet nor I can make any sense of the question. We see no reason why there should be a net force.
There must be some text associated with the question as presented to you. If it is not in English, please provide the best translation you can make yourself, as well as a translation through an online utility such as Google or Babelfish.
Equipped with a D=1.2m diameter hemispherical cap in the circular oil depots inclined wall, hemispherical cap center point O, depth of H=4m in the page. Inclined wall and thelevel angle of α=30 degrees, there is the density of ρ=900kg/m^3. and total tensionbolts a, b.

Chalkboard-style diagram of an inclined oil tank wall with a hemispherical cap; center O at depth H = 4 m, angle α = 30°, and pressure labels ρg(H − R·sinα) and ρg(H + R·sinα) across the cap.

Handwritten derivation on a black board: Fx equals half of [rho g (H minus R sin alpha) plus rho g (H plus R sin alpha)] times 2R sin alpha times R, with R circled and a green arrow pointing to it; below, rho g H times 2R squared sin alpha, then 900 x 9.8 x 4 x 2 x 0.6 squared x sin 30, and the result 12700.8 N.

Handwritten free-body diagram on a blackboard of a hemispherical cap on an inclined wall, with a green box around the cap and a hatched fluid region, and a pressure triangle labelled pg(H-R.Sinα) beside a fluid-force arrow sketch.

Handwritten chalkboard derivation of the vertical force Fy on a hemispherical cap, with a notebook annotation in Chinese questioning whether the projected length should be R or 2R, plus the formula 2/3 pi R^3 for the hemisphere volume.
All above calculations are made my teacher!
But I cannot agree with him( I feel very puzzled with R circled by me)
 
Diagram of a hollow hemisphere tilted at 30 degrees, with its flat cut edge fixed at two points along an inclined line, partly in a river and partly in air; a downward force Fz is marked on the curved surface.


Maybe the above fig is more helpful to calculate Fz
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of a hollow hemisphere tilted 30 degrees below a horizontal water surface line, with a downward vertical force labelled Fz acting on its upper curved surface; the region above the surface is labelled in a river, and air is labelled on the other side, with the base marked be fixed.
    kkkk.JPG
    33.6 KB · Views: 501
dodonaomik said:
Maybe the above fig is more helpful to calculate Fz
Indeed it is, particularly the label "air".
Your challenge to the 'R' is in regard to Fx, not Fz. The part in square brackets (divided by 2) is the pressure at O, and by symmetry it is the mean pressure acting over the circular opening to the hemisphere. To get Fx, you want to find the effective area in a vertical plane. That will be sin(alpha) multiplied by the complete area. But what I see as wrong is that the complete area is written as 2R2 instead of ##\pi R^2##.
Your Fz corresponds to Fy in the later calculation. This calculation is the same, except that it's cos instead of sin, and you have to add the weight of the water in the hemisphere.