Virial temperatures - why does this equality hold?

  • Thread starter Thread starter gomboc
  • Start date Start date
Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
1 reply · 4K views
gomboc
Messages
38
Reaction score
0
I've done a problem which makes some basic assumptions about an gas of protons and electrons to find that given each electron or proton has kinetic energy [tex]KE = \frac{3}{4}m_p\sigma^2[/tex] and also that each particle has average energy [tex]\frac{3}{2}kT[/tex], then we can show that the temperature as

[tex]T \approx \frac{m_p \sigma^2}{2k}[/tex]

This is fine - it was easy enough to show. But the question asks to show that

[tex]T \approx \frac{m_p \sigma^2}{2k} = 5\times10^6 \left(\frac{\sigma}{3\times 10^5\ m/s}\right)^2[/tex]

I can't figure out why the right half of the equality is true. It's easy to test, but I can't seem to show why it might be analytically true. Note that [tex]\sigma[/tex] is the average particle velocity and [tex]m_p[/tex] is the proton mass.

Basically, I need to show why [tex]\frac{m_p}{2k} = 5\times 10^6 \cdot \left(\frac{\sigma}{3\times 10^5\ m/s}\right)^2[/tex] and I have no idea how to do that.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Hi Mr. gomboc,

This is how to procede:
  1. First convert the masse mp to MeV, divide it by the 2 and you'll get roughly 500 MeV.

    [itex]m_p/2 \approx500 MeV[/itex]

    for K:

    [itex]K_B\approx8.6*10^{-5}eV*Kelvin^{-1}[/itex]

    and for c:

    [itex]c\approx3*10^8 m/s[/itex]
  2. Separate the results into 5 MeV and [itex]100 /c^2[/itex]. Then put [itex]100 /c^2[/itex] into a fraction with [itex]ρ^2[/itex] and K. Rise up the square to the entire fraction.

    [itex]\frac{m_p*ρ}{K_B}\approx5 *10^6 eV*\left(\frac{10*ρ}{(3*10^8 m/s)*\sqrt{8.6*10^{-5}eV}}\right)^2[Kelvin][/itex]
  3. Simplify eV with eV and you will end up with the needed expression.

    [itex]T=5 *10^6*\left(\frac{ρ}{3*10^5}\right)^2[Kelvin]^*[/itex]

Notice that if you make the assumption that the gaz is degenerate, it allows you to find out the energy as:

[itex]E\approx K_B*T=\frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{ρ}{3*10^5}\right)^2 KeV[/itex]

If you deal with ultra-relativistic fermions then it gives:

[itex]E\approx\frac{1}{2} KeV[/itex]

which is clearly neglected in comparaison to the energy at rest of one electron:

[itex]E_{0e^+}= 512 KeV[/itex]

even more compared to that of a nucleon:

[itex]E_{0n}= 0.9 GeV[/itex]

It's interesting to put our results in contrast with observations. What happen in the core of a cooler white dwarf star is, with the decreasing of temperature, the core become thermically "static" because it's difficult to "squeech" the matter inside, without any internal heat provided by the fusion reactions of hydrogen. The star dies.


Sorry to be too explanatory. Good luck.


*Note: assuming that [itex]ρ[/itex] is in [itex]m/s[/itex]!