What are some recommended books for improving mathematical physics skills?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion centers around recommendations for books to improve skills in mathematical physics. Participants share their thoughts on various texts, their suitability for different levels of understanding, and the overall approach to learning mathematical physics. The scope includes theoretical foundations, mathematical methods, and practical applications.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • One participant lists a comprehensive selection of books, expressing uncertainty about which to start with given their current understanding of classical mechanics, electromagnetism, and quantum mechanics.
  • Some participants suggest that the goal of mastering mathematical physics in two years may be unrealistic, emphasizing the need for patience and a gradual learning process.
  • Another participant recommends starting with "A Guided Tour of Mathematical Physics" by Roel Snieder, noting its review of calculus and linear algebra concepts relevant to physics.
  • There is mention of "Mathematical Methods for Physical Sciences" by Mary Boas as an excellent resource to consider alongside Snieder's book.
  • Participants caution against rushing through the material, suggesting that a thorough understanding is more beneficial than adhering to a strict timeline.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree on the importance of a gradual approach to learning mathematical physics and express skepticism about the feasibility of mastering the subject within two years. However, there is no consensus on the specific order of the recommended books or the best starting point for a learner.

Contextual Notes

Some participants highlight the need for foundational knowledge in calculus and linear algebra before tackling more advanced topics in mathematical physics. There is also an acknowledgment of the subjective nature of book recommendations and the varying learning styles of individuals.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be useful for students or self-learners interested in enhancing their mathematical physics skills, particularly those seeking guidance on book selections and study approaches.

aLearner
Messages
25
Reaction score
0
So I really want to get good at mathematical physics. Below is a list of books I could get from various libraries, but I don't know which one's I should start with and which to do next and so on. I currently understand intro CM, EM, and QM. My math skills are very basic (ODES as of now). I thank you for your time.

Mathematical Physics :

1) Mathematical methods for physics and engineering - Riley, Hobson
2) Math methods in physics and engineering with Mathematica - F. Cap
3) Applied Mathematical Methods in Theoretical Physics - Masujima M.
4) A Guided Tour of Mathematical Physics - Roel Snieder
5) A Course in Modern Mathematical Physics - Groups, Hilbert
6) Equations of Mathematical Physics - Bitsadze A.V.
7) Mathematical Tools for Physics - J. Nearing
8) Mathematical Methods for Physicists - a Concise Introduction - T. Chow
9) The Fourier Transform And Its Applications - Bracewell
10) Calculus Of Variations With Applications To Physics & Engineering - R. Weinstock
11) Determinants and their applications in mathematical physics - Vein R., Dale P.
12) Geometry, Topology and Physics - M.Nakahara
13) Introduction to Groups, Invariants and Particles - F. Kirk
14) Differential Geometry - Analysis and Physics - J. Lee
15) Topology & Geometry in Physics - Steffen
16) Topology and Geometry for Physicists - C. Nash, S. Sen
17) Twistor Geometry, Supersymmetric Field Theories in Supertring Theory - C. Samann
18) Modern Differential Geometry for Physicists 2nd ed., - C. Isham
19) Mathematical Methods of Classical Mechanics, 2nd ed. - V.I. Arnold
20) Nonlinear Physics with Mathematica for Scientists and Engineers - R. Ennis, G. McGuire
21) Chaos - Classical and Quantum - P. Civitanovic
22) Chaos and Structures in Geophysics and Astrophysics - Provenzale & Balmforth
23) From calculus to chaos - Acheson
24) Mathematical topics between classical and quantum mechanics - Landsman N.P.
25) Methods of Modern Mathematical Physics Vol 1 - Functional Analysis 2nd. ed. - M. Reed
26) Methods of Modern Mathematical Physics Vol 2 - Fourier Analysis, Self Adjointness -2nd ed., - M. Reed
27) Methods of Modern Mathematical Physics Vol 3 - Scattering Theory - M. Reed
28) Methods of Modern Mathematical Physics Vol 4 - Analysis of Operators - M. Reed
29) Numerical Quantum Dynamics - W. Schweizer
30) Quantum Geometry - A Statistical Field Theory Approach - Ambje, Durhuus B., Jonsson T
31) Supersymmetric methods in quantum and statistical physics - Junker G.
32) Path integrals and their applications in quantum, statistical, and solid state physics - Papadopoulos , J. T. Devreese
33) Path Integrals in Physics Volume 1 Stochastic Process & Quantum Mechanics - M. Chaichian, A. Demichev
34) Path integrals in physics, vol.2. QFT, statistical physics and modern applications - Chaichian M., Demichev A.

also, feel free to modify the list in any way. I hope to dedicate two solid years on the subject, and at the end, be able to look at any physics branch and undertand the math behind it (even string theory).
-aLearner
 
Physics news on Phys.org
aLearner said:
I hope to dedicate two solid years on the subject, and at the end, be able to look at any physics branch and undertand the math behind it (even string theory).

You should realize that this is not possible in two years (or ever). So don't feel disappointed if you don't meet your goals in the end.
 
You have to be patient to learn physics. It won't happen overnight, so don't rush it. It always feels like you don't know enough and that will never go away, so you should just accept it. Haste makes waste. You don't want to spend too much time dwelling on things, either, but if you go too fast, it won't hang together and you'll be wasting your time.
 
aLearner said:
So I really want to get good at mathematical physics. Below is a list of books I could get from various libraries, but I don't know which one's I should start with and which to do next and so on. I currently understand intro CM, EM, and QM. My math skills are very basic (ODES as of now). I thank you for your time.

Mathematical Physics :

1) Mathematical methods for physics and engineering - Riley, Hobson
2) Math methods in physics and engineering with Mathematica - F. Cap
3) Applied Mathematical Methods in Theoretical Physics - Masujima M.
4) A Guided Tour of Mathematical Physics - Roel Snieder
5) A Course in Modern Mathematical Physics - Groups, Hilbert
6) Equations of Mathematical Physics - Bitsadze A.V.
7) Mathematical Tools for Physics - J. Nearing
8) Mathematical Methods for Physicists - a Concise Introduction - T. Chow
9) The Fourier Transform And Its Applications - Bracewell
10) Calculus Of Variations With Applications To Physics & Engineering - R. Weinstock
11) Determinants and their applications in mathematical physics - Vein R., Dale P.
12) Geometry, Topology and Physics - M.Nakahara
13) Introduction to Groups, Invariants and Particles - F. Kirk
14) Differential Geometry - Analysis and Physics - J. Lee
15) Topology & Geometry in Physics - Steffen
16) Topology and Geometry for Physicists - C. Nash, S. Sen
17) Twistor Geometry, Supersymmetric Field Theories in Supertring Theory - C. Samann
18) Modern Differential Geometry for Physicists 2nd ed., - C. Isham
19) Mathematical Methods of Classical Mechanics, 2nd ed. - V.I. Arnold
20) Nonlinear Physics with Mathematica for Scientists and Engineers - R. Ennis, G. McGuire
21) Chaos - Classical and Quantum - P. Civitanovic
22) Chaos and Structures in Geophysics and Astrophysics - Provenzale & Balmforth
23) From calculus to chaos - Acheson
24) Mathematical topics between classical and quantum mechanics - Landsman N.P.
25) Methods of Modern Mathematical Physics Vol 1 - Functional Analysis 2nd. ed. - M. Reed
26) Methods of Modern Mathematical Physics Vol 2 - Fourier Analysis, Self Adjointness -2nd ed., - M. Reed
27) Methods of Modern Mathematical Physics Vol 3 - Scattering Theory - M. Reed
28) Methods of Modern Mathematical Physics Vol 4 - Analysis of Operators - M. Reed
29) Numerical Quantum Dynamics - W. Schweizer
30) Quantum Geometry - A Statistical Field Theory Approach - Ambje, Durhuus B., Jonsson T
31) Supersymmetric methods in quantum and statistical physics - Junker G.
32) Path integrals and their applications in quantum, statistical, and solid state physics - Papadopoulos , J. T. Devreese
33) Path Integrals in Physics Volume 1 Stochastic Process & Quantum Mechanics - M. Chaichian, A. Demichev
34) Path integrals in physics, vol.2. QFT, statistical physics and modern applications - Chaichian M., Demichev A.

also, feel free to modify the list in any way. I hope to dedicate two solid years on the subject, and at the end, be able to look at any physics branch and undertand the math behind it (even string theory).
-aLearner

The books I have bolded are all excellent books IMO. Your book selection seems to be great already! I think Sneider is an ideal start as he reviews all calculus and Lin Alg concepts and then makes connections to physics. Also check out Mathematical Methods for Physical Sciences - Mary Boas. Another excellent resource. Maybe you can use Sneider and Boas in conjuction! Take heed however, go slowly and thoroughly; as micromass has suggested, 2 years seems too ambitious. Don't rush through it just because you need to meet the deadline.

Good Luck!

SolsticeFire
 
micromass said:
You should realize that this is not possible in two years (or ever). So don't feel disappointed if you don't meet your goals in the end.

homeomorphic said:
You have to be patient to learn physics. It won't happen overnight, so don't rush it. It always feels like you don't know enough and that will never go away, so you should just accept it. Haste makes waste. You don't want to spend too much time dwelling on things, either, but if you go too fast, it won't hang together and you'll be wasting your time.

SolsticeFire said:
The books I have bolded are all excellent books IMO. Your book selection seems to be great already! I think Sneider is an ideal start as he reviews all calculus and Lin Alg concepts and then makes connections to physics. Also check out Mathematical Methods for Physical Sciences - Mary Boas. Another excellent resource. Maybe you can use Sneider and Boas in conjuction! Take heed however, go slowly and thoroughly; as micromass has suggested, 2 years seems too ambitious. Don't rush through it just because you need to meet the deadline.

Good Luck!

SolsticeFire

micromass, homeomorphic, and solstice, thank you for the advice. And thanks for the organizational list solstice fire. Yes, I do have Mary Baos' Mathematical Methods ! How could I not after Taylor brags about it in his book a lot! But anyway, I think thread got me my answers, see you all in another webpage!
-Thanks again
 
I like very much the book "Mathematical methods of Physics" by Mathews and Walker.
I also second the suggestion that Solsticefire made about Boas' book. In fact starting with Boas' book and then moving further would be a good way to go.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
5K
  • · Replies 34 ·
2
Replies
34
Views
10K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 21 ·
Replies
21
Views
6K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
5K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
3K
  • Sticky
  • · Replies 33 ·
2
Replies
33
Views
12K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
4K