What does resultant impulse mean and how does it differ from impulse?

4 replies · 2K views · last reply
x2017
Messages
84
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement


Typed physics question 5: Karen pushes a 200 kg boulder for 10 seconds with an average force of 300 N; Annette pushes a 160 kg boulder for 25 seconds with an average force of 120 N. Parts a and b ask about impulse and resultant impulse when neither boulder moves.


Homework Equations


ΣFΔt = impulse
mΔv = momentum
ΣFΔt = mΔv

The Attempt at a Solution


Handwritten solution on lined paper for question 5a: Karen impulse = ΣFΔt = (300N)(10s) = 3000 Ns; Annette impulse = ΣFΔt = (120N)(25s) = 3000 Ns; followed by a note that both exert the same impulse and the boulders' weight does not affect the resulting impulse.


I got the first part of the question (I hope I did it correctly), I just don't understand what my professor means by resultant impulse... Do I use the same equation? Is it going to be the same as a) since the boulders aren't moving?
 
impulse is the change in momentum(FΔt=ΔP-Newtons 2nd law)
but here ΔP=0=impulse
 
akshay86 said:
impulse is the change in momentum(FΔt=ΔP-Newtons 2nd law)
To clarify, that is for the net (i.e. resultant) impulse.

@x2017 , in the first part, you are correct that they exert the same impulse, but your final sentence is wrong in referring to the weights of the boulders. Why did the boulders not move?
 
haruspex said:
To clarify, that is for the net (i.e. resultant) impulse.

@x2017 , in the first part, you are correct that they exert the same impulse, but your final sentence is wrong in referring to the weights of the boulders. Why did the boulders not move?
Hmmmm... because the force applied by each girl isn't great enough to overcome the force of friction acting on each boulder? (I expect this to be incorrect since friction isn't mentioned in he question at all, it's just the first thing that come to mind!)
 
x2017 said:
Hmmmm... because the force applied by each girl isn't great enough to overcome the force of friction acting on each boulder? (I expect this to be incorrect since friction isn't mentioned in he question at all, it's just the first thing that come to mind!)
We are not told which way they are pushing, but suppose it is horizontal. Neither are we told whether the boulders are simply lying on flat ground, but suppose they are. If there is no opposing horizontal force then the boulders must move. What could the opposing force be?
But you don't need to care what the opposing force is, you just need to deduce there is one. Weight acts vertically.