What happens when light is brought to an absolute stop?

  • Thread starter polaris12
  • Start date
21
0
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2010/06/100627072458.htm

According to the above article, light was brought to a complete stop during an experiment. What confuses me is that, if light has no mass, and is then manipulated to have no velocity either (which means there is no frequency and hence no energy) then what DOES it have? Does it even exist anymore? I did not understand this part of the article, and I would appreciate it if somebody could explain it to me.
 

Hurkyl

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
14,845
17
The fiction of light slowing down is probably not an intuitively useful abstraction at this point. Really, they just found way (an apparently very good way) to store the information in the light so that they can recreate it later.
 
206
28
Remeber, the light is not stopped in vacuum. What happens is actually that the state of the light is transferred to the atoms in a suitable prepared matter, which in this case is a rare-earth-ion-doped crystal.

One can also easily do slow light in these types of materials, where the light pulse is seen to be travelling slowly through the medium. One can show however, that in this case the energy of the light is only partially stored in the medium during the travel, and returned to the light as it exits. The slower you can get it to travel the more of the energy is transfered to the material, and in the special case of stopped light, everything is in the medium. The reason it's called stopped light is probably more historical (and because it sounds cool :biggrin: ).
 
868
3
(and because it sounds cool :biggrin: ).
:rolleyes: This is the source of a lot of confusion, sometimes even propagating among people who should know better. Sometimes such news articles even go so far I scratch my head and go: what the hell were they trying to claim? I tend to find the actual facts far more interesting, and intriguing when certain glossed over questions remain unanswered.
 
21
0
Oh, so its just a not-completely-true simplification of whats actually going on, which is that energy/information is being transferred into the material?
 
As light enters a transparent solid, it slows down and increases in frequency (in other words, its wavelength gets shorter).
If light slows down to a near-standstill, therefore, it would become extremely energetic.
 

Hurkyl

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
14,845
17
As light enters a transparent solid, it slows down and increases in frequency (in other words, its wavelength gets shorter).
It would take a strange material to change the frequency; normally it's held constant, while velocity and wavelength vary proportionally.

It's relevant to the topic to recognize that light slowing down is a fiction. Photons always move at the speed of light; but because they are constantly being absorbed and emitted, the progress of the (bulk of the) wavefront is delayed, and that's what is really meant by "light slows down".
 
95
1
It Photons always move at the speed of light; but because they are constantly being absorbed and emitted, the progress of the (bulk of the) wavefront is delayed, and that's what is really meant by "light slows down".
Is there any real evidence for this? I heard that how the photon slows down is actually not known.
 
206
28
It's relevant to the topic to recognize that light slowing down is a fiction. Photons always move at the speed of light; but because they are constantly being absorbed and emitted, the progress of the (bulk of the) wavefront is delayed, and that's what is really meant by "light slows down".
This is not entirely true.

Saying photons are constantly being absorbed and reemitted suggests a resonant phenomena, which is usually not the case. By tailoring the inhomogeneous profile for a material such as the one mentioned in the OP, one can create a situation where you have a strong dispersion profile (refractive index varies greatly with frequency), but zero absorption.

In this case the spectral components of a pulse going through the material sees different refractive indicies and when you sum up the movement of all spectral components, it is seen that the group velocity of the pulse is either slower of faster than c depending on the actualy shape of the dispersion curve.

The refractive index itself is of course due to light interacting with the atoms in the material, but it's very offresonant interaction so one should probably not call it absorption and emission, and in addition, no light is lost in the crystal, one can make 100% go through.
 

Related Threads for: What happens when light is brought to an absolute stop?

Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
190
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
859
Replies
3
Views
748
Replies
18
Views
4K

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving

Hot Threads

Top