What is the best conceptual electronics book for beginners?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around finding a suitable conceptual electronics book for beginners. Participants express a desire for resources that prioritize conceptual understanding before delving into mathematical explanations, covering various topics in electronics.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Technical explanation

Main Points Raised

  • One participant seeks a book that explains electronics concepts conceptually before introducing math, mentioning "All New Electronics Self-Teaching Guide" as a potential option.
  • Another participant suggests "Sedra Smith Microelectronics" for derivations of circuit equations and "Modern Physics" or "Solid State Electronics" for understanding biasing equations.
  • A different participant recommends the Malvino book as an excellent resource for beginners, emphasizing its ability to explain concepts without heavy reliance on math.
  • Concerns are raised about the necessity of math in understanding electronics, with one participant sharing their experience of struggling with math for years before realizing its importance.
  • Suggestions are made to explore books used in trade schools, as they may offer simpler explanations suitable for beginners.
  • Another participant mentions the Schaum's outline series for practice in solving circuit problems, indicating its usefulness alongside larger textbooks.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing opinions on the best resources, with no consensus on a single book. While some advocate for the Malvino book, others suggest alternatives like Sedra Smith and emphasize the importance of math in learning electronics.

Contextual Notes

Some participants note the varying editions of recommended books and the potential differences in content, which may affect their suitability for beginners. There is also mention of the need for practical problem-solving resources alongside theoretical texts.

PainterGuy
Messages
938
Reaction score
73
"conceptual" electronics book

Hello, :wink:

I have seen some books which do not explain give any conceptual background to electronics concepts. They use math to explain everything. I am in search of a book which first explains the concepts from conceptual point of view then comes to simple math content. The one I found on Amazon is:

All New Electronics Self-Teaching Guide (Wiley Self Teaching Guides) by Harry Kybett and Earl Boysen.

Please tell me of some good books so that I can make a choice. Many thanks for this.

Cheers
 
Physics news on Phys.org


PainterGuy said:
Hello, :wink:

I have seen some books which do not explain give any conceptual background to electronics concepts. They use math to explain everything. I am in search of a book which first explains the concepts from conceptual point of view then comes to simple math content. The one I found on Amazon is:

All New Electronics Self-Teaching Guide (Wiley Self Teaching Guides) by Harry Kybett and Earl Boysen.

Please tell me of some good books so that I can make a choice. Many thanks for this.

Cheers

Conceptual in what way?

If you mean you want derivations of the circuit equations you could pick up Sedra Smith Microelectronics.

If you mean you want to understand why biasing equations for op amps and transistors need to be there, you could pick up Modern Physics or Solid State Electronics books.
 


clope023 said:
Conceptual in what way?

Hello clope023, :smile:

I need a book which is aimed at readers with not very broad knowledge of electronics beforehand but still gives understanding and explains why and how things work. It should also cover topics such MOSFETs. Hope you understand it. Many thanks.

Cheers
 


Did you get the Malvino book? That one is as good as it get for beginner. I started my career with that book...from knowing next to nothing! You seem to going the same path as I was in the begining!

Yes most of the books use math to demo all the theories, that's another thing that you should start considering to enroll in. There is really no way out, I tried to avoid math for 20 years and you'll find you hit the wall in all direction sooner or later. In my old age, I actually stop and concentrated on calculus for two years to get up to snub. I just finished PDE last year and it really help!

From having two tall book case of electronics books mainly on RF and analog electronics, Malvino is the best first book I ever seen and I doubt you'll find another one that explain better without getting into math. If that is still too much math, you know what you need right now!

PS, make sure it's the same Malvino that I referred to you, don't want to scare you to death if we are talking about different books!


I don't think this place is the best place to get opinion on this. Go find out what books used in trade school like Heald College or ITT etc. They tend to teach people in a very simple way. I got the Malvino book from Heald College at the time. Next is to try junior college. They tend to use very simple book also. Get a few used book for cheap. No one book can be good in all subjects.
 
Last edited:


yungman said:
Did you get the Malvino book? That one is as good as it get for beginner. I started my career with that book...from knowing next to nothing! You seem to going the same path as I was in the begining!

Yes most of the books use math to demo all the theories, that's another thing that you should start considering to enroll in. There is really no way out, I tried to avoid math for 20 years and you'll find you hit the wall in all direction sooner or later. In my old age, I actually stop and concentrated on calculus for two years to get up to snub. I just finished PDE last year and it really help!

From having two tall book case of electronics books mainly on RF and analog electronics, Malvino is the best first book I ever seen and I doubt you'll find another one that explain better without getting into math. If that is still too much math, you know what you need right now!

PS, make sure it's the same Malvino that I referred to you, don't want to scare you to death if we are talking about different books!


I don't think this place is the best place to get opinion on this. Go find out what books used in trade school like Heald College or ITT etc. They tend to teach people in a very simple way. I got the Malvino book from Heald College at the time. Next is to try junior college. They tend to use very simple book also. Get a few used book for cheap. No one book can be good in all subjects.

Hello yungman, :wink:

Many thanks for reply and advice. I understand you. Really appreciate your suggestions.

Do you recognize this https://www.amazon.com/dp/0073222771/?tag=pfamazon01-20?

In which forum are you active? I was waiting that you will help me with some of electronic circuit problems. :rolleyes: Much grateful.

Cheers
 
Last edited by a moderator:


Sedra Smith's Microelectronics is a good book, though quite large so very long chapters but you'll learn with it.

For practice solving circuit problems I recommend the Schaum's outline series for Electric Circuits and Microelectronic Devices.
 


PainterGuy said:
Hello yungman, :wink:

Many thanks for reply and advice. I understand you. Really appreciate your suggestions.

Do you recognize this https://www.amazon.com/dp/0073222771/?tag=pfamazon01-20?

In which forum are you active? I was waiting that you will help me with some of electronic circuit problems. :rolleyes: Much grateful.

Cheers

I mainly over here, you can always PM me here and I'll try to help if I can.

No I don't recognize your Malvino book at all. Remember I read that book over 30 years ago. That must be the 1st or 2nd edition! It was a black and white print only.

Go look around to see whether you can find a cheaper used book. I never buy new books to save money. I am a self studier all these years, one big secret is buy a lot of books so if you get stuck on one, jump to the other and see whether they explain a little better. Go check in the trade school book store, I am sure students are eager to sell their used books after the semister ( don't know how big a mistake they are making!). Never sell your used books.

If you don't have Heald College in your area, check with the Heald in California, ask what book they use in the first course electronics involving transistors and op-amps. I really studied two of the books they used, one was Malvino and the other was digital electronics. Both were about the best book I ever seen so far. I really wish I keep those two. But I remember both by heart! I started my career with those two books! I am dead serious.
 
Last edited by a moderator:


yungman said:
I mainly over here, you can always PM me here and I'll try to help if I can.

No I don't recognize your Malvino book at all. Remember I read that book over 30 years ago. That must be the 1st or 2nd edition! It was a black and white print only.

Go look around to see whether you can find a cheaper used book. I never buy new books to save money. I am a self studier all these years, one big secret is buy a lot of books so if you get stuck on one, jump to the other and see whether they explain a little better. Go check in the trade school book store, I am sure students are eager to sell their used books after the semister ( don't know how big a mistake they are making!). Never sell your used books.

If you don't have Heald College in your area, check with the Heald in California, ask what book they use in the first course electronics involving transistors and op-amps. I really studied two of the books they used, one was Malvino and the other was digital electronics. Both were about the best book I ever seen so far. I really wish I keep those two. But I remember both by heart! I started my career with those two books! I am dead serious.

Many thanks yungman.:wink: And thanks for allowing me to PM you. It's in 8th edition now and also has a co-author David Bates. I think it's the same Malvino because it has very good reviews.

You wouldn't believe it. I still have some of my books from 2nd grade. Many thanks. And you are very nice, happy to interact with you.

Edit:-- Who was the author of that digital electronics book? Tell me please.

Cheers
 
Last edited:


PainterGuy said:
Many thanks yungman.:wink: And thanks for allowing me to PM you. It's in 8th edition now and also has a co-author David Bates. I think it's the same Malvino because it has very good reviews.

You wouldn't believe it. I still have some of my books from 2nd grade. Many thanks. And you are very nice, happy to interact with you.

Edit:-- Who was the author of that digital electronics book? Tell me please.

Cheers

I don't remember the name anymore. That is really not that important, at the time we still had to study basic gates, FFs type of primitive circuits, digital circuits change dramatically since 30 years ago. Usually digital stuff are easy and there are a lot of books written in easy language. So I don't think you'll have problem with those. It's the analog and RF that is much harder to get in. But remember, start studying math. While you can started with Malvino, but if you are going to be in this field, you are going to need it. I tried for 20 years without the first two semister of calculus and finally I had to give in and stop for 2 years to study the multi-variable, differential equation and partial differential equation. Those take time and you should study along with Malvino. You thank me for that in the future.
 
  • #10


Many thanks yungman. Someone also aid the book by Thomas Floyd Electronic Devices is also very good. It has very good reviews on Amazon too. Have you used it or know about it? Grateful for your advice on math.

Cheers
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
4K
Replies
25
Views
6K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
5K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
12K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
4K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
4K
Replies
29
Views
6K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
6K
Replies
3
Views
2K