What is the Correct Equation for Deviation by a Thin Prism?

2 replies · 34K views · last reply
shr
Messages
2
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


This really is not a Homework question, but I guess it fits in here. So, according to snell's law the ratio of sine of angle of incidence to the sine of angle of refraction is a constant called refractive index. But, in our textbook while deriving an expression for "Deviation by a thin prism", Snell's law seems to be used incorrectly. They have written "n = sin (refracted)/sin (incident)", which I do not understand, until now. Probably I'm wrong because I'm just a learner. Do you guys have any idea?

Homework Equations


A scan of the derivation, from our textbook:
Textbook page section 2.5 on deviation by a thin prism, with a ray diagram of a prism (Fig 2.6) showing incident ray P, refracted rays at faces Q and R, and emergent ray S; equations d = (i1 + i2) - A, A = r1 + r2, n = sin i1/sin r1 and d = A(n - 1) are printed, with a handwritten note questioning the sin i2/sin r2 ratio.

The Attempt at a Solution


I googled, but did not find anything interesting.
 
General expression for Snell's law is
n1*sini1 = n2*sini2 where 1 suffices indicates the incident medium and suffices 2 indicates refracted medium.
Now apply the law to the face AC of the thin prism ABC.
 
rl.bhat said:
General expression for Snell's law is
n1*sini1 = n2*sini2 where 1 suffices indicates the incident medium and suffices 2 indicates refracted medium.
Now apply the law to the face AC of the thin prism ABC.

RL, I figured it out myself after asking the problem:)

The root of the problem arose from our textbook. They had, at first defined refractive index as "sin i/sin r" but did not mention that it only holds good in the case where a light ray falls from air(n = 1) into another medium. That's where I fell :)

Thanks for your reply.